Skip to main content

Full text of "The Debatable Land: A Sketch of the Anglo-Spanish Contest for the Georgia Country"

See other formats


paveches 


UNIVERSITY 
OF THE PACIFIC 


Stockton, California 
95204 


Gift: of 


Mrs. Harry Noyes Pratt 


Digitized by the Internet Archive 
in 2024 


https://archive.org/details/debatablelandske0000mary 


Pay 


te 
—_ 


s¢ 


a 
1b 


“BISIOAL ‘SAIVI, “YS IvoU ‘UOISSIP, BIUV]T BJUBY JO SUINY 


THE DEBATABLE LAND 


A SKETCH OF THE ANGLO-SPANISH 
CONTEST FOR THE GEORGIA 
COUNTRY 


BY 
HERBERT E. BOLTON 
. AND 


MARY ROSS 


UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS 
BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA 
1925 


Bo bali! 


TMIBRAR ¥. i 
NOV 17 1965 


UNIVERSITY OF THE PACIFIC 


AUVABSSABBAASsVSSBseeSe 
Western 


Americana 


Pewaeesases 


; 
‘ 
; 
6 
= 


COPYRIGHT, 1925 
BY 
HERBERT E. BOLTON 


THE PUBLICATION OF THIS VOLUME 


WAS MADE POSSIBLE BY 


SIDNEY M. EHRMAN 


, 7 
ay Pg i. hy 
‘See Balt Ment 
: ik ys 


te 
¥ 


PREFACE 


or 6 
( Spain and Portugal effectively and permanently 
colonized the vast area from Chile to the West Indies 
and to the Rio Grande—two-thirds of the Western 
Hemisphere. The late-comers, England, Holland, and 
France, planted centers of expansion in the left-over 
areas to the northward. In her northern borderlands 
Spain’s activities were chiefly defensive. Foreign 
danger there forced her into several salients before she 
was ready to colonize them. The French intruded 
into the Caribbean, Florida, Louisiana, and Texas, and 
border contests ensued. As the English frontier moved 
westward, the Anglo-Spanish borders overlapped in a 
succession of areas, and one by one a series of conflicts 
resulted—in the Caribbean, in Georgia and Florida, in 

| Louisiana, in Texas, in New Mexico, in California. 
Anglo-American aggression stopped in each case when 
it reached the line of effective Spanish colonization. 
Together these border struggles constituted a drama 
covering two centuries. All the acts had features in 
common. But each had its own peculiar incidents and 
characters, and each made its particular contribution to 
the larger story of American history. | One episode in 
the long contest, brimful of human interest but as yet 
imperfectly understood, was Spain’s resistance to the 
English in the country that is now Georgia. This is 
the theme of the historical sketch here presented. 7 The 


[v] 


PREFACE 


survey was written as an introduction to Antonio de 
Arredondo’s Historical Proof of Spain’s Title to Georgia, 
just published by the University of California Press. 
It is here printed separately in the belief that it may 
interest a wider audience than the one which will wel- 
come the Arredondo document. 

Arredondo’s Demostracién Historiographica, as he 
called his essay, is an interesting and an important 
document, and its appearance creates a new interest in 
the early history of the Georgia borderland. It makes 
clearer than any other work hitherto published the 
nature of the long contest between Spain and England 
over the coast region of South Carolina and Georgia. 
It was written by a trained man who saw service on 
the disputed frontier as diplomat and soldier. In 1736 
Engineer Antonio de Arredondo was sent from Havana 
to Frederica to protest to Oglethorpe against the 
establishment of the Georgia colony. In succeeding 
years he served at intervals in Florida, drawing maps, 
writing reports, and perfecting the fortifications for the 
forthcoming struggle with England. In 1742 he was 
chief-of-staff in the Spanish campaign against Georgia. 
The Demosiracién Historiographica was dated just 
before that event, but the narrative terminates some- 
what earlier, with the diplomatic contests in 1736— 
1737. It was written at the request of Giiemes y 
Horcasitas, captain-general of Havana, who directed 
the Georgia expedition. 

The memoir brings into clear relief the following 
episodes in the early history of the South Atlantic 


[vi] 


PREFACE 


seaboard: (1) The planting of Spanish settlements on 
the Georgia-South Carolina coast, 1566-1670. (2) 
The founding of Charleston in 1670. (3) The treaty 
of 1670, by which Spain recognized the legality of 
England’s actual settlements in America (including 
Charleston) at that date. (4) The destruction of the 
Spanish settlements on the Georgia coast by English 
and Indian raids, 1670-1702. (5) The founding by 
Carolinians of Fort King George on the Altamaha in 
1721. (6) The diplomatic controversy in America and 
Europe following thereupon, 1721-1725. (7) The 
founding of Oglethorpe’s Georgia colony, 1733. (8) 
The resulting diplomatic controversy in America and 
Europe, 1736-1737 (the SAnchez-Oglethorpe treaty, 
the Arredondo episode, the Geraldino-Newcastle cor- 
respondence). 

Arredondo’s dissertation was in effect a reply to the 
English contentions brought forth in the two diplomatic 
controversies of 1721-1725 and 1736-1737. His argu- 
ment was essentially this: Spain had first claim to the 
South Atlantic coast by right of discovery, exploration, 
and occupation. Between 1566 and 1670 she main- 
tained actual settlements all the way up the Florida- 
Georgia-South Carolina coast between St. Johns River 
and Port Royal harbor. They were still occupied when 
Charleston was founded in 1670. In view of the fore- 
going, England’s claim to the disputed region on the 
basis of Cabot’s voyage, Drake’s raid, the Carolina 
charters, and the Indian grant of Santa Elena (Port 
Royal) to Dr. Henry Woodward, was baseless and 


[vii] 


PREFACE oy 


absurd. By the treaty of 1670 the principle ‘of actual 
possession was agreed upon by Spain and England; 
this compact legalized England’s ownership as far 
south as Charleston, and Spain’s as far north as Santa 
Elena Sound, in 32°, 30’ north latitude. Therefore, 
the subsequent English raids on the Georgia establish- 
ments, and all English settlements south of Charleston, 
were a violation of Spain’s rights based on actual settle- 
ment, and an infraction of the treaty of 1670. 

The editorial Introduction here reproduced is a brief 
sketch of the ground covered by Arredondo, broadened 
to include the Georgia back country and extended 
chronologically to 1763, the time when the Anglo- 
Spanish contest was ended by the cession of Florida to 
England. The sketch is the result of extensive inde- 
pendent investigation, based on both manuscript and 
printed sources. Although more comprehensive, and 
at many points more explicit, in the main it bears out 
the soundness of the historical portions of Arredondo’s 
account. é 

This contribution from the Pacific Coast to the 
history of the Atlantic Seaboard is a token of the unity 
of the story of all Spanish North America. In the olden 
time the Georgia country was one of Spain’s Northern 
Borderlands, linked by common ties with the whole 
frontier that stretched from the Caribbean westward 
to the Pacific Ocean. At the very time when Ogle- 
thorpe was invading Florida and Vernon was attacking 
the Isthmus, the Viceroy of New Spain was urging the 
defensive colonization of Tamaulipas, and taking 


[viii] 


PREFACE 


measures to protect the California coast and the 
Manila galleons against capture by George Anson. 

_ My own interest in the early history of the Carib- 
bean area and the “Old Southeast’? is one of long 
standing. In The Colonization of North America 
(Bolton and Marshall), this phase of American history 
was given new emphasis. Indeed, it was while at 
-work on that book, nearly ten years ago, that I first 
acquired and used the Arredondo manuscript. In the 
original draft of The Spanish Borderlands there was a 
* chapter on “The Anglo-Spanish Border,”’ which treated 
briefly the ground covered here in “The Debatable 
Land,” but it was finally cut to a few paragraphs for 
lack of space, according to the plan of the series in 
which the book appeared. For several years past, 
different students in my seminar have studied one or 
another subject in the field indicated. Three of these 
especially, Dr. William Edward Dunn, Miss Mary Ross, 
and Dr. James Guyton Johnson, have brought portions 
of their work to valuable fruition in published 
articles or books. 

In more recent years there has been a veritable 
renaissance of interest in the history of the “Old 
Southeast.” Dr. John R. Swanton has made excellent 
researches in the early history of the Creek Indians; 
Professor Verner W. Crane is shedding a flood of new 
light on the southward advance of the English border 
in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries; and Dr. 
Peter H. Guilday is admirably promoting the early 
Church history of the region. Especially notable is 


[ix] 


PREFACE 


the work now going on under the direction of the 
Florida State Historical Society. Through the leader- 
ship and the generosity of Mr. John B. Stetson, Jr., 
and under the scholarly editorial supervision of Dr. 
James A. Robertson, the Society is proceeding rapidly 
to the publication of original documents and the 
preparation of monographs. Notable among the pub- 
lications thus far completed are Dr. Hrdlicka’s Anthro- 
pology of Florida and Jeannette Thurber Connor’s 
edition of Solis de Meras’s Menéndez de Avilés. 

The preparation of this volume has put me in debt 
to many persons. First of all must be mentioned Mr. 
Sidney M. Ehrman, whose generosity and personal 
interest have made its publication possible. Thanks 
are due to the administration of the University of 
California for permission to publish the volume 
through its press. Especially am I grateful to Mr. 
Joseph W. Flinn, University Printer, for his great skill 
and his infinite care in the production of the book. It 
is a pleasure to acknowledge the valuable aid rendered 
by Mr. Herbert B. Foster in drafting the maps. For 
inestimable assistance in the preparation of the text 
I am indebted to Miss Mary Ross. The actual writing 
was done by myself, but so great has been her aid that 
this portion of the work is here published separately 
under joint-authorship. 


HERBERT E. Bouton. 


Tue Bancrort Liprary, 
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, 


May 1, 1925. 
[x] 


CONTENTS 


PAGE 
1 SSH ON 0) 0 EE Sg a eee eT ed v-x 
Oo Leto PAL Sd BAT TONS. here ea ooccccceneae xiii 
CHAPTER 
fg Vaud EVN ERR Hoes Ok GD A GT ee 1 
II. THESPANISH PIONEERS IN GEORGIA 
AND SOUTH AROGLINAS 2 2ticlndes:, 6 
Ill. THE ANGLO-SPANISH CONTEST FOR 
CELE Dee ae digg, en ee a 28 
IV. THE CONTEST FOR WESTERN 
SALE Naty 11 lg ee gate Sed pa ee ORS hee 45 


V. DIPLOMATIC CONTROVERSIES OVER 
FORT KING GEORGE AND OGLE- 


PUERCO Oe Wi AO CAQIN Nosed net ates tynctectn cece 69 
VI. THE WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR............... 77 
VII. THE NEUTRAL GROUND AND THE 

PIN ATS PG Lan Ses Hieatnteiinccs 98 
ye eC per EVRA heed Gn trenceaeta tas give nya qaittnens 113 
ENED Fe pe cg aR ee ed sda rehstAl oy snes staceannnth Gai ious 127 


est 


ft 
s 


“i 


he ae 
a a 
ree yh 


Sata aa - 


LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 


Georgia seme. ee Pie eh eo Rl 2 Peeve Frontispiece 
FACING PAGE 
- Map of the Georgia Country in Spanish Days....00..0.0.00cccc- xv1 
poeta, CA DAL iris gles LAricl eee eevee ee cecr, ess Sark, rag, mee 16 
Another view of the ruins of Santa Marfa Mission, near 
sS Pem VESEY Be GEOR E ohio. oe clewe ete cee en enrol ty 24 
Mapjob the Caroling Grant -OiylO65...924u.teene recat: 32 
Blan‘obthe Apalachicola Ports 1680 2cc..sccctecccsssseree-ssee- ee 48 
St. Simons. (Gualquimi) Sound...........::.::::csecsessessseseessesssesseeeeeeee 64 
IMaprotoneuDebavablenbiands.< 04.8 sor sudeseear nese coteveucer ae 80 
HainsLony ther SOuUbLMeAl bana). cccc trees. tec teers. pons dweterrscone eos 88 
The Siege of San Agustin. Map by Thomas Silverv.............. 96 
Arredondo’s Map of Gualquini Harbot.............:.:ccccseseseseeneees 104 
Arredondo’s Map of the Debatable Land... 112 
Bowen’s Map of the Georgia Country, VAS ee ee coe 138 


[xiii] 


THE DEBATABLE LAND 


A SKETCH OF THE ANGLO-SPANISH 
CONTEST FOR THE GEORGIA COUNTRY 


APA L CHICOL. AS 


RE SUICUE ty ayy" a" i oa 
CAVETA: ties f R ; Rs 
CoLONENA. J} Rpt. 79 ve oes ELENA 8 
rr fa casista ie 
{ dsuchrT curr bids £4 
APALACHICOLA OCUTE va - 
SPANISH. FORT EIS ACHITO ye SANTA ELENA 
-ALIPA alae eee I$ SOS 


SAVACOLA EL GRANDE 


hear SAVAG SOLAATY® “SAVACOLA ‘aso 


a 
\\ 

S\N) \ 

~ \ \ 

Pea ain \ ( : a ey ‘ Apeen ; 

| i ¢ i : 7a “f ~ a : Ne aes : : ZAPALA (SAN JOSE} 

; ~ e 

. \ emis WA \ : Jes \ WPAgESPaCACHE 

2] s\\ Ges : . eae Re Se cs ee NS iy BOCAS DE TALAJE - 
{ A wie : io : RESN oe ANTO DOMINGO 

. ASAO (SAN SIMON 


FGULOUINI (SAN BUENAVENTURA) 
SPO : 


wa = 
~\ ‘A 
“\ J 
| ma ad ; a Ge SAN PEDRO 
Nt a ‘i $e, / od fb owane fF ena ISANTA, MARIA 
Xd santa cruz ct SABhcOLA 72 \ er Sy hes [ = el : 
\ ; 4 eae ae ets WRSANTA MARIA 


/~ S \ ier } sins } :: 7 ce : 
$ cuators of SAITCARLOS oO \sonLoseg j 7s eS \ ; : cl ) Souk ii 
30" {67+ \ iC ON AYUBAL 4 G { N F 
fe SAN ANTONIO (Baby Bapaay Say Ju O Me RANCISCO OCONT, 3 . ; N sy Bree 
oft, a Luis 106 SEN DAMIAN JAN. LORENZO (IBITACHUGE] ) ee foie) SAN JUAN 
Sees - a Be I ™ 7] CAROLINE (SAN MATEO) 


ELENA MACHAVA 


SAN PEORO POTURIBA M| | J 


Sach ei es DE ASIL 
Sd 
~ SAN 
ee SN 


be santa cruz 


a4 Brean ‘a os I MaRCOS 
SS i . so 00 
) aera J i ROTANO \ 
UACARA \\ “s Ves. al iw / SAN DIEGG 4 1. 
SANTA CATALINA A é mat & fare oo PUPO mip C3 & SAN AGUSTIN 
} SANTA CRUD $ SEAN BOUT E 1 ana 
/ DE TARICA ALACHUA S ROA! 
Bae RA MATANZAS 
af é : - ‘ ie 19°30 


LEGEND 


4 MISSION 
@ PRESIDIO 
A INDIAN TOWN 


SCALE iN MILES 
SSS 
0 


we 


Map of the Georgia Country in Spanish Days. 


CHAPTER I 


A BIRD’S-EYE VIEW 


It is not generally known that for more 
than a century the Georgia coast was dotted 
with Spanish missions. But such was the 
case. From St. Marys River on the south to 
Port Royal (South Carolina) on the north 
little centers of Spanish influence were planted 
in the midst of nearly every coast tribe. 
Scores of devoted missionaries lived among 
these children of the forest and taught them 
the Gospel of Christ. Small soldier garrisons 
protected the missionaries from their neo- 
phytes and guarded the country against the 
intrusions of unwelcome European neighbors. 
The Georgia coast constituted the district of 
Guale, and was a part of the province of La 
Florida. Most of the Spanish establishments 
in Guale were on the islands, for these are 
terra firma, while the adjacent mainland pre- 
sents a wide strip of difficult swamp and 
salt-marsh, which even yet is unsubdued. 


2 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Missionary activity in the Georgia country 
was not confined to the seaboard. Occasional 
journeys were made by the friars to the inland 
tribes. Westward from the Atlantic coast a 
line of missions stretched along the southern 
border all the way from Cumberland Island to 
the lower reaches of the Apalachicola and 
thence onward to Pensacola. On the banks 
of the Chattahoochee, near the western fringe 
of Georgia, a mission was planted in the village 
of Sdbacola. Below the falls of the same 
stream a presidio was established in the midst 
of the Apalachicolas, or Lower Creeks. 

Spain’s principal agents on the Georgia 
frontier were the missionary and the soldier. 
The supporting base from which they went 
forth and by which they were sustained was 
San Agustin, capital of the province of 
Florida, of which the Georgia country was a 
part. Here a presidio served as the center of 
supply and control, and furnished succor in 
time of need. The guardian outpost on the 
north till 1587 was Santa Elena (Port Royal), 
with its presidio of San Felipe. After Santa 
Hlena was withdrawn, Santa Catalina, near 
the Savannah, held the border for nearly a 
century. Spain’s main pathways between 


A BIRD’S-EYE VIEW 3 


these outposts were cut through the water. 
Larger craft braved the storms and waves of 
the outer sea; smaller vessels sought the 
shelter of the friendly Inland Passage that 
winds between the mainland savannahs and 
the necklace of islands that front the ocean. 

The Georgia missions, with their slender 
garrisons, were not alone signs of Spain’s desire 
to spread the Faith. They were evidences, 
likewise, of her title to all the vast area in- 
cluded in our “Old Southeast.”’ This title was 
soon enough contested. From the days of 
Ribaut and Drake, French and English free- 
booters almost incessantly came up out of the 
Caribbean, traded with the natives of the 
interior, and raided the Spanish settlements on 
the Atlantic coast. After the founding of 
Charleston in 1670 the English colonists 
steadily encroached on the Spanish settle- 
ments in Guale, while in the back country the 
Carolina traders challenged Spain’s hold on 
the Apalachicola Confederacy. 

The advantage was with the more aggres- 
sive contestant. Step by step the Spanish 
frontier receded. Santa Elena was first 
yielded. Then, after a century’s actual occu- 
pation of the Georgia coast, in 1680 Spain 


+ THE DEBATABLE LAND 


withdrew her Guale outpost from Santa 
Catalina (St. Catherines) to Zdpala and the 
Altamaha. Six years later, after new raids of 
Carolinians, Indians, and buccaneers, the 
frontier retreated to the St. Marys. A decade 
and a half still later, during Queen Anne’s War, 
it fell back to the St. Johns. 

Nor could Spain exclude the English from 
the hinterland. In vain she sent missionaries 
to Sdbacola; in vain she sent expeditions to 
capture the traders; in vain she fortified the 
Chattahoochee. The contest there upset tribal 
relations and drove the Lower Creeks eastward 
to the Ocmulgee. Incident to the struggle 
the Carolinians ruthlessly laid waste thirteen 
missions in the Tallahasse district that had 
been continuously occupied by Spain for 
seventy years. 

The Yamassee War (1715) demonstrated 
the need, long felt, of a buffer English out- 
post south of the Savannah. The effort to 
provide it by establishing Fort King George 
on the Altamaha precipitated a sharp diplo- 
matic controversy. With the coming of 
Oglethorpe’s Georgia colony in 1733 a half 
decade of bluster and argument followed on 
that noisy border. The contest for Guale then 


A BIRD’S-EYE VIEW 5 


became part of a larger struggle known as 
the War of Jenkins’ Ear, in which failures 
were the rule on both sides. The result was 
indecisive, and Georgia continued to be 
“debatable land.” For a decade or more 
England nursed the idea of a Neutral Ground, 
unoccupied by either contestant. She would 
“make a solitude and call it peace.’”’ Hoping 
thereby to conciliate Spain, she forbade 
Englishmen to settle south of the Altamaha. 
But unruly frontiersmen flouted the order and 
violated the Neutral Ground. In spite of 
English diplomacy, Spain entered the Seven 
Years’ War, and thereby lost all her lands east 
of the Mississippi. The century-long contest 
over the Georgia country was thus ended. 


CHAPTER II 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS IN GEORGIA AND 
SOUTH CAROLINA 


(1566-1670) 


Georgia land, and indeed the whole South 
Atlantic coast of North America, came into 
history as a region lying across the pathway 
to fabled realms of untold wealth and alluring 
romance. Ayll6én, seeking to exploit the land 
of the Giant King Datha, planted a short- 
lived colony on the shores of South Carolina 
(1526). De Soto, in quest of golden Yupaha, 
and then of enticing Coosa, trod Georgia soil 
for nearly half a thousand miles. The land 
failed to yield ‘‘gold in quantity,’ so two 
decades passed before it was visited once 
more. The expedition of De Luna and 
Villafafie sent to plant colonies at Coosa and 
Santa Elena became the helpless plaything of 
a hurricane that swept the harbor of Pensa- 
cola, where they landed. Discouraged at these 
costly failures, King Philip II now declared 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 7 


that no further attempt should be made to 
colonize inhospitable Florida (1561). There 
were better lands in Mexico and Peru. And 
so the curtain was rung down on the first act 
of Georgia and Carolina history.: 

But Philip’s decision was premature. He 
could not abandon Florida if he would. His 
words were hardly cold when Frenchmen 
intruded. Ribaut’s ill-starred colony at Port 
Royal miserably failed (1562). Then Laudon- 
niére planted Fort Caroline on St. Johns 
River, near the site of Jacksonville (1564). 
The French menace called for action, and 


1 EKarly Spanish activities in the southeastern portion of the 
United States are treated in English by Woodbury Lowery in his 
two-volume work on Spanish Settlements Within the Present 
Limits of the United States, 15138-1574 (New York, 1901, 1905); 
Bolton, Herbert E., The Spanish Borderlands (New Haven, 1921), 
chs. 1, 3, 5; Shea, J. G., The Catholic Church in the United States, 
vol. I (New York, 1886). Their place in the general history of 
North America is set forth briefly in Bolton and Marshall, The 
Colonization of North America (New York, 1920), 24, 40-42, 61- 
65, 253-257. An excellent general account in Spanish is con- 
tained in Barefa, Andrés Gonzdlez (Cardenas), Ensayo Crono- 
légico para la Historia General de la Florida (Madrid, 1723). An 
indication of the original documents for the period before 1543 
is given by Hodge and Lewis (editors), Spanish Explorers in the 
Southern United States, 1628-1643 (New York, 1907). An 
interesting account of the expedition of Fray Luis Cancer and 
that of De Luna and Villafafie is contained in Davila Padilla, 
Historia de la fundacién y discurso de la provincia de Santiago de 
Mezico, etc. (Brussels, 1625). 


8 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Philip sent his ablest seaman to eject the 
intruders and colonize the threatened coasts. 
In September, 1565, Menéndez de Avilés 
reached Florida with a large colony and 
founded San Agustin. Ten days later he 
marched stealthily overland, surprised Fort 
Caroline at dawn, and mercilessly slew most 
of its defenders.! 

“Pious cutthroat,’ Parkman has called 
Menéndez. But he was more than that. He 
was a constructive colonizer as well as a hard- 
fisted soldier. He did not stop with wordy 
plans; he executed. Within a year he had a 
line of posts and settlements all the way round 
the coast from Tampa Bay to Santa Elena 
(Port Royal). 

It was in April, 1566, that the great Adelan- 
tado made his first visit to the northern 
Georgia coast. The chief of Santa Catalina 
(St. Catherines) Island, where Menéndez 


1 Good accounts of the early French in Florida are given by 
Lowery, Spanish Settlements within the present limits of the 
United States, Florida, 1562-1574, Bk. I; Parkman, Francis, 
The Pioneers of France in the New World; and Barcia, Ensayo 
Cronolégico, 45-46. A briefer sketch is in Bolton, The Spanish 
Borderlands. French accounts are Paul Gaffarel, Histoire de la 
Floride Francaise (Paris, 1875); Basanier, Histoire Notable de la 
Floride (Paris, 1586), reprinted in Gaffarel, 347-376); Lescarbot, 
Histoire de la Nouvelle France (Paris, 1611). 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 9 


landed, was an old man called Guale. From 
this circumstance the name Guale was specif- 
ically applied to the island; but it was gradu- 
ally extended down the entire Georgia coast 
islands and mainland from Santa Elena to the 
St. Johns. Landing with fifty men, the 
Adelantado made friends with old chief Guale, 
and soon had him sitting on the beach eating 
biscuits ‘‘with gusto.’”’ When he departed 
Menéndez left his nephew and another Span- 
iard as hostages. On his way back from Santa 
Elena in August he made another stop of eight 
days in Guale, and left there a garrison of 
thirty men. This post on St. Catherines was 
the first of a chain of Spanish settlements on 
the Georgia seaboard; its founding in 1566 
was the beginning of more than a century’s 
continuous occupation. 


1 Menéndez was not the first Spaniard to visit Guale Island. 
In 1564 Hernando Manrique de Rojas was sent from Cuba to 
remove the remains of the colony left at Port Royal by Ribaut. 
Twelve or fifteen leagues south of Port Royal he visited a town 
called Guale. It was evidently identical with the Guale visited 
by Menéndez. The early English settlers of South Carolina 
used the name Guale for the Georgia coast, spelling it ‘Wallie,”’ 
a phonetic equivalent for the Spanish ‘‘Guale.” The identifica- 
tion of Guale with Amelia Island is correct only after 1686, when 
the Guale missions were moved southward across the St. Marys. 
“Lengua de Guale’”’ in the early documents meant, variously, the 
language, an interpreter, the island, the tongue of land, or the 
district, of Guale. 


10 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


While Menéndez hurried up and down the 
coast, brave Pardo and Boyano explored the 
back country of Carolina and Georgia. They 
garnered little or no gold. But they brought 
back stories of ‘treasure that circulated on the 
frontier for a century, grew bigger with each 
passing generation of yarn spinners, and 
inspired more than one later expedition to the 
Georgia interior. 

Menéndez was a soldier of God as well as - 
of the King. So he brought Jesuit mission- 
aries to teach the natives Christianity and the 
elements of European civilization. Brothers 
Domingo Agustin and Pedro Ruiz led the 
way to Guale (1568). Three others soon fol- 
lowed. Brother Domingo was a born linguist, 
and within six months he had translated the 
Catechism and prepared a grammar in the 
Yamassee tongue. This Guale grammar, it 
would seem, was the first ever written on 
United States soil. But Brother Domingo 
wrote no more grammars in this world. Be- 
fore the end of the year he died during an 
epidemic, a martyr to the Faith in Georgia. 
Father Rogel went'to Orista, near Port Royal, 
or Santa Elena. On the southern end of the 
Georgia littoral Menéndez established another 
garrison called San Pedro. It was-soon fol- 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS at 


lowed by a mission. These first Jesuit mis- 
sionary labors were short lived. The Indians 
had their own view of things. During an 
uprising in 1570 the missions of Guale and 
Orista were deserted. Father Segura and his 
little band withdrew to Virginia, where they 
were forthwith slaughtered by the very Indians 
they hoped to save. At the same time the 
garrisons at San Agustin, San Pedro, and 
San Felipe were reduced to fifty men each. 
The Jesuits had gone; Menéndez soon 
followed them.1 For seven years La Florida 
had been the great man’s chief care. In 1572 


1'The work of Menéndez de Avilés is sketched in Lowery’s 
second volume, Florida, 1562-1574. The book is sound. AlI- 
though Parkman (Pioneers of France in the New World) is unsym- 
pathetic toward the Spaniards, his sketch of Menéndez’s career 
possesses literary qualities lacked by that of Lowery, and is still 
valuable. A contemporary account is the Memorial que hizo el 
Doctor Gonzalo Solis de Merds, de todas las jornadas y sucesos del 
Adelantado Pedro Menéndez de Avilés. It was published in 
Spanish by Ruidfaz y Caravia in his La Florida, su conquista y 
colonizacién por Pedro Menéndez de Avilés (Madrid, 1893). Just 
recently an excellent English translation of Merds has been made 
by Jeannette Thurber Connor and published under the title of 
Pedro Menéndez de Avilés (Deland, 1923). Ruidfaz gives a good 
sketch of Menéndez’s life, ample bibliographies, and. extensive 
documentary appendices. His book is fundamental for the early 
history of the Atlantic coast. Barcfa’s Ensayo Cronoldégico con- 
tains a good general account. Other contemporary accounts are 
in Genaro Garcfa (ed.), Dos Antiguas Relaciones de la Florida 
(Mexico, 1902). Data concerning Father Rogel will be found in 
the Historical Magazine, vol. V, pp. 327-330 (New York, 1861). 


12 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


he left it never to return. Now for the 
greater part of two decades the fortunes of 
the province were directed by his able nephew, 
Pedro Menéndez Marqués. Among his mani- 
fold difficulties Indian uprisings in Santa Elena 
and Guale were not the least. A Christian 
chief was killed in Guale. Solis, commander 
at Santa Elena, posted down the Inland 
Passage and hanged some of the offenders. 
When their chance came, the Gualeans repaid 
the compliment by massacring nine Spaniards 
at Espogache, a village near the Altamaha.! 
Among the slain was Pedro Menéndez, the 
Crosseyed, another nephew of the Adelantado. 

These Indian disturbances were encouraged 
by French corsairs who harried the coast, for 
other Gauls had followed in the wake of 
Ribaut. They traded profitably in sassafras, 
and they intrigued with the Indians. But 


1The rebellion at Santa Elena in 1576 and the raids of 
Estrozi and Gil are treated by Mary Ross of the University of 
California in her “French Intrusions and Indian Uprisings in 
Georgia and South Carolina, 1577-1580” (Georgia Historical 
Quarterly, Vol. VII, no. 3, September 1923, pp. 251-281). The 
wealth of materials for this period in the Archivo General de 
Indias is indicated by the footnotes to Miss Ross’s article. A 
description of the new fort built at Santa Elena after the uprising 
of 1576 is given by Flores in his manuscript report made in 1578 
(A. G. I., 2-5-2/10). A later French intrusion is treated by 
Miss Ross in “The French on the Savannah, 1605” (Georgia 


Historical Quarterly, Vol. VIII, no. 3, September, 1924, pp. 167- 
194). 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 13 


some of them paid dearly for their ventures. 
One such was Estrozi, head of one of these 
marauding bands. He was captured by 
Marqués in Guale, taken to San Agustin, 
questioned, and then summarily executed with 
twenty-two of his men (1579). In the follow- 
ing summer no less than twenty French 
corsair vessels were seen on the Georgia coast. 
Their leader, Captain Gil, was slain in a hot- 
fought battle in San Juan River. Marqués 
now had a breathing spell. But these were not 
the last of the sassafras gatherers. 

Such a frontier demanded more mission- 
aries, and the place of the Jesuits was taken 
by the Franciscans. These “precursors” began 
a work in Georgia which lasted for a century— 
and was then forgotten.1 The first band of 


1 Most of the records of the work of the first Franciscans in 
the Georgia country are still in manuscript. Many of these are 
contained in the Archivo General de Indias. Barcia (Ensayo 
Cronolégico) gives valuable data. Torquemada, Monarquia 
Indiana (Madrid, 1723), Ch. XXX, gives a detailed account of 
the uprising of the Guale Indians, which occurred shortly before 
he wrote. This book was first printed in Seville in 1615. In 
modern times pioneer work of high character was done by John 
Gilmary Shea, in his Catholic Church in the United States, vol. I. 
Shea was followed closely by Rev. Father Zephyrin Engelhardt 
in a series of valuable articles published in the Franciscan Herald, 
vols. I-III (1913-1915). More recently J. G. Johnson has pub- 
lished The Spanish Period of Georgia and South Carolina, 1566- 
1702 (Bulletin of the University of Georgia, May, 1923). 


14 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


the Little Brothers came to Santa Elena in 
1573. Most of their work centered around 
San Agustin. Part of them went to Guale 
only to be driven out or slain. But the friars 
held on. Churches were built in the principal 
towns—at Tolomato, at Tupique, at Guale, 
at Yoa. On the southern coast San Pedro 
(Cumberland Island) became an important 
missionary center, where Father Baltasar 
Lépez won fame. But the hero of all this early 
Franciscan period was Fray Alonso Reynoso. 
Devout, gentle, zealous, tireless, his figure, 
though shadowy in the distance, still looms 
large and strong. He was a sixteenth century 
Serra on the Atlantic coast. 


1 Father Reynoso’s work is dealt with in a Council warrant, 
Madrid, November 12, 1583; royal cédula to the Casa de Con- 
tratacién, November 22, 1583; to Fray Alonso de Reynoso, 
March 31, 1584; to the Casa de Contratacién, February 3, 1587; 
to the same, February 23, 1587; to the royal officials of Florida, 
October 11, 1589; to the same, October 18, 1589; the Council of 
the Indies to Antonio de Cartagena, November 6, 1589; royal 
cédula to the officials of Florida, March 17, 1587; to the Casa de 
Contratacién, June 1, 1587; to the same, September 20, 1589; 
to the goyernor of Florida, March 6, 1590 (all the foregoing are 
in A. G. I., 154-1-18).. In a letter dated at San Agustin, May 10, 
1586, Governor Marqués wrote in highest praise of the friar. 
“T can tell your Majesty that he has worked hard among these 
people, for since he came he has never left them.” (A. G. L., 
54-5-16, Doe. no. 48.) His work is reviewed in a document of 
1602 entitled Florida, Materias Gubernativas (A. G. I., 86-5-24). 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 15 


Guale’s importance was increased by 
Drake’s attack, for that bold raid caused the 
removal of the Santa Elena garrison to San 
Agustin (1587). Santa Catalina, the mission 
near the Savannah, was now the northern out- 
post. A new epoch was opened in 1595, when, 
in the cool of October, Governor Avendafio 
conducted five more friars to Guale. Gratify- 
ing success attended their labors. In seven 
towns along the Georgia coast old churches 
were restored or new ones built.:' Father 
Chozas the explorer, and Pareja the linguist, 
labored on San Pedro Island; Davila, the 
captive-to-be, on Ospo (Jekyl); Velascola the 
Cantabrian giant, on Asao (St. Simons); the 
veteran Corpa on the mainland at Tolomato, 
~ across from Zdpala (Sapelo) Island; Rodriguez 
at Tupique three leagues north, and also on 
the mainland; Aufion and Badajoz at Santa 
Catalina. Encouraged by bountiful harvests 
on the coast, Fathers Chozas and Velascola 
journeyed inland eight days on horseback to 


‘1 An illuminating report of the missions in 1597 is given in 
Ynformacién hecha en 8. Agustin de la Florida ante fray Fran- 

cisco Marron, custodio cura y vicario de aquellas Provincias, 
. sobre la pobreza y necesidad en que se encuentran los Religiosos 
Misioneros y del buen efecto de las misiones entre los naturales. 
January 23, 1597 (A. G. I., 54-5-20). 


16 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


distant Tama and Ocute, Creek towns near 
the upper Altamaha. Their enthusiastic re- 
ports revived old tales of Boyano’s Diamond 
Mountain, and stirred up new dreams of 
interior conquest. 

For two years the Guale missions flour- 
ished. Then suddenly the thunderbolt of 
rebellion came out of a clear sky. Juan, a 
heady young chief, heir of the mico of Tolo- 
mato, organized a conspiracy. Followers were 
not hard to find, and in September, 1597, the 
blow fell.1 Father Corpa was slain and be- 
headed. From Tolomato the angry mob 
rushed to the other missions, gathering 
strength as it went. The tide first turned 
north and then it surged southward. Father 
Rodriguez at Tupique, Aufion and Badajoz at 
Santa Catalina, and Velascola at Asao, 
suffered a fate like that of Father Corpa. 
Father Davila at Ospo was wounded, seized, 


1 The story of the Guale revolt is set forth at some length by 
Torquemada in his Monarquia Indiana, which was written shortly 
after the event. Barcia (Cardenas) retold the story a century 
and a quarter later in his Hnsayo Cronolégico. Accounts in 
English are given by Shea (The Catholic Church in the United 
States, I); Engelhardt (Franciscan Herald, vol. 1), and Johnson,’ 
J. G. (“The Yamassee Revolt of 1597 and the Destruction of 
the Georgia Missions,”’ Georgia Historical Quarterly, vol. VII, 
pp. 44-53, March, 1923). 


Santa Catalina Island, looking south, down the Inland Passage. 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 17 


and carried into a captivity that was worse 
than death. But the Indians at San Pedro 
remained faithful, and there the bloody 
massacre spent its force. 

A hurried appeal for help was sent from 
San Pedro to San Agustin. To punish the 
offenders Governor Canzo arose from a sick 
bed and sailed north up the Inland Passage 
with a hundred and fifty soldiers. The 
Indians everywhere fled in terror.1 At Ospo, 
Zapala, Tolomato, Guale, Tupique, Asao, and 
Talaje, Canzo destroyed all that was left of 
towns and cornfields. But he could find no 
Indians to chastize. Other punitive expeditions 
were made, and the Indians at last submitted. 
After nearly a year Father Davila was re- 
covered from captivity. Don Lucas, a young 


1 Manuscript materials for the history of the subjugation of 
the Indians are voluminous. Some of the documents are the 
following: Carta del Gobernador de la Florida Gonzalo Mendez 
de Canco 4 8. M. San Agustin, February 23, 1598 (A. G. L, 
54-5-9); Ynformacién sobre la muerte de los Relixiosos, July 11, 
1598 (A. G. I., Patronato, 1-1-1/19 Ro. 28);Carta de Gonzalo 
Mendez de Canco, Gobernador de la Florida, 4S. M. En ella 
trata de la muerte que dieron los Yndios de guale 4 los Religiosos, 
San Agustin, August 8, 1598; Auto y pregon del Gobernador de 
la Florida Gonsalo Mendes de Cango, sobre la libertad de los 
Yndios, January 31, 1600; Testimonio cerca de la pacificacion de 
los caciques de la provincia de Guale. May 18, 1600 (A. G. L., 
54-5-9). 


18 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


hostage who confessed to a part in the uprising, 
was hanged at San Agustin on the public 
scaffold. The harsh punishment had its effect. 
Now the Guale chiefs renewed their allegiance, 
were granted pardon, and once more loyally 
furnished levies of laborers for the public 
works at San Agustin. 

The restoration of the missions followed. 
They were urgently needed. The coast de- 
manded protection against a new swarm of 
French corsairs. The interior beckoned. 
Canzo projected a colony at Tama, and sent 
Juan de Lara inland nine days to investigate 
rumors of strangers.1 To prepare the way for 
missionaries, Ibarra the new governor, made 
a triumphal visit to the Guale towns. There 
was another year of waiting, then seven more 
sandaled friars reached San Agustin. Early 
in 1606 part of them were escorted north up 
the Inland Passage. The destroyed churches 
had already been rebuilt, and the friars were 
welcomed with ceremony. Once more the 


1 Tdeas concerning the interior, and plans for interior expan- 
sion, are set forth in Ynformacion hecha de oficio ante Don 
Gonzalo Mendez de Cango, Gobernador de las Provincias de la 
Florida, sobre la situation de la Tama y sus riquezas y de la 
poblacion de Yngleses. San Agustin, February 4, 1600; Carta 
del Gover." de la Florida, 22 Sep.e 1602 (A. G. I., 54-5-9); 
Florida, Materias Gubernativas, 1602 (A. G. I., 86—5-24). 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 19 


Georgia forests echoed the peaceful tones of 
the Angelus bell. Father Juan de Capillas 
took charge at San Pedro; Pedro Delgado at 
Talaje and Espogache; Pedro Ruiz at Santa 
Catalina. What these Brown Robes had ac- 
complished by summer is revealed in the 
report by the bishop of Cuba, who then made 
the first pastoral visit ever accomplished on 
United States soil. At the four Georgia 
missions he confirmed 1070 neophytes. Guale 
had come back to the Christian fold. 
Activity in the Georgia missions was 
stimulated by a new cloud in the northern 
sky. In the very year after the Franciscans 
returned to Guale the English settled at 
Jamestown. Philip III might easily have 
crushed the weak little post, but he tempor- 


1The manuscript materials for the restoration of friendly 
relations with Guale and the reestablishment of the missions are 
extensive. The following are some of them: Visita hecha por 
el Gouct. G°. Mendez de Canzo, February, 1603; Carta del 
Gouer.*? de la Florida G.° Mendez de Cango, 15 de Abril, 603; 
Discurso del uiaje que ba a hacer el Sefior Pedro de Ybarra... 
November, 1604; Opinion of Juan Maldonado Barnuevo, Valla- 
dolid, March 21, 1605 (A. G. I., 54-5-9); Carta de Pedro de 
Ybarra al padre Benito Blasco, San Agustin, December 7, 1605; 
Testimonio de una carta de Pedro de Ybarra al Padre Fray 
Vermejo, December 13, 1605 (A. G. I., 54-5-17); Relacion 
presentada a S. M. en su Consejo de Yndias, June 26, 1606 
(A. G. I., 54-5-20); Ybarra to the King, June 26, 1606 (A. G. I., 


54-5-9). 


20 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


ized, misled by his advisors to think that the 
struggling colony would fail through disease 
and starvation. Nevertheless, the danger set 
in motion a new wave of missionary activity. 
Indeed, the seventeenth century was the 
Golden Age of the Franciscans in the “Old 
Southeast.” Their work was at once a 
crusade against heathendom and a defensive 
move to hold the border.t. In 1612 the Atlan- 
tic coast was included in a new missionary 
province called Santa Elena, and Fray Juan 
de Capillas, the Georgia missionary, went to 
live at Havana as first provincial. New friars 
came in large numbers. Fray Luis de Ore, 
“oran tedlogo,” arrived with twenty-four 
workers in 1612. All through the century 
others followed at frequent intervals. Thirty, 
forty, or even fifty at a time was the usual 
corps in the Florida province, of which Guale 
was a part. Baptisms were sometimes stimu- 
lated by epidemics; at other times they were 


1 For Spain’s reaction to Virginia, see Brown, Alexander, 
Genesis of the United States (Boston, 1890), I, 115-127, and 
elsewhere; Brown, Alexander, The First Republic in America 
(Boston, 1898), 91; Irene A. Wright, “Spanish Policy toward 
Virginia” (American Historical Review, April, 1920, 448, et seq.)} 
Calendar of State Papers, Colonial, America and the West Indies 
(London, 1860-1910), 1675-78, pp. 45 et seg. See also the 
following manuscripts: Carta incompleta de Pedro de Ibarra, 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 21 


retarded by lack of funds. The friars con- 
tinued to make occasional visits to Tama in 
the interior, and by the middle of the century 
they had returned to Santa Elena (Port 
Royal). 

Of the missions on the coast we have a 
picture drawn in 1655. Five of them were 
within the present Georgia. These were San 
Pedro on Cumberland Island; San Buena- 
ventura on St. Simons Island; Santo Domingo 
at Talaje, on the mainland; San José on 
Sapelo Island; and Santa Catalina on St. 
Catherines Island. Beyond the Savannah, 
in South Carolina, there were San Felipe on 
Parris Island, and Chatuache, six leagues 
farther north. 

Varied indeed were the labors of these 
pioneers of Georgia and South Carolina. At 
the missions there were churches and houses 
to build, fields to clear, and the monotonous 
round of spiritual offices to perform. ‘There 


January 4, 1608 (A. G. L, 54-5-9); Royal cédula to Pedro 
de Ybarra, “sobre que haga descubrir las bayas y puertos que 
ay en la Virginia.’”’ El Pardo, November 8, 1608 (A. G. L, 
87-5-2); Alonso de las Alas to the King, San Agustin, November 
23, 1609 (A. G. I., 56-5-14); Orden del Gobernador D. Pedro de 
Ybarra (de S. Agustin de la Florida) a el Capitan Francisco 
Fernandez de Ecija para reconocer las costas del norte (A. G. L., 
Patronato 2-5-3/16); Derrotero que hizo Andres Gonzales al 
Xacan (A. G. I., Patronato 1-1-1/ LOTRes SL): 


22 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


were children to instruct, daily masses to be 
sung, and special ceremonies to be performed 
on feast days; there were marriages to solem- 
nize, babes to baptize, medical aid to ad- 
minister to the sick, and last rites to perform 
for the dying and the dead. All these activi- 
ties must be carefully written down as a matter 
of record.1 This, too, was faithfully done, for 
models of neatness are the old mission books. 
But these routine labors were only part of the 
missionary’s toil. He must write long letters 
to his religious superiors or to the governor at 


1Data concerning Father Ore’s friars is given in Barcia, 
Ensayo Cronolégico, 181-184. Missionary progress is revealed 
in Carta a 8. M. de Varios Religiosos, January 17, 1617; Carta 
del Provincial y definidores, January 24, 1617; Carta de Fray 
Juan de Santander, November 25, 1630 (A. G. I., 54-5-20); 
Copia de carta que Luis de Horruytiner escrivio a Su Magestad, 
November 15, 1633 (A. G. I., 54-5-10); Barcfa, op. cit., 197; 
Shea, The Catholic Church in the United States, I, 162-5; Carta 
para S. M. de Fray Francisco Alonso de Jesus, February 7, 1635; 
Goy. Ruiz to the King, April 16, 1645 (A. G. I., 54-5-10); Memo- 
ria de las Poblaciones, MS. cited by Shea, op. cit., p. 166; Con- 
sulta del consejo, July 28, 1646 (A. G. I., 54-5-20); Barcia, op. 
cit., 212; Father Pérez, Memorial para 8. M., July 28, 1646; 
Memorial of Fray Pedro Moreno Ponce de Leén, July 21, 1648; 
Memorial of Fray Pedro Moreno Ponce de Leén, September 7, 
1651; Petition of Guale Indians, October 17, 1657 (A. G. L., 
54-5-20). Rebolledo to the king, October 18, 1657 (in Brooks, 
A., Unwritten History of Old St. Augustine (St. Augustine, 1909?), 
102-105). Relacién de los Religiosos, July 8, 1658 (A. G. L., 
54-5-20); the governor to the king, August 6, 1668 (A. G. L, 
54-5-9). 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 23 


San Agustin. He must report all disturbances 
among the Indians, or rumors of intruding 
Englishmen; for these missionaries were news- 
agents and diplomats on the frontier, as well 
as spiritual teachers. 

Missions were not solely a matter of friars 
and soldier guards.. The Indian was the 
central figure; and he was not always happy. 
He was between two masters, the secular and 
the spiritual arms of the state. Sometimes 
he complained. Sometimes he was able to 
make his voice heard—not always. His com- 
plaints were quite as likely to be echoes of the 
wranglings of friar and official as of the yearn- 
ings of the neophyte for a happier lot.1. In 
rare instances, as had been the case in 1597, he 
broke out in open revolt. 

The shadow of Jamestown soon projected 
itself into the Carolina-Georgia back country. 


1Los Religiosos de San Francisco Fr. Sebastian Martinez, 
Fr. Carlos de Anguiano y Fr. Gabriel Fernandez, a 8S. M., 
Guale, Noviembre 8, 1657. They transmit a complaint of the 
Guale Indians dated October 16, 1657 (A. G. I., 54-5-20); 
Dictamen fiscal, Madrid, May 24, 1660; Governor Alonso de 
Aranguiz y Cotes to the king, November 15, 1661 (El Gobernador 
de la Florida informa 4 S. M. contestando a una Real Cédula, 
sobre lo que pidié Santiago, Mico de Tolomato, y otros principales, 
cerca de que los Gobernadores, les occupaban en servicios per- 
sonales, etc. (A. G. I., 54-5-10). 


THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Ever since the days of the Roanoke colony the 
English settlers had talked of Spanish mines 
and west flowing rivers in the interior. ‘These 
loadstones of adventure lured Englishman as 
well as Spaniard. Loquacious John Smith 
led the way to the falls of the James. Other 
Anglomen unknown to history soon followed 
his track and lengthened it toward the 
Spanish border.1. Echoes of their movements 
reached Spanish circles, where a little fact got 
sadly mixed with much imagination. Guale 
Indians reported strange men on horseback, 
and ruddy faced foreigners who found favor 
with the Indian women. Fear of foreign 
intrusion was intertwined with an ever recur- 
rent desire to seek the pearls of Cufitachiqui, 
or Boyano’s Diamond Mountain. 

From time to time, in the course of the 
seventeenth century, Spanish expeditions were 
sent to investigate these rumors. Soldiers and 
Indians despatched by Governor Salinas in 
1624 scoured the Georgia-Carolina interior for 


1 For English activities see: Peter Force, Tracts and Other 
Paper Relating principally to the Origin, Settlement, and Progress 
of the Colonies in North America, III, no. 11, p. 15 (Washington, 
1844); Alvord and Bidgood, The First Explorations of the Trans- 
Allegheny Region by the Virginians, 1650-1674 (Cleveland, 1912), 
108, 104, 


Another view of the ruins of Santa Marfa Mission, 
near St. Marys, Georgia. 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 25 


one hundred and fifty leagues, but they found 
no trace of the rumored “gente blanca 4 
caballo.” Another party sent by Salinas had 
like success. A little later Pedro de Torres, ten 
soldiers, and sixty Guale Indians traveled 
four months in the back country of Georgia 
and Carolina, and. covered two hundred 
leagues (1628). They, too, failed to find 
Englishmen. Rumors of fair-haired strangers 
continued to come, and in 1661 a Spanish 
expedition was made all the way across 
Georgia to the Apalachicolas, or Lower 
Creeks.! 

During these years things were happening 
on the southern fringes of Georgia. The old 
Timucua missions reached northward to min- 
ister to the Indians in the region where 
Statenville and Valdosta now stand. The 
center of a new movement was Apalache, with 
San Luis (now Tallahassee) as its focus. 
Toward this important region in the back 


1Zuis de Rojas y Borja to the king, January 20, 1625; the 
king to Rojas, May 3, 1627; Carta de Don Luis de Rojas y Borja, 
Governador de la Florida 4 Su Magestad. ‘Trata en ella de un 
descubrimiento de perlas hecho en Cofitachiqui. San Agustin, 
June 30, 1628; El Gobernador de la florida, D. Alonso de Arangufz 
y Cotes aS. M., Florida, Septiembre 8, de 1662 (A. G. I., 54-5-10); 
El Alférez Juan Bauptista Terrazas a Su Magestad, ca. 1682, 
with decree of October 6, 1682 (A. G. I., 54-5-19 No. 50). 


26 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


country French and English pirates on the 
Gulf, empty flour barrels at San Agustin, and 
the demand of the royal fleets for wild turkeys 
pointed the finger of prophecy. The Apalache 
Indians had long been asking for missionaries, 
but for lack of funds and workers the petition 
could not be answered till 1633. Then the 
guardian of the head monastery at San 
Agustin trudged westward and answered the 
call. Twenty years later there were nine 
flourishing missions in Apalache, all within a 
few leagues of the principal mission at San 
Luis. Some of them drew neophytes from the 
region that is now southwestern Georgia. 
Missionary work carried with it other 
developments toward civilization in western 
Florida. A garrison was stationed at San 
Luis. Packet boats soon plied between San 
Agustin, Havana, and San Marcos Bay (1639). 
Apalache became a lively center for trade in 
deerskins and wild turkeys. Of maize and 
beans three or four thousand bushels were 
shipped annually to San Agustin. At Asile 
(Aucilla) a royal plantation was opened. 
Hostile Choctaws in the west, pirates on the 
Gulf, and English traders in the back country 
increased the importance of Apalache. The 


THE SPANISH PIONEERS 27 


military defence was strengthened, and San 
Luis became a base for advance toward 
Pensacola and up the Chattahoochee into 
western Georgia.! 


1 Manuscript materials for the history of the Tallahassee 
district in the seventeenth century are plentiful. The fol- 
lowing are a few: Fray Francisco Ale de Jhs. 4 Su Magestad, 
Florida. Sin fecha, with Decreto 27 de Febrero de 1635; D. 
Luis Horruytiner, 4S. M., S. Agustin. Junio 24, 1637; Same to 
same, September 12, 1638; Parrafos de una carta de Damian de 
Vega, August 22, 1639 (A. G. I., 54-5-10); Francisco Menéndez 
Marqués y Pedro Benedit Horruytiner, a 8. M. July 27, 1647 
(A. G. I. 54-5-20. Doc. no. 50); El Rey a Oficiales reales, 
Balzain, 24 Octubre, 1653 (A. G. I., 54-5-11); Memoria de las 
Poblaciones, 1655 (cited by Shea, op. cit., I, 165-166); Carta de 
Fray Juan Gomez de Engraba, Havana, March 13, 1657 (A. G. 
I., 54-5-10. Doc. no. 73); Memorial of friars Francisco de San 
Antonio, Juan de Medina, Sebasti4n Martinez, Jacinto Dom{in- 
guez, Alonso del Moral, and Juan Caldera, to his Majesty, 
Florida, September 10, 1657; Carta de los Religiosos de la 
Provincia de Santa Elena a S. M., September 10, 1657 (A. G. L., 
54-5-20); Carta de los Religiosos de la Florida, June 16, 1664 
(A. G. I., 54-5-18). 


CHAPTER III 


THE ANGLO-SPANISH CONTEST FOR GUALE 
(1670-1686) 


A new menace now arose in the north. 
The English came up out of the Caribbean 
to settle on the very soil of old Santa Elena, 
next door to Santa Catalina. The impulse 
for the settlement of South Carolina came 
from the Antilles. Plantations there were 
playing out; new lands were needed; a “‘west- 
ward movement” to the mainland resulted. 
Sir John Colleton, Barbadian planter, inter- 
ested a group of men in the Carolina country. 
A charter granted to eight Proprietors all the 
region from 36° to 31°. Two years later the 
paper boundaries were pushed south to 29°. 
Who cared that Spain at that very moment 
had, within the area granted, a line of settle- 
ments stretching up the coast for one hundred 
and fifty miles, some of them nearly a century 
old? Or that the grant included El Paso and 
Santa Fé? 


THE CONTEST FOR GUALE — 29 


William Hilton was sent from Barbados to 
explore the Carolina coast. When he arrived 
at Parris Island he found there Captain 
Argiielles with soldiers from San Agustin. 
Presents were exchanged. The Spaniards 
proffered venison and pork; the Englishmen 
responded with a jug. of brandy. But Hilton 
was cautious and withdrew to avoid capture. 
The Spaniards had blocked the way to Port 
Royal.! 

Three years later Yeamans, one of the 
Proprietors, took a colony to Cape Fear 
River. Then, while he returned to Barbados, 
Robert Sandford sailed south to explore. 
With him went young Dr. Henry Woodward, 
a man of destiny on that international border. 
Santa Elena was Sandford’s goal. No Span- 


1For Hilton, Yeamans, Sandford, and Woodward, see 
Shaftesbury Papers (South Carolina Historical Society Collec- 
tions, Vol. V, 1897), pp. 18-28, 57-82, and index; McCrady, 
Edward, The History of South Carolina under the Proprietary 
Government, 1670-1719 (New York, 1897), pp. 71-72, 81-93; 
Calendar of State Papers, Colonial, America and West Indies, 1669- 
1674 (London, 1889), p. 246; Swanton, J. R., Harly History of the 
Creek Indians (Washington, 1922), 62-67. For a biographical 
sketch of Woodward, see Joseph W. Barnwell, “Dr. Henry 
Woodward, The First English Settler in South Carolina, and 
Some of his Descendants (South Carolina Historical and Genea- 
logical Magazine, VIII, no. 1, January, 1907, pp. 29-41). Among 
Woodward’s many distinguished descendants one was Robert 
Y. Hayne, of ‘‘Webster-Hayne debate” fame. 


30 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


iards were there now, but “a faire woodden 
Crosse of the Spaniards ereccon”’ stood in the 
plaza of the town on Parris Island, and signs of 
preparation for new buildings were in sight. 
When on July 8 Sandford departed he took 
with him the nephew of the cacique of Santa 
Elena; in his place he left Dr. Woodward. A 
formal ceremony sealed the arrangement. 
The whole village being assembled, Sandford 
delivered Woodward into the keeping of the 
head chiefs and their wives. Woodward was 
placed beside the cacique on a throne, given 
the cacique’s niece for a housekeeper, and 
endowed by the Niquesalla with “‘formall pos- 
session of the whole Country to hold as 
Tennant at Will of the right Hono” Lords 
Proprietors.’ 

A site for a colony had been selected. But 
it was debatable ground, destined to witness 
stirring scenes. Twenty years of conflict 
were necessary to decide the possession of 
Santa Elena. Spaniard, Indian, and Scotch- 
man, each lent color to the moving picture 


1 For the failure of the Cape Fear settlement and the founding 
of Charleston, see Shaftesbury Papers, 13, 25, 31, 52, 89, 93, 130, 
136, 141-143, 158, 161, 163, 168, 178, 217-218, 263, 273; McCrady 
Carolina Under the Proprietary Government, chs. 3-5; Carroll, 
Historical Collections of South Carolina, I, ch. 2 (New York, 1836). 


THE CONTEST FOR GUALE 31 


staged on its shores. The key to the border 
was in the pocket of Dr. Henry Woodward. 
He studied the country and learned the 
tongues of the natives. Months were spent 
in these pursuits, then Spaniards carried him 
to San Agustin. The English account has it 
that he was captured. The Spanish version 
is that he went of his own accord. Be that 
as it may, at San Agustin he found favor. He 
lived with the parish priest, became a Catholic, 
and was made official surgeon. Thus ad- 
vantaged, he learned the secrets of the country 
and then awaited a chance to escape. It soon 
came. In 1668 the freebooter, Robert Searles, 
favored Florida with a visit... By a mirth 
provoking trick he entered the harbor at San 
Agustin and ransacked the town. In the 
confusion Woodward fled to the English and 
with them sailed to the Antilles. Within two 


1For the Searles attack on San Agustin in 1668 and the 
escape of Woodward see Carta del Licenciado francisco Sotolongo, 
Cura de la Yglesia de aquella Provincia de la Florida, San 
Agustin, July 4, 1668 (A. G. I., 54-5-20) ; Carta de Juan Menéndez 
Marquéz, July 4, 1668; Carta del capitan Antonio de Agiielles, 
July 6, 1668 (A. G. I., 54-5-18); Governor Francisco de la 
Guerra y de la Vega to the queen, San Agustin, August 6, 1668 
(A. G. I., 54-5-9); Carta de D. Nicolas Ponce de Leon 4 la reyna 
August 6, 1668; Carta de D. francisco de la Guerra y de la Vega, 
August 8, 1668 (A. G. I., 54-5-18). 


32 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


years he was back in South Carolina, and 
ready once more to annoy the Spaniards. 

Cayagua harbor and not Port Royal was 
now chosen for the seat of a colony, and there 
in 1670 Kiawah (Charlestown, Charleston) 
was founded. The Spaniards called it San 
Jorge. A few weeks later England’s right to 
Charleston was legalized by a treaty which 
adopted the principle of actual occupation.’ 
By it Spain recognized all English settlements 
then established, but no others. 

The English colonists found themselves, as 
they complained, ‘in the very chaps of the 
Spaniards.”” And they soon felt their teeth. 
One of the vessels bound for Charleston by 
accident made anchor at Mission Santa Cata- 
lina, near the Savannah. The English were 
treated as invaders. In a skirmish several of 
the passengers were killed, and by a trick 
John Rivers and William Carr were captured. 
Governor Sayle at Charleston sent a rescue 


1 For the treaty of 1670, see Chalmers, A Collection of Treaties 
(London, 1790), II, 35; Calvo, Coleccién Completa de Tratados 
(Paris, 1862), I, 162; Herstlet, A Complete collection of Treaties 
and Conventions (London, 1840), vol. II, Haring, The Buccaneers 
in the West Indies in the XVII Century (New York, 1910), 196- 
197; 200, 209; Harris, F. R., Life of Edward Montagu, First Earl 
of Sandwich, 1625-1672 (London, 1912), 84-109; 209-210; 
Stevens, History of Georgia (New York, 1847, Philadelphia, 1859), 
I, 141. 


4 


) 


: 


[\ AXACAN 
2 
SEQURA MISSION 


SAN LUIS ® 


STE GENEVIEVE, & 


SS 
ails SEK 
g 
x ; “SANTA ELENA 
sOTU. = . ¢ T Ch 
is! it aay ‘ | ry A AANTACATALINA 
aS. F S 5 et : HON (ASAQ) 
7 AS Oe a BPALACHE ts rey 
1, AfISPE hey NAS Sod 


SAN AGUSTIN 


, 
tN ‘ACK 


sat 0AN PARBAL « “PUAREDO 


SANTA BARBARA® peeks \*DOLGRES. j a SN 3 ae =~ 


SINALDA 


X emoconita yg oe : S 
‘ § F MATAMORAS, 


LINARES. © 
@MAZAPIL sayy 


GUEMES @=-9 iiss. 
©SOMBRERETE CLERAS 3 HAVANA, @ Sait Cran 


‘n ontiks 1ETA race ie’, walgans is 


AN LUIS POTOSI! 
AGUAS CAUENTES @ ee VBLLES, TAMPICO 


‘SAN BLA ertinc em 


+ GUANAJUATO \ ~ eMERIDA 


© QUERETARO VALLADOUS® 


2 CAMPECHE 
~ ecouny SRO guEicg he cruz CHAMPOTON 


~ CUERNAVACA @ = @FUEBLA aaananage7/) ) 


Nd bane 
ZACATULA, , eee MS 


Map of the Carolina Grant of 1665 and of the Georgia Grant of 1732, superimposed on a map of the northern Spanish 
frontier. 


THE CONTEST FOR GUALE 33 


expedition with a blustering threat. Joseph 
Bailey and John Collins carried the message 
from the sloop to the mission. They, in turn, 
were captured, and like Rivers and Carr, were 
sent prisoners to San Agustfn.! 

Governor Guerra was alarmed. Here was 
serious business, indeed. Stay at San Jorge 
the English must not, for they were on 
Spanish soil. So three frigates were equipped 
and put under command of Juan Menéndez 
Marqués. Fourteen pirogues rowed by Indi- 
ans accompanied the ships. When on August 
18 the crimson and gold waved off Cayagua 
harbor there seemed little hope for San Jorge. 
But the mighty Atlantic intervened to protect 


1¥For the capture of Rivers, Carr, Bailey, and Collins and 
their experience at San Agustin, see Shaftesbury Papers, 135, 169, 
170, 199, and index; W. E. Dunn, ‘Letter from Joseph Baily,” 
December 12, 1672 (South Carolina Historical and Genealogical 
Magazine, XVIII, pp. 54-56, no. 1, January, 1917. See below); 
Colonial Records of North Carolina, I, 207 (Raleigh, 1886); 
McCrady, op. cit., 126-129; Declaraciones de los Yngleses, San 
Agustin, October, 1671 (A. G. I., 58-1-26); Governor Manuel de 
Zendoya to the crown, March 24, 1672 (A. G. I., 54-5-11); 
Joseph Bailey to the ambassador from England to Spain, San 
Agustin, December 12, 1672; filed with the original English 
letter is a Spanish translation (A. G. I., 58-1-26); Certificacién 
sobre defuncion del Ingles D. Juan de Rivera, San Agustin, 
March 8, 1675 (A. G. I., 54-5-11); Salazar to the crown, January 
20, 1677; Salazar to the crown, March 6, 1680, enclosing declara- 
tions of five English prisoners at San Agustin (A. G. I., 58-1-26). 


34 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


the infant colony. A heavy sea carried away 
the cables of the Spanish frigates and they 
withdrew to San Agustin.! 

Charleston was safe for the moment. But 
for years the settlers lived in dread. Indian 
disturbances were charged to Spanish com- 
plicity. The danger was increased by run- 
away white servants and negro slaves. Fear 
was mingled with anger.2 Then arose the cry 
that ““Wallie”’ with its hated missions must be 
destroyed. Destroyed they were in due time. 

The English intrusion, coupled with fierce 
pirate raids, stimulated a Spanish program of 
defense. At Santa Catalina a garrison was 
now established beside the mission. It was 
the founding of Charleston that introduced 
the stone age at San Agustin. Hitherto the 
old fort had been a wooden structure. But 
now a crisis had arisen. Funds were appro- 


1The expedition of Marqués against Charleston is briefly 
treated in Hchagaray’s Memorial, 1684, paragraph 1 (A. G. L., 
61-6-20); Report of Guerra, Madrid, July 12, 1673 (A. G. I., 
58-1-26); see also Shaftesbury Papers, 178, 194, 198-199; 
McCrady, Carolina under the Proprietary Government, 130; 
Carroll, B. R., Historical Collections of South Carolina, II, 370 
(New York, 1836). 


* Uneasiness at Charleston over the Spanish border in 1671- 
1672 is reflected in the Journal of the Grand Council of South 
Carolina, August 25, 1671-June 24, 1680 ek by A. S. Salley, 
Jr.), pp. 8-9, 14, 22, 45. 


THE CONTEST FOR GUALE — 35 


priated, stone was quarried, lime kilns were 
opened, and an engineer and artisans brought 
from Havana. Indians were levied from 
Guale, Timucua, and Apalache to work on 
the fortification. Sleepy old San Agustin 
was stirred to new life. Delays occurred, but 
when Quiroga came (1687) as governor he 
found “completed in the main’ the great 
castle which still stands at San Agustin, a 
monument to Spain’s determination.2 

For a decade the English cloud hovered 
over Santa Catalina, guardian of, the Guale 


1 Defensive measures in Guale and San Agustin are treated 
in two letters of Governor Ponce de Leén to the queen, July 8, 
1673 (A. G. I., 58-1-26); an undated summary of defensive 
efforts, ca. 1675, in Brooks, The Unwritten History of Old St. 
Augustine, pp. 130-135; Zendoya to the king, December 15, 1672 
(Ibid., 115-117); Carta del Comisario general de indias sobre los 
religiosos que asisten en la provincia de Santa Helena de la 
Florida, May 2, 1673 (A. G. I., 54-5-20); Salazar to the king, 
June 15, 1675 (Brooks, op. cit., 125-129); Salazar to the king, 
August 23, 1675 (Brooks, op. cit., 121-123); to the sovereign, 
November 23, 1675 (Brooks, op. cit., 123-125); Quiroga to the 
king, December 20, 1687 (A. G. I., 2-4-1/19, no. 17). 


2 Defensive measures at Apalache during the same period are 
discussed in Salazar to the queen, June 15, 1675 (A. G. I., 54-5- 
11); Salazar to the king, September 6, 1677 (A. G. I., 58-1-26); 
same to same, November 10, 1678 (A. G. I., 54-5-11); Salazar 
to the king, March 6, 1680, enclosing plans for the fort at San 
Marcos; Instructions by Salazar to Henrique Primo de Rivera 
for building a redoubt at San Marcos, December 3, 1678; Cabrera 
to the king, October 7, 1682 (A. G. I., 58-1-26). 


36 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


border. England and Spain were nominally 
at peace, but this did not prevent Carolinian 
trade and intrigue with the Indians. Old 
Barbadians in Carolina proceeded as if they 
were still “beyond the line.” The Guale 
missions were a menace, and their neophytes 
would make good slaves on Carolina planta- 
tions. Savage allies were eager to join in the 
work of destruction. 

Early in 1680 the storm broke across the 
Savannah. Three hundred Indians headed 
by Englishmen attacked Mission Santa Cata- 
lina. Led by Captain Fuentes, commander 
of the guard, the inhabitants rallied to the 
defense. Taking refuge in the monastery, 
for nearly a whole day they withstood a siege. 
Governor Salazar despatched a relief vessel 
with fifty-eight men, but when they reached 
Santa Catalina the enemy had retired.! 

The frightened neophytes forthwith de- 
serted the mission. Some hurried south to 


1 For the attack on Santa Catalina, see Salazar to the king, 
March 6, 1680, enclosing the declarations of five runaway 
Englishmen (A. G. I., 58-1-26); same to same, May 14, 1680 
(A. G. I., 58-1-26); printed in Serrano y Sanz, Documentos 
Histéricos de la Florida y la Louisiana (Madrid, 1912), pp. 216- 
219. Badly translated in Brooks, The Unwritten History of Old 
St. Augustine, 187-139; Juan Marqués Cabrera to the king, 
December 8, 1680 (A. G. I., 54-5-11). 


THE CONTEST FOR GUALE = 37 


Zapala. Others fled west and took refuge on 
the Chattahoochee border. With the Indians, 
or close behind them, Fuentes and his soldiers 
withdrew to Zdpala.t. Governor Cabrera sent 
more soldiers thither, with orders to construct 
a casa fuerte. It is apparently the remains of 
this fort that are plainly visible on Zdpala 
Island to-day and are known as ‘The Old 
Sugar House.” To hold Santa Catalina, the 
King ordered families sent from the Canary 
Islands; but through various mishaps they 
failed to arrive. Cabrera was instructed to 
observe the treaty of 1670, which had yielded 
Charleston to England; but to repel and even 
pursue all intruders beyond the line. But this 
stern command did not prevent Lord Cardross 
from establishing a Scotch colony at Port 
Royal (1683).2 


1For the retreat to Zdpala, see Captain Fuentes to the 
governor, ZApala, February 7, 1681; same to same, May 4, 1681; 
Cabrera to the Father Provincial, May 10, 1681; Cabrera to the 
king, June 14, 1681 (A. G. I., 54-5-11); The Proprietors of 
Carolina to the governor and council, Calendar of State Papers, 
Colonial, America and West Indies, March 7, 1681, No. 37; the 
king of Spain to Cabrera and to the president of the Canaries, 
November 10, 1681 (A. G. I., 61-6-20). Pirate attacks are briefly 
summarized in the Memorial by Echagaray, pp. 4-5 (A. G. I., 
61-6-20). 

2For the establishment of Lord Cardross’s colony, see 
McCrady, South Carolina Under the Proprietary Government, 
195-196. 


38 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


The reoccupation of Santa Catalina, or 
even the strengthening of Zapala, was put out 
of question by the tightening of the hold of 
Carolina traders on the Guale Indians, and 
by savage attacks of English and French free- 
booters all along the coast. English trade 
in Indian slaves grew at an appalling rate. 
The Carolinians purchased captives and thus 
encouraged the tribes to make war on their 
southern neighbors. In this way the Yamas- 
sees were won over and turned against the 
Timucua mission Indians. The heathen 
Yamassees moved in a body to Santa Elena, 
and the disaffection spread to their Chris- 
tianized relatives in the Guale missions. 

Simultaneously a staggering blow was 
given the missions by pirate raids. In 1683 


1¥For the pirate raid of 1683 the manuscript materials are 
voluminous. See especially: Razon de lo sucedido, May 20, 
1683 (A. G. I., 54-5-11); Royal cédula to governor of Florida, 
February 26, 1684 (A. G. I., 61-6-20); Cérdova to the king, 
May 20, 1685 (A. G. I, 58-2-6). For plans to remove the 
Guale Indians southward, see Cabrera to the king, June 28, 
1683; Consulta del consejo, February 10, 1684; Royal cédula to 
Cabrera, March 28, 1684 (A. G. I., 58-1-26); Cabrera to the king, 
August 26, 1684, with autos, decrees, and report of the juntas 
of August 21-22 (A. G. I, 54-5-11, No. 118). The raid of 
September-October, 1684, is set forth at length in a petition by 
Pérez de la Mota with accompanying proceedings in the Ranson 
case (A. G. I., 58-2-6). See also McCrady, South Carolina 
Under the Proprietary Government, 204-206. 


THE CONTEST FOR GUALE — 39 


the notorious ‘Abraham’? (Agramont) 
plundered the missions of southern Guale, 
despoiled them of provisions, carried off 
church bells and ornaments, and killed neo- 
phytes. The survivors fled to the forests. 
When the scare was over the southern Guale 
missions were nearly ruined. Next year a 
Carolina vessel entered the harbor at Gual- 
quini mission and created a new terror. 
During another raid by the pirate Hinckley 
(October, 1684) the soldiers and Indians fled 
from Zapala to the mainland. 

Cabrera now endeavored to remove the 
remaining Guale missions southward to the 
Islands of Santa Maria and San Juan. But 
councils were divided. The missionaries, 
zealous and unafraid, opposed the removal. 
Some of the Indians sided with the padres 
and others with the officials. In the turmoil 
many of the neophytes of Zdpala, San Simon, 


1 For the relations of the Carolinians with the Westoes and 
Yamassees, see Calendar of State Papers, Colonial, America and 
West Indies, September 30, 1683, No. 1284; November 6, 1683, 
No. 1364; June 3, 1684, No. 1722; February 21, 1685, No. 28. 
See also No. 83; West to Cabrera, July 8, 1685 (A. G. I., 58-1- 
26, Doc. 82); Crane, “The Southern Frontier in Queen Anne’s 
War” (American Historical Review, XXIV, April, 1919). For a 
statement of the reason for the Yamassees’ flight to Carolina see 
Fray Joseph Ramén Escudero to Marqués de Monteleén, 
London, October 20, 1734 (MS.). 


40 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Tupique and Asao fled with the heathen 
Yamassees to the Scotch colony at Santa 
Elena. Led by Chief Altamaha, and en- 
couraged and outfitted by Lord Cardross, 
the Yamassees now made a raid clear across 
Guale to the Timucua missions west of San 
Agustin (February, 1685). At Santa Catalina 
de Afuica early one morning they sacked the 
mission, killed some of the inhabitants, and 
carried off others to be sold as slaves. When 
they returned, the raiders were met at the 
Savannah by Lord Cardross and his men, 
eager to buy their plunder. 

These and other disturbances helped Ca- 
brera to carry out his plan for removing the 


1For the Yamassee raid on Timucua, see Juan Marqués 
Cabrera a Su Magestad, April 15, 1685 (A. G. I., 58-2-6, Doe. 
No. 2); Autos Se la entrada do los Enemigos Yngleses En las 
prou.** de Timucua, Apalachicoli, y Caueta. Y obstilidades q. 
Yntentan Hazer. Afio 1685 y 1686. This contains Carta del 
then.te de la prou.* de timucua, March 16, 1685, and autos 
giving testimony of witnesses (A. G. I., 58-1-26, Doc. No. 82) 
Copia testimoniada. Los Oficiales Reales a Su Magestad, 
September 30, 1686 (A. G. I., 54-5-19, Doc. No. 65); Calendar 
of State Papers, Colonial, America and West Indies, February 21, 
1685, no. 28; No. 83; Arredondo, Demostracién, Ch. 5; Shea, The 
Catholic Church in the United States, I, 178; Barcia, Ensayo 
Cronolégico, 287; one writer confused this Timucuan mission of 
Santa Catalina with the one in northern Georgia then abandoned. 
Colleton to Quiroga, undated letter (A. G. I., 58-1-26). 


THE CONTEST FOR GUALE 41 


Guale missions. In the summer of 1686 the 
pirate Agramont again appeared on the coast 
and spread new terror. At the same time a 
rumor was afloat that the English were 
coming to destroy what was left of Guale. 
Glad of protection now, most of the remaining 
neophytes consented to move south to Santa 
Maria, San Juan, and Santa Cruz islands, 
which correspond to-day to Amelia Island, 
Talbot Island and the coast land to the south- 
ward. Simultaneously the military head of 
the province was moved from Zdpala to Santa 
Maria. With the removal of the missions the 
name Guale was extended southward to 
include the new district. 

Old Guale was ruined. But not without a 
counter blow by Cabrera. He was between 
pirates and Carolinians—who were not en- 
tirely distinct. With three vessels he sent 
Thomas de Leén against Carolina (1686). 
There were a hundred Spaniards in the party 
and an auxiliary force of Indians. In Sep- 


1For the withdrawal to Santa Marfa see Swanton, J. R., 
Early History of the Creek Indians, 92, citing a royal letter of 
September 9, 1688, in the Brooks MSS.; Carta de Aviso, by 
Andrés Hern4ndez to Cabrera, August 1, 1686 (A. G. I., 61-6-20. 
Delgado expediente, p. 97); royal officials to crown, October 4, 
1686 (A. G. I., 54-5-15. Doc. 33); Arredondo, Ch. 5; Barcia, 
Ensayo Cronolégico, p. 284. 


42 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


tember they assaulted and completely de- 
stroyed the hated Scotch Colony at Port 
Royal, which had caused so much damage.! 
Some of the settlers they killed; others they 
captured and plundered. The rest found 
refuge by flight to Charleston. Among the 
slain was the Indian chief from whom our old 
friend Woodward had received his grant of 
Santa Elena. Continuing north, at Edisto 
Island, De Leén sacked Governor Morton’s 
plantation, burned seven houses, and carried 
off thirteen slaves, besides other plunder 
amounting to 3,000 pounds sterling. Charles- 
ton came next; but once more nature inter- 
vened to save it from the Spaniards. In a 
hurricane De Ledén’s vessel, the Rosario, was 
cast ashore, and he with others perished. A 


1 For the attack on Port Royal, see Andrés de Munibe to the 
king, Havana, February 12, 1687, transmitting declarations of 
Pedro Hortelano, Joseph Juan, and others (Delgado expediente, 
A. G. I., 61-6-20, p. 1). Cabrera to the king, October 6, 1687 
(A. G. I., 58-1-26, no. 113). The account contained in these 
documents is confirmed in all its essential details, including the 
hurricane and the stranding of the vessels, in the “Introduction 
to the Report on General Oglethorpe’s Expedition,” in Carroll, 
Hist. Coll., II, 350. See also McCrady, South Carolina under the 
Proprietary Government, 216-217; Rivers, William J., A Sketch. 
of the History of South Carolina to the Close of the Proprietary 
Government by the Revolution of 1719 (Charleston, 1856), 143, 144; 
Appendix, 425-443; Carroll, Hist. Collections, I, 83. 


THE CONTEST FOR GUALE 43 


second vessel was beached by the storm and 
then burned. In it perished a captive 
brother-in-law of the governor. With the 
third vessel the expedition limped back to 
San Agustin. Cabrera was even with Lord 
Cardross. 

The destruction of Port Royal came in the 
midst of squabbling at Charleston. Half 
angry, half frightened, the colonists rose up 
in arms. They appealed to the Proprietors; 
they complained of “unpreparedness.” In a 
Parliament it was decided to strike a counter 
blow. Two French buccaneering vessels were 
fitted out and manned with two hundred good 
pirates and three hundred Carolinians. But 
the expedition did not sail.1. England and 
Spain were nominally at peace, and the new 
governor, James Colleton, promised a noosed 
rope for anyone who might persist in the 


1¥or the failure of plans for a counter blow, see Governor 
Richard Cony to the Earl of Sunderland, December 2, 1686, 
Calendar of State Papers, Colonial, America and West Indies, No. 
1029. The Proprietors to Colleton, March 3, 1687, zbid., No. 
1161; same to same, October 10, 1687, ibid., No. 1457; McCrady, 
South Carolina under the Proprietary Government, 218-229. 
Rivers, A Sketch of the History of South Carolina, Appendix, 425, 
443, 444. Barcfa, Ensayo Cronoldgico, 286; Carroll, Hist. Coll., 
II, 350. For the activities of some of the buccaneers between 
1680 and 1690 see Jameson, J. F., Privateering and Piracy in the 
Colonial Period: Illustrative Documents (N. Y., 1923), 84-147. 


4 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


enterprise. The Proprietors in England ap- 
proved Colleton’s stand. The Carolinians 
themselves were to blame, they said. Charles- 
ton had harbored pirates; the Scots had 
abetted the Yamassees. The Carolinians 
could only smother their wrath and await a 
better day. 


CHAPTER IV 


THE CONTEST FOR WESTERN GEORGIA 
(1680-1725) 


The Spaniards had been driven from old 
Guale. Meantime a similar contest in the 
hinterland had begun. From Charleston the 
English traders led the onslaught. From 
Apalache (Tallahassee) the Spanish mission- 
aries and soldiers went forth to stem the tide. 

To the westward the Georgia tribes beck- 
oned the Englishmen across the Savannah to 
a life of adventure and freedom, and to 
profitable trade in skins and slaves. ‘The 
trails through their villages led to fabled 
mines of silver and gold, and to the shores of 
the great Spanish Lake (the Gulf of Mexico), 
on which more than one English buccaneer 
had already sailed. Relentlessly the Caro- 
linians advanced. In vain the Spaniards tried 
to hold them back. The game was played by 
diplomacy, trade, and war. The chief pawn 
in the sport was the Red Man between. 


46 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Each year the Carolinians visited tribes more 
and more remote. Charleston was not a year 
old when Dr. Henry Woodward visited Cufi- 
tachiqui. Four years later he crossed the 
Savannah to the Westoes.! 

The Spaniards were on the qui vive. In 
the very year when Woodward crossed the 
middle Savannah (1674) the Apalachicolas 
(Lower Creeks, the English called them) 
opportunely asked for missionaries. There 
may have been some connection between the 
two events. These tribes lived on the middle 
Chattahoochee below the falls. They had 
made more than one such petition in vain, 
but now their voice was heard. The English 
danger served as a magna vox. So to the 
Apalachicola Confederacy Fray Juan Océn 
and two newcomers were sent in 1679 to set 


1¥or the early explorations of the Virginians in the West, 
see Alvord and Bidgood, The First Explorations of the Trans- 
Allegheny Region by the Virginians, 1650-1674 (Cleveland, 1912), 
For Woodward’s journey to Cufitachiqui in 1670, see Shaftesbury 
Papers, 183, 201, 265, 216-217; for his expedition to Virginia in 
1671, see zbid., 210, 220, 300-307, 337-338, 345, 349; his visit to 
the Westoes in 1674 is treated ibid., 441, 448, 445, 446, 456-462. 
See also Calendar of State Papers, Colonial, America and West 
Indies, April 10, 1677, nos. 176, 177, 180; McCrady, South Caro- 
lina under the Proprietary Government, 177. For early Carolina 
Indian trade, see Crane, V. W., American Historical Review, 
XXIV, 379-380. 


WESTERN GEORGIA 47 


up the Cross at Sdbacola, a village on the 
Chattahoochee a few leagues below the falls. 
Their hopes were destined to a shock. The 
Gran Cacique, or Emperor, of the Cavetas 
(Cowetas), head tribe of the Confederacy, had 
not been consulted. Three days after the 
friars arrived this potentate descended the 
river and ordered them out. Heavy-hearted, 
Father Océn and his companions withdrew to 
Apalache. 

Hard-fisted Cabrera now became governor. 
The trouble, he concluded, was that the 
friars had gone to Sdabacola without soldiers. 
So in March, 1681, two wide-brimmed Fran- 
ciscans, accompanied by seven uniformed 
infantrymen, rowed up the Chattahoochee 
once more to Sdbacola. In May Father 
Gutiérrez wrote glowing accounts of success.! 
He had hopes of baptizing even the Gran 
Cacique himself. But his dream soon faded. 


1 For early relations with the Apalachicolas and the founding 
of the Sdébacola mission, see Castro to the King of Spain, August 
22, 1639; Arangufz to the King of Spain, September 8, 1662 
(A. G. I, 54-5-10); Hita Salazar to the king, November 23, 
1675; Hita Salazar to the king, March 8, 1680; Cabrera to the 
king, December 8, 1680; Carta de Fray Pedro Gutiérrez, May 
19, 1681; Cabrera to the king, two letters, June 14, 1681; Carta 
de Fray Miguel Abengojar, July 3, 1681 (A. G. I., 54-5-11); 
same to same, October 7, 1682 (ibid., Doc. no. 95). 


48 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Within a few months the Indians became 
hostile, and soldiers and friars withdrew. 
English influence was suspected by the Span- 
iards. Cabrera threatened and a compromise 
resulted. The Christianized portion of the 
Sébacolas moved down the river to the junc- 
tion of the Chattahoochee and the Pedernales 
(Flint). There they were established in the 
mission of Santa Cruz de Sdbacola, near the 
recently formed mission of the Chastots. 

The English tide rolled on. Carolinians fell 
out with the Westoes and by 1682 the tribe 
had been practically exterminated.:! The way 
was open now for the English traders to the 
Apalachicolas. Woodward again led the van. 
With half a dozen hardy followers, in the 
summer of 1685 he was on the Chattahoochee, 
where he introduced himself to the Gran 
Cacique at Caveta. His presence there 
brought on another border clash with the 
Spaniards. The documents incident to it 


1For troubles of the Carolinians with the Westoes, see 
Calendar of State Papers, Colonial, America and West Indies, May 
17, 1680, No. 1357; February 21, 1681, Nos. 26 and 27; March 7, 
1681, No. 37; March 9, 1681, No. 39. For Woodward’s com- 
mission, see ibid., May 10, 1682, No. 499; for his pardon, ibid., 
May 23, 1682, No. 518. See also Crane, V. W., American 
Anthropologist, N. S. XX, 331; Swanton, Early History of the 
Creek Indians, 307. 


? x fo lf Ge Belg opr ee, 
Csua Esplanta dela Cosa fuerte quewhico Cnlarnr¥ wbvalache colg 
_ 4 3 pera i 7 4 


_ —_ 


Plan of the Apalachicola Fort, 1689. From the original in the 
Spanish Archives. 


WESTERN GEORGIA 49 


bring the Apalachicolas at that period out of 
hazy conjecture into the clear light of history. 
The Anglo-Spanish contest for western Geor- 
gia thus begun lasted till 1763. 


News of Woodward’s doings caused a stir | 


at Apalache. Antonio Matheos, commander 
there, now assumed the character of defender 
of the Chattahoochee border. Governor 
Cabrera sent soldiers to reinforce the Apalache 
garrison. Without awaiting them Matheos 
hurried west and north with a force of 
Spaniards and two hundred and fifty mission 
Indians. His primary aim was to capture 
Woodward and his men and to punish the 
vassals of Spain who had admitted these 
foreigners. On his way up the Chattahoochee 
to the falls, where Columbus now stands, he 
passed through eight or more of the villages 
which later were known to the English as the 
Lower Creeks. Their location was very much 
the same as that which they occupied a 
century later. 

Indians and Englishmen fled. Of all the 
chiefs Old Pentocolo, of the village of Apala- 
chicola, alone dared risk his neck. Before he 
went in hiding Woodward penned a defiant 
note to Matheos declaring that next time he 


a 


50 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


would be strong enough to stand his ground. 
“T am very sorry that I came with so small a 
following that I cannot await your arrival. 
Be informed that I came to get acquainted 
with the country, its mountains, the seacoast, 
and Apalache. I trust in God that I shall 
meet you gentlemen later when I have a larger 
following. September 2, 1685. Vale.” Near 
the falls Matheos destroyed a_ half-finished 
stockade built by the Indians under the 
direction of the Englishmen. Leaving spies in 
the country, he then returned to San Luis, 
after nearly a month’s futile chase. 

Woodward no doubt smiled as Matheos 
withdrew. Scarcely had the Spaniards turned 
their backs when the Englishmen emerged 
from their hiding places and began to operate 
once more in the Apalachicola towns. The 
news was carried to Matheos by the spies. 
So back he posted late in December with a 
larger force than before. Cabrera’s wrath was 
now stirred, and he ordered Matheos, in case 
the Indians refused to deliver the Englishmen, 
to burn their towns. 


1 The first expedition of Matheos is set forth in Woodward’s 
defiant note to Matheos, September 2, 1685 (A. G. I., 584-23); 
Matheos to Governor Cabrera, Casista, September 21, 1685; 
Domingo de Leturiondo to Cabrera, San Luis, November 5, 
1685 (A. G. I., 58-1-26, Doc. 82). 


WESTERN GEORGIA 51 


This time Matheos went overland to 
Sdbacola el Grande. Crossing the Chatta- 
hoochee there, he went by roundabout trails 
in an endeavor to make a surprise attack on 
the Englishmen. Near Caveta he confiscated 
from a blockhouse five hundred deerskins and 
other merchandise belonging to the invaders. 
But his efforts to capture Woodward and his 
men were in vain. Once more they and the 
natives had taken to the woods. 

Aided by Chief Pentocolo Matheos now 
summoned the absconding headmen to Caveta. 
Eight villages reluctantly responded, but the 
chiefs of the four northern towns stubbornly 
refused to appear. The eight towns which 
submitted were pardoned. The others—Ca- 
veta, Casista, Tasquique, and Colone—were 
burned to ashes. While the embers were 
still smoking Matheos returned homeward. 
Thirty disabled men he sent down the | 
Chattahoochee in canoes. With the rest he / 
went to San Luis by land.! ——! 


1 For Matheos’s second expedition to Caveta, see Matheos to 
Cabrera, Caveta, January 12, 1686; San Luis, February 8, 1686; 
San Lufs, March 14, 1686; Cabrera to the viceroy, March 19, 1686 
(A. G. I., 584-23); Cabrera to the viceroy, March 19, 1686 
(A. G. I., 58-1-26, Doc. 102). 


52 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


The destroyed towns repented, and five 
weeks after Matheos returned Pentocolo was 
sent to ask mercy for them. But Matheos 
suspected crocodile tears. His suspicions were 
well founded, for as soon as the Spaniards left 
Caveta the Englishmen once more emerged 
from their hiding places and continued to 
trade. Some of them soon returned to Charles- 
ton, leaving Woodward ill at Casista. Late in 
summer he too departed, carried on a stretcher 
by the Indians, and followed by one hundred 
and fifty Apalachicola braves laden with 
peltry.1. On their way home four of his men 
were killed and plundered by Guale Indians, 
allies of the Spaniards. The English traders 
to Apalachicola were not yet safe from a 
flank attack. 

Woodward never returned to the Apala- 
chicolas, it seems, but he had shown the way, 


1 For the repentance of the Apalachicolas, the return of the 
English to the Apalachicolas, and of Woodward and his men to 
Charleston, see Cabrera to the king, March 22, 1686; same to 
same, May 29, 1686 (A. G. I., 58-1-26, docs. 104, 106); Matheos 
to Cabrera, San Luis, May 19, 1686; same to same, May 21, 
1686; Cabrera to viceroy, June 2, 1686; the viceroy to the king, 
July 19, 1686; junta de guerra, Mexico, July 20, 1686 (all in 
A. G. I., 584-23); Cabrera to the viceroy, July 22, 1686; Matheos 
to Cabrera, August 21, 1686 (both in A. G. I., 616-20); Cabrera 
to the king, November 8, 1686, with enclosures (A. G. I., 54-5-12, 
doc. 39). 


WESTERN GEORGIA 53 


and next season other Carolinians went to 
the Chattahoochee. Cabrera sent a third 
expedition to capture them. When Quiroga 
became governor (1687) the Apalachicolas 
complained bitterly of the burning of their 
towns. Quiroga consoled them and they 
renewed their allegiance. But this did not 
keep the English out. They kept coming each 
season and Quiroga in turn was forced to send 
two expeditions to capture them. Five such 
campaigns had thus been made against these 
Carolina traders in less than five years. But 
they were all in vain. The Anglomen were 
fully protected by the natives, for they had 
good merchandise at low prices. 

There was only one thing to be done, said 
Quiroga. A garrison must be established on 
the Chattahoochee. To build the fort, late 
in 1689 he sent Captain Primo de Rivera. 
It was placed at the village of Apalachicola, 
south of Caveta. At the end of two months 
it was completed, with stockade, parapet, 
ditch and four bastions. To guard it Fabian 
de Angulo was left with twenty soldiers and 
twenty Apalache Indians. In an assembly 
at Caveta, in the following May, the chiefs 
promised Angulo to join hands with the 


54 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Spaniards to keep the English out. They 
now had ‘“‘but one word and one heart,” both 
Spanish.? 

The Spanish policy seemed for a moment 
to have succeeded. In reality it had mis- 
carried. The burning of the towns and the 
establishment of the fort in their midst were 
designed to keep the Indians loyal and the 
English out. Neither result followed. Instead 
the Indians were alienated. Most of them 
now abandoned their homes on the Chatta- 
hoochee and moved eastward to join the 
Uchis on the Ocmulgee. Thither the English 
promptly followed them. The Ocmulgee now 
became known to the English as Ocheese 
(Uchis) Creek, and the Indians as the Creeks. 
In Spanish circles, in a similar way, the 
Apalachicolas gradually became known as 
Uchis. 


1 For Spanish relations with the Apalachicolas during 1687— 
1690 and the building of the fort, see Quiroga to the king, April 
1, 1688 (A. G. I., 54-5-12, doc. 61, published in Serrano y Sanz, 
Documentos Histéricos de la Florida y la Luisiana, 219-221); 
Quiroga to the king, April 15, 1688; same to same, September 
29, 1689; same to same, June 8, 1690, with accompanying docu- 
ments relative to the building of the fort (with drawing), on the 
Chattahoochee (A. G. I., 54-5-12); same to same, August 21, 
1690 (A. G. I., 54-5-13, Doc. 18, A.B.C.). 


WESTERN GEORGIA 55 


It is the records of a dispute which reveal 
this new information concerning the migra- 
tion of the Creeks.1 Quiroga asked the pro- 
vincial for missionaries for the new outpost 
on the Chattahoochee. An argument ensued. 
Father Luna maintained that the Indians, 
afraid of the garrison, had fled east, ‘‘to find 
favor with the English.” Quiroga denied the 
charge. He was able to prove that some of 
the Apalachicolas were still on the Chatta- 
hoochee; but it is equally clear by his own 
admission that some of them had moved east 


1 Both Swanton and Crane were unable to determine the 
location of the Lower Creeks before 1690. Both have left the 
question a matter of speculation. Swanton writes: “South 
Carolina documents place this tribe [the Kasihta] on Ocheese 
Creek in 1702, Ocheese Creek being an old name for the upper 
part of the Ocmulgee, and it seems probable from an examination 
of the Spanish documents that they were settled there as early 
as 1680-1685.’’ Commenting on Matheos’s report of May 19, 
1686, Swanton infers that the four towns burned by Matheos 
were probably on the Ocmulgee. Of course his conclusion is 
incorrect (Swanton, J. R., Harly History of the Creek Indians, 220- 
221 (Washington, 1922). In another connection Swanton says 
that in 1681 the Coweta were living in the neighborhood of Butts 
County, Georgia. Jbid., 307; Crane, V. W. (‘“The Southern 
Frontier During Queen Anne’s War,’ Am. Hist. Rev., XXIV, 
381), implies that the Kawita and Kasihta (which he makes 
synonymous with Oconee and Ocheese) were on the Oconee in 
1684. For the naming of the Lower Creeks see Crane, Missis- 
sippi Valley Historical Review, V, 339. For the identity of the 
Westo, see Crane, American Anthropologist, N. S., XX, 331. 


56 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


to the Uchis. Thus is solved the mystery of 
the appearance of the Lower Creeks on the 
Ocmulgee. 

The Apalachicola presidio was short-lived. 
In the summer of 1691 corsairs again threat- 
ened San Agustin. Soldiers were sorely needed 
and the garrison was withdrawn. In order 
that the English on the “Rio de Uchise”’ 
might not occupy it, the fort was destroyed 
and even the ditches filled in.! 

The defection of the Apalachicolas from 
Spanish allegiance did not end with the 
desertion of their home lands. It turned into 
active war on the missions of Apalache and 
Timucua, and on the Indians there who had 
taken part in the burning of their towns. 
Englishmen lived among the Apalachicolas, 
stirred them up, and even led them in their 
assaults. Torres, the new governor, launched 
another campaign (1694), in which fifty 
captives were taken. A lively dispute now 


1 For the call for missionaries, the abandonment of the fort, 
and the eastward migration of the Apalachicolas, see Quiroga to 
the king, April 10, 1692 (A. G. L., 54-5-18, Doc. No. 32); same 
to same, April 18, 1792 (ibid., Doc. 36); same to same April 30, 
1692 (ibid., Doc. 42). 

* Swanton (p. 221), citing Serrano y Sanz, gives the date of 
Torres’s expedition as 1695, but the documents show that it was 
in 1694. 


WESTERN GEORGIA 57 


followed over boundaries. Governors Smith 
and Blake claimed the Apalachicola country 
for Carolina. Torres branded the claims as 
preposterous. Archdale was conciliatory, but 
he warned the Spaniards to keep out of 
Apalachicola.! 

While Spaniards fought and protested, the 
Carolina Indian trade grew apace. English- 
men soon passed beyond the Chattahoochee 
to the Alabamas and Chickasaws.2 The 
rapidity of their advance was an index of the 
growing demand for Indian slaves. The 
climax of greed was reached while Moore was 


1¥For Apalachicola relations and boundary disputes, 1694— 
1700, see Torres to Governor Smith, August 5, 1694 (A. G. L, 
58-1-26, No. 182). Torres to the king, March 11, 1695 (A. G. 
I., 58-1-26, Doc. 130, in Serrano y Sanz, Documentos Histéricos, 
224-227); Torres to the king, July 8, 1695, with related docu- 
ments concerning boundaries (A. G. I., 58-1-26, No. 132); 
Torres to Governor Archdale, January 24, 1695 (Archdale 
Papers, Library of Congress); Archdale to the Governor of 
Florida, January 24, 1696; same to same, April 4, 1696 (Archdale 
Papers, Library of Congress); Torres to the king, February 7, 
1697 (A. G. I., 58-1-26, Doc. 131). 

2 For the Carolina Indian trade in the last decade of the 
century, see Crane, American Historical Review, XXIV, 379- 
882. See also Carroll, Hist. Coll., II, 88-89, 107-108, 118-121; 
Journal of the Council of South Carolina, December 12, 1699; 
E. Randolph to the Lords of Trade, in Rivers, A Sketch of the 
History of South Carolina, 443. A Carolina view of Moore’s 
trading activities is given in a “‘Representation and Address,” 
printed in Rivers, zbid., 455-456. 


58 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


governor (1700-1702). A new impetus was 
given to the traffic by the settlement of the 
French at Biloxi. Excitable Carolinians feared 
a French attack on Charleston. Some of them 
talked of fleeing to England; but the more 
manly favored a counter blow and a’ more 
aggressive trade policy. 

The Carolinians now found two rivals 
blocking the way to the Alabamas. ‘The first 
- obstacles to be removed were the Spaniards 
and Indians of Apalache. On them the Apala- 
chicola-English raids continued. In May, 
1702, the Timucua mission of Santa Fé was 
destroyed. To retaliate, Governor Zufiiga sent 
Captain Uriza with a force of Spaniards and 
eight hundred Indians against the Apalachi- 
colas and their English abettors. At that 
very moment Englishmen, headed by a 
“Captain Antonio,”’ were holding war councils 
in Caveta. A double blow was to be struck 
at the Spaniards. While a fleet captured San 
Agustin, traders and the Apalachicolas were 
to destroy Apalache. In preparation for the 
fray a fort was built at Caveta. On the same 
day that Uriza left Bacuqua, Captain Antonio 
led several hundred braves forth from Achito, 
They met near the Pedernales (Flint). By a 


WESTERN GEORGIA 59 


trick the Spanish force was defeated. The 
battle ground was strewn with dead and 
dying Apalaches; others were captured; the 
rest fled in dismay, leaving baggage behind. 
The Spanish soldiery showed nearly equal 
speed. All Florida was now terrorized. The 
Apalache settlements. were ordered consoli- 
dated close to San Luis; San Agustin was put 
under arms; and Governor Zufiiga sent calls 
for help to Spain and Mexico.! 

Zuniga’s fears were justified, for Queen 
Anne’s War was now proclaimed in America. 
Governor Moore in person led the expedition 
planned against San Agustin. As he went 
down the coast he spread devastation. The 


1¥or Uriza’s campaign, see Iberville to Francisco Martinez, 
January 3, 1702, Margry, Décowvertes et Etablissements des 
Francais dans ’ Amerique Septentrionale (Paris, 1875-1886), IV, 
579; Shea, J. G., The Catholic Church in the United States, I, 459; 
Zuniga to the king, September 30, 1702 (A. G. I., 58-1-27, Doc. 
58); Manuel Solano to the king, October 22, 1702 (Demanda 
Puesta, A. G. I., 58-2-18); Francisco Romo de Uriza to Zuiiga, 
October 22, 1702 (ibid.); autos and report regarding defence at 
San Agustin, October 27, and November 1 (ibid.). The cam- 
paign was approved in Royal Council, August 23, 1703, nearly a 
year after Uriza’s defeat (cbid.); Mitchell’s Map of 1755 (Swan- 
ton, Early History of the Creek Indians, plates 3 and 6). See also 
Crane, Am. Hist. Rev., XXIV, 385; McCrady, South Carolina 
under the Proprietary Government, 379-380; Rivers, A Sketch of 
the History of South Carolina, 199-200; Carroll, Hist. Coll., I, 
351; Swanton, Early History of the Creck Indians, 120-121. 


60 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


three transplanted Guale missions were com- 
mitted to the flames and three friars were 
captured. Thus it was that the Spanish 
frontier fell back another step, from the 
Santa Marfa to the San Juan. The Carolini- 
ans took the city of San Agustin, but after a 
siege lasting nearly a month they failed to 
capture the sturdy stone fortress outside the 
gates.! 

Moore, no longer governor, was given a 
chance to retrieve his lost reputation by a 
| new campaign against Apalache—that Apala- 
che which stood in the road to Pensacola and 
Mobile. In December, 1703, he set forth 
from Charleston. When he left the Ocmulgee 
he had in his train fifty Englishmen and a 
thousand Indian allies. The Apalache missions 
had served the red men three-quarters of a 
century; now they were doomed. The first 
blow was struck at the fortified town of 
Ayubale. Father Miranda directed the de- 
fence. The fight lasted nearly all day, and 


1 For Moore’s expedition against San Agustin, see Rivers, A 
Sketch of the History of South Carolina (Charleston, 1856), pp. 
197-204, 453-456; Crane, Am. Hist. Rev., vol. XXIV, p. 386; 
McCrady, South Carolina, 1670-1719, 378, 391; Carroll, Hist. 
Coll., II, 351-352; Shea, J. G., Catholic Church in the United 
States, 459-460; Fairbanks, History of Florida (Philadelphia, 
1871), 174; Bareia, Ensayo Cronolégico, 320. 


WESTERN GEORGIA 61 


the Spaniards yielded only when their am- 
munition gave out. Several Englishmen fell; 
twenty-five defenders were slain and over one 
hundred and fifty captured. Of his exploit 
Moore wrote, ‘‘I never see or hear of a stouter 
or braver thing done.”’ Near Ayubale Moore 
defeated Lieutenant Mexia and the garrison 
of San Luis. A number of prisoners taken 
were tortured; Father Parga was burned at 
the stake and beheaded while Mexfa looked 
on from the stocks. Shortly afterward Mexfa 
himself, Father Miranda, and four soldiers 
met a like fate. One town bought immunity 
with the church ornaments and ten horses 
loaded with provisions. Of fourteen missions 
this was the only one not destroyed.1. When 
Moore withdrew eastward he took with him 


1 For Moore’s campaign against Apalache, see Crane, Am. 
Hist. Rev., XXIV, 386-387; Moore, “An account of what the 
army did under command of Col. Moore, in his expedition last 
winter, against the Spaniards and Spanish Indians. In a letter 
from the said Col. Moore to the governor of Carolina. Printed 
in the Boston News, May 1, 1704.’’ (Carroll, Historical Collec- 
tions of South Carolina, II, 574-576; Zufiiga to the king, March 
30, 1704 (Swanton, J. R., Early History of the Creek Indians, 
122-123); letter of Bienyille to his home government (printed 
in Swanton, ibid., 123); ‘Statements made in the Introduction 
to the Report on General Oglethorpe’s Expedition to St. Augus- 
tine” (Carroll, Hist. Coll., II, 352-353); Shea, History of the 
Catholic Church in the United States, 1, 461-462; Rivers, Sketch, 
207-209. 


62 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


1400 mission Indians. Part of them were 
enslaved; the rest were established on the 
Savannah River, safely between Charleston 
and the Apalachicola allies. Moore wrote to 
Governor Johnson, ‘‘We have made Carolina 
as safe as the conquest of Apalatchia can make 
abs? 

~  Moore’s savage attack was a mortal blow 
to the Apalache missions. Later the frag- 
ments were reassembled round a new presidio 
at San Marcos, on the Gulf coast. To the end 
of Queen Anne’s War the English were free to 
live and trade among the Apalachicolas 
(Lower Creeks), whose towns—eleven in num- 
ber in 1709—were now ranged alone the 
Ocmulgee River. 

Apalache annihilated, it was the aim of the 
Carolinians next to destroy Pensacola, uproot 
the French of Mobile, and extend trade and 
dominion to the Father of Waters. In this 
great game the western Georgia Indians still 
participated; but the struggle now turned on 
the control of the Alabama Creeks, next 
beyond, and of the Chickasaws and Choctaws 
further west. English and French traders alike 
donned the war paint and conducted their 
partisans to battle. The English won over 


WESTERN GEORGIA 63 


the Alabamas, led them against Pensacola, 
and against the Choctaws who protected 
Mobile. But the able Frenchman, Bienville, 
won back the Alabamas. Peace in 1714 left 
Pensacola and Mobile intact, and the French 
secure in the Alabama basin.! 

Suddenly an event occurred which sent 
the Apalachicolas back to the Chattahoochee 
to live, and restored Spanish influence among 
them. It was a case of poetic justice. The 
Yamassees had been Carolina’s chief instru- 
ments in the destruction of Spanish Guale. 
They now headed a widespread revolt against 
the English and returned to Spanish allegiance. 
The first blow fell in May, 1715, at the Yamas- 
see town of Pocotaligo. By the middle of 
June the revolt east of the Savannah had been 
snuffed out, but not before two hundred 
Carolinians had been slain. The Yamassees 


1For the Alabama country during Queen Anne’s War, see 
Crane, ‘“The Southern Frontier in Queen Anne’s War” (American 
Historical Review, vol. XXIV, 379-395; Margry, Découwvertes et 
Etablissements des Francais, lV; Rivers, Sketch, pp. 231-237, gives 
a report on western trade in 1708. The same is given in Calendar 
of State Papers, Colonial, America and West Indies, 1708-9, p. 
468. For attacks on Pensacola in 1712, see Salinas Varona to 
the viceroy, January 16, and July 16, 1713 (A. G. L, 61-1-34, 
pp. 31-32. See also document ibid., pp. 89-90); Barcfa, Ensayo 
Cronolégico, 328. 


64 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


now fled to San Agustin where they were 
welcomed by the ringing of church bells.' 
The disaffection spread west to the Creeks 
and other tribes. Here was Spain’s chance 
and quickly she seized it. When the upris- 
ing occurred, Old Brimins, the Emperor of 
Caveta, called a council of the Lower Creek 
chiefs. They decided to make peace with the 
Spaniards. Englishmen among them were 
evicted, imprisoned, or slain. An embassy was 
sent to Pensacola.2 There on July 7, forty 
Creek chiefs and headmen delivered Spanish 
captives, and enacted peace ceremonies. Seven 
chiefs of the Western (Upper) Creeks went to 
Mexico and swore allegiance to the King in 
the presence of the viceroy. They were 
lavishly entertained and they marvelled at 


1The Yamassee-Creek war is treated by Crane, Am. Hist. 
Rev., XXIV, 394; McCrady, South Carolina under the Proprietary 
Government, 1670-1719, 513-548; Swanton, J. R., Early History 
of the Creek Indians, 97-102, 225-226. Osgood, Herbert L., 
The American Colonies in the Eighteenth Century, II, 347-352. 
(New York, 1924). Contemporary narratives are “An account 
of Missionaries sent to South Carolina” (in Carroll, Hist. Coll., 
II, 527-568); ‘‘Account of the Breaking Out of the Yamassee 
War,” Boston News, June 13, 1715 (Carroll, Hist. Coll., II, 
569-572). Escudero to Marqués de Monteleén, Spanish ambas- 
sador at London, Madrid, February 17, 1716. 


2 An anonymous French account of the uprising at Caveta is 
given in Swanton, op. cit., 225-226. The episode is made the 
theme of a novel in The Yamassee, by William Gilmore Simms. 


St. Simons (Gualquini) Sound, looking seaward. 


WESTERN GEORGIA 65 


the wonders of the metropolis of North 
America.!' Meanwhile the Lower Creeks gave 
obedience at San Agustin and made inter- 
mittent war on Carolina. 

For a decade now Spanish and English 
diplomats waged a battle for supremacy 
among the Creeks. At Caveta two factions 
formed in the Indian councils. Old Brimins, 
the Emperor, leaned toward the English; his 
son, the usingulo Chipacasi (Seepey Coffee), 
was a staunch supporter of the Spaniards. 
Numerous contests occurred between the 
Spanish and English agents who met at the 
Indian towns in the struggle for control. 
One such took place in 1717. Diego de Pefia, 
head of an embassy from San Agustfn, 
encountered a party of English traders at 
Caveta.2. The chiefs held a heated debate. 


1¥or the Creek visits to Pensacola and Mexico, see Salinas 
Varona to Governor Ayala, Pensacola, July 24, 1717 (Serrano y 
Sanz, Documentos Histéricos, 238-240); same to same, September 
9, 1717 (ibid., 240-242). 

2 For the visit to San Agustin in 1717 of the Usingulo and 
war chief Chislacaliche, see letter of Governor Ayala quoted in 
Swanton, Early History of the Creek Indians, 125. For Pefia’s 
embassy to Caveta, see ‘Diario del Viaje que hizo el Teniente 
Diego Pefia 4 Apalachicola,” beginning at Sdvacola on Sep- 
tember 20, 1717 (Serrano y Sanz, Documentos Histéricos, 227- 
237; Barcia, Ensayo Cronolégico, 329, 356-357, 361. 


66 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


The Emperor adhered to the English, his son 
to the Spaniards. Chipacasi’s oratory and 
Pefia’s whiskey were plied in vain, and Pefia 
was forced to leave under escort to prevent a 
massacre. But it was a drawn battle, for at 
the same time ten of the English party were 
expelled from Talapoosa, an Upper Creek 
town. 

This tilt is typical of the decade. A few 
months after Pefia withdrew from Caveta 
Juan Ferndndez and a party of soldiers 
escorted to their homes the Talapoosa chiefs 
who had been to Mexico City. At Teguale 
Emperor Brimins, Chipacasi, and a delega- 
tion of Lower Creek chiefs, in formal ceremony 
ratified what had been done in Mexico. The 
celebrations were interrupted by a messenger 
who told of the arrival of John Musgrove and 
thirty Englishmen at Caveta. Brimins, Fer- 
nandez and Chipacasi hurried east and another 
factional struggle ensued. In the end the 
English were expelled and the Ferndndez 
party withdrew. It was another drawn battle.! 


1The diplomatic mission of Juan Ferndéndez to the Creeks 
in 1718 is set forth at length in Barcfa, Ensayo Cronoldgico, pp. 
331-340. 


WESTERN GEORGIA 67 


Spanish influence was now strengthened 
by a new presidio at San Marcos (1718). 
Scattered Apalaches were reassembled, and 
new missions were established there. Some 
of the Creeks, too, moved south to live close 
at hand.1 But in time good bargains told in 
favor of the English. Though it was no one- 
sided matter, in 1725 Tobias Fitch made real 
progress. On an official visit for Carolina he 
went several times back and forth among the 
Upper and Lower Creeks. He organized a 
campaign against the hated Yamassees, who 
now lived under the shelter of San Agustin. 
The Upper Creeks were friendly and readily 
joined the war party, but the Lower Creeks 
were “‘unserton.”’ At Caveta Fitch encount- 
ered and struggled with a Spanish embassy 
from San Marcos. Old Brimins was still 
friendly to the English. Chipacasi had been 
loyal to Spain ever since the Yamassee up- 
rising. But now, by the aid of the Emperor, 
Fitch won him over and he joined the cam- 
paign against the Yamassees. It was a signal 


1 For the presidio and the new missions at San Marcos, see 
Barefa, Ensayo Cronolégico, 343-346, 348; Fray Joseph Ramén 
Escudero to Marqués de Monteleén, London, October 20, 1734 
(MS.); extract of the same quoted in Swanton, Early History of 
the Creek Indians, 102. 


68 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


victory. Nevertheless, the down river towns 
—Seminoles they became—still clung to 
Spain. With the rest the English were for the 
time in the ascendant, but for the next 
thirty-five years constant vigilance was the 
price of success. 


1The mission of Tobias Fitch to the Creeks is recounted in 
Mereness, Newton D., Travels in the American Colonies (New 
York, 1916), pp. 175-212. 


CHAPTER V 


DIPLOMATIC CONTROVERSIES OVER FORT 
KING GEORGE AND OGLETHORPE’S 
COLONY 


(1721-1738) 


The Yamassee-Creek war shocked the 
Carolina colony into a sense of its insecurity, 
and there followed a movement for the 
defense of the southern border. Inevitably 
this southward advance of the English brought 
on new struggles with the Spaniards. 

Sir Robert Montgomery’s fantastic scheme 
for Azilia (1718) never got beyond the paper 
stage, but it was symbolic of the desire for a 
buffer colony. Soon after Azilia went up in 
rhetoric, Colonel John Barnwell was sent to 
build Fort King George at the mouth of the 
Altamaha (1721). It was planted close to the 
site of one of the old Spanish missions. 

Now it was the Spaniard’s turn to sound 
the alarm. Governor Benavides protested to 
Governor Nicholson. On the other side of 
the Atlantic a diplomatic joust was held by 
Newcastle and Pozobueno. England stood 
on the Carolina grant of 1665, which extended 


70 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


to 29°. Spain’s reply was obvious. England 
could not grant what she did not possess. 
Charles II’s paper grant had included a line 
of Spanish settlements all the way from Santa 
Catalina to San Agustin, a stretch of one 
hundred and fifty miles... In 1670, when the 
two nations adopted the principle of actual 
possession, England did not hold a foot of 
soil south of Charleston. The debate waxed 
warm. Then Spain proposed that the gov- 
ernors of Carolina and Florida be commis- 
sioned to fix the boundary in accord with the 
treaty of 1670. England agreed, and Spain 
appointed commissioners. In March, 1725, 
Menéndez Marqués and Joseph Primo de 
Rivera arrived at Charleston. Dressed in 
their best they presented their instructions. 


1 For Azilia, see Jones, C. C., History of Georgia (Boston, 1883), 
I, 70-75; South Carolina Historical Society Collections (Charles- 
ton, 1858), II, 232-233. For Fort King George on the Alta- 
maha, see ibid., Vol. I, 232, 235, 236, 237, 239, 243, 281, 285, 
295, 296; Vol. II, 144, 148, 154, 155, 169, 170, 171, 179; Smith, 
W. R., South Carolina as a Royal Province (New York, 1903), 
208-209; McCrady, South Carolina under the Proprietary Govern- 
ment, 1670-1719, 575, 577; Carroll, B. R., Historical Collections 
of South Carolina, I, 236, 240, 254, 257-259, 269, 278, 280, 281, 
282-292. Jones, History of Georgia, (I, 68), erroneously locates 
Fort King George at the junction of the Oconee and Ocmulgee. 
For Benavides’s plan to capture Charleston in 1719, see Barcfa, 
Ensayo Cronolégico, 341-348, 350-354; McCrady, History of 
South Carolina Under Royal Government, 1719-1776, 32, 35, 53-54, 
(New York, 1899), 


DIPLOMATIC CONTROVERSIES 71 


Surprised enough they were to be told by 
President Middleton that he had no orders in 
the matter. For two more years the English 
flag waved over the Altamaha; then Fort 
King George was abandoned, but not because 
of the Spanish protest. 

The need of a buffer colony continued and 
Georgia was founded. The charter assigned 
to the Trustees the region between the 
Savannah and the Altamaha, and westward 
to the Pacific. What cared King George that 
the grant cut a wide swath through Florida, 
Louisiana, and Texas? Or that, incidentally, 
it included Albuquerque, Socorro, and other 
New Mexico settlements? Oglethorpe ar- 


1 Records of the negotiations between Newcastle and Pozo- 
bueno, and between Governor Benavides and the officials at 
Charleston (1724-1725) are given in “‘Testimonio de los autos y 
demas diligencias fechas sobre la division de los terminos de esta 
jurisdiccién, y la de Carolina, en virtud de las dos reales zédulas 
que en ellos se contienen, sus fechas 10 de junio y 18 de Agosto 
de 1724 (A. G. I., 58-1-31. Printed in Serrano y Sanz, Docu- 
mentos Histéricos de la Florida y la Luisiana, pp. 243-260.) 
See also Arredondo, Demostracién, ch. 6; Smith, South Carolina, 
208-209; Carroll, Historical Collections, I, 269-271; McCrady, 
History of South Carolina, 1719-1776, 74-78; South Carolina 
Historical Society Collections, Vol. I (1857), pp. 234-239; Jones, 
History of Georgia, I, 68-69; Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 
145; Benavides to the king, April 21, 1722, concerning Fort 
King George and the mission of Menéndez to protest, enclosing 
letter to the Governor of South Carolina, February 11, 1722 
(Brooks, op. cit., 168-170). 


72 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


rived in 1733 and Savannah quickly arose on 
the site of Musgrove’s trading post. Darien 
on the Altamaha and Frederica on St. Simons 
soon followed. The Altamaha was the south- 
ern limit of the Georgia grant, but Oglethorpe 
did not stop here. He was standard bearer 
for England, not alone for Georgia, and he had 
military ambitions. So down the coast he 
pushed his fortifications to the very shadow 
of San Agustin. 

A new diplomatic battle now took place. 
Geraldino protested in the name of Spain;? 


1 For the founding of Georgia, see McCrady, History of South 
Carolina under the Royal Government, 1719-1776, 113-115; 
Jones, History of Georgia, I, chs. 4-12; Stevens, History of Georgia, 
I, 57-140; M’Call, Hugh, History of Georgia (1811, 1816; re- 
printed, Atlanta, 1909. The reprint is here cited); Colonial 
Records of Georgia (Atlanta, 1904 to date, cited Ga. Col. Rec.), 
vol. I. For official opinion in England on pushing the forts 
beyond the Altamaha, see Diary of the First Earl of Egmont 
(Viscount Percival), Historical Manuscripts Commission, vol. I, 
1734-1738 (London, 1923), 141, 159, 181, 1838, 285-286; South 
Carolina Historical Society Collections, II, 264. For Oglethorpe’s 
return to England in 1734, see Egmont’s Diary, II, 112. For 
Tomochichi at the Court of London, zbid., 113-118, 121-126. 
For Oglethorpe’s demand for soldiers (1735), see Egmont’s 
Diary, Il, 141, 159, 166, 183, 187, 201-204. 


? For the Spanish protest against the founding of Georgia, see 
Arredondo, Demostracién, ch. 6. Fray Joseph Ramon Escudero’s 
communication to Marqués de Monteleén, Spanish ambassador 
in London, October 20, 1734, was written while Tomochici was 
there. He suggests a combination of French, Spaniards, and 
Indians to expel the English (MS., Library of Congress). 


DIPLOMATIC CONTROVERSIES 73 


Newcastle replied for England. The old 
arguments were thrashed over, and Charles 
Dempsey was sent to America to assist in the 
negotiations. Like a shuttle-cock he darted 
back and forth between Georgia and Florida. 
Oglethorpe insisted on the San Juan River as 
a boundary, and backed his demand with 
soldiers.. Then Giiemes y Horcasitas sent 
Antonio de Arredondo from Havana to Fred- 
erica to demand English retreat beyond Port 
Royal. Florida and Georgia were on the 
verge of war. At last, after many parleys, 
Oglethorpe and Governor Sdnchez signed a 
treaty.2 All boundary questions were left for 


1 This demand was made plausible, to the innocent govern- 
ment at home, by a map showing a southern mouth of the 
Altamaha debouching near the St. Marys. 


2For the Dempsey and Arredondo negotiations and the 
SAnchez treaty, see Jones, History of Georgia, I, 239-252; Stevens, 
History of Georgia, I, 145-149; Wright, Robert, A Memoir of 
General James Oglethorpe (London, 1867), chs. 8-9; Georgia 
Colonial Records, XXI, 77, 86, 104, 115, 122, 123, 144, .150, 154, 
155, 160-161, 206-207, 212, 218, 224-226, 236, 271, 284, 362- 
363 (this contains a summary), 376; XXII, Pt. I, 219; Egmont’s 
Diary, I1, 282-296, 325-326, 331; Arredondo, chapter 6, par. 19; 
Ga. Hist. Soc. Collections, VII, Pt. I, no. I, p. 7 (Savannah, 1909). 
For reports of the Georgia-Florida coast made by Arredondo after 
his visit to San Simén, and for his relations with Oglethorpe in 
1736, see Philip Lee Phillips, The Lowery Collection (Washing- 
ton, 1912), 270-275. John Wesley in his journal, mentions the 
visit of Arredondo to San Simén (Nehemiah Curnock, The 
Journal of The Rev. John Wesley, A.M., I, 267. London, 1909). 


74 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


final settlement by the royal courts, but mean- 
while Oglethorpe agreed to withdraw Fort 
St. George from St. Georges Island (San 
Juan). Oglethorpe regarded the treaty as a 
good bargain for England. Spain emphati- 
cally agreed with him, and Sdnchez, who 
signed the document, was called home and 
hanged.! 

Oglethorpe now returned to England to 
demand of the Trustees more soldiers, more 
funds, and more power.? The Trustees turned 
to Parliament and that body complied. Ogle- 
thorpe was made commander-in-chief of all 


1The text of the treaty with SAnchez is in Harris, Complete 
Collection of Voyages and Travels (London, 1748), Il, 331-332. 
Dempsey concluded two treaties. One was ratified by Sdénchez, 
the other by the Junta de Guerra at San Agustin (Ga. Col. Rec., 
I, 266). Concerning the fate of Sdnchez it is stated “That the 
late Spanish Govern™ of Augustine who made the Treaty of 
Neutrality some years ago with Gen! Oglethorpe, and had been 
therefore sent home in chains by the succeeding Gov" on that 
account, is hang’d; and that Capt Dempsy’s brother an Officer 
in the Spanish service is cashier’d because the Captain assisted 
Oglethorpe in concluding that Treaty.” (Ga. Col. Rec., vol. V, 
351); see also Egmont’s Diary, II, 326, 410. For the complaints 
against Sdnchez see Brooks, The Unwritten History of Old St. 
Augustine, 156-162. Among numerous charges the treaty with 
Oglethorpe is not mentioned. 


2 For Oglethorpe’s demands for troops and money while in 
England in 1737, see Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 150-152; 
Jones, History of Georgia, I, ch. 17; Egmont’s Diary, I1, 339, 368, 
383, 401, 414-417, 427-431, 433-438, 457, 469, 494, 501; Ga. 
Col. Rec., I, 323-324; IV, 140-151; V, 18-19. 


DIPLOMATIC CONTROVERSIES 75 


the forces of Carolina as well as of Georgia. 
He was now in effect Count of the Southern 
March. 

At this militant gesture Spain protested 
in still louder tones.:. Indeed, she prepared 
to “reannex all that formerly belonged to the 
Spanish monarchy.”’ Governor Montiano sent 
agents among the Creeks.2 Four hundred 
soldiers were dispatched to Florida, and fresh 


1For Geraldino’s two memorials, 1736, 1737, Newcastle’s 
reply, and the reaction of the Trustees of Georgia, see Egmont’s 
Diary, II, 300-304, 426-438; Coxe, Memoirs of Walpole, IV, p. 9. 
Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 148-149; Wright, Memoir, ch. 10; 
Arredondo, ch. 6, par. 33 and following; Temperley, ‘‘The 
Causes of the War of Jenkins’ Ear, 1739” (Royal Historical 
Society Transactions, Third Series, vol. III, 197-236). Montiano 
aided the Spanish diplomats with documents at San Agustin 
bearing on the “right and title of Your Majesty to the colonies 
illegally occupied by the English.” Among other things was a 
map based on the knowledge of persons acquainted with the 
coast (Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., VII, Part III, 16-18. Savannah, 1913). 


2 For Spanish war preparations in 1737 and early in 1738, see 
the correspondence of Montiano and Giiemes, Ga. Hist. Soc. 
Collections, VII, Part I, pp. 8-20; Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 
150-151; Clowes, The Royal Navy, a History, vol. III (London, 
1898), p. 50; Georgia Colonial Records, XXII, Part I, 134-136, 
217, 219, 223; Egmont, Diary, II, 446-447. For English war 
preparations at the same time, see Egmont, Diary, II. On 
February 10, 1737-8, Sir Chas. Wager (Admiral) instructed Capt. 
Chas. Brown at Jamaica to protect Georgia from a Spanish 
attack. (Ford, W. C., Vernon-Wager Manuscripts, 53, Wash- 
ington, 1904); Arredondo, maps and reports listed in Phillips, 
The Lowery Collection, 270-275. 


76 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


contingents were assembled at Havana. Seven 
thousand men and sixty warships were made 
ready there. Georgia seemed doomed, when 
suddenly, on March 21, Giiemes received a 
hurried order to suspend the expedition while 
the two crowns deliberated over the boun- 
dary. 

Walpole had stilled for the moment the 
fears of the Spanish court. The peaceful 
news was proclaimed through the streets of 
old San Agustin by beat of drum. But Spain’s 
confidence had been misplaced. Oglethorpe 
blustered and had his way. Was Georgia to 
be abandoned? He got the ears of the King, 
and was given aregiment. Now he could hold 
his ground. Spain’s golden moment was lost.! 


1 For the armed truce on the border in 1738-1739, see Stevens, 
History of Georgia, I, 150-153; Jones, History of Georgia, I, ch. 17. 
Ga. Col. Rec., XXII, Part II, 68; ‘‘Relacion del Yndio Juan 
Ignacio de los Reyes Vecino del Pueblo de Pocatalaca.”’ (A. G. I., 
86-6-5; printed in Serrano y Sanz, 260-264); Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., 
VII, Part I, 26-27; Brooks, The Unwritten History of Old St. 
Augustine, 175-180. The subjects treated in this chapter and 
the next are sketched in Chapter XIII of Robert Greenhow’s 
rare book, The History of Florida, Louisiana, Texas, and Cali- 
fornia, and of the adjoining countries, including the whole valley 
of the Mississippi, from the discovery to their incorporation with 
the United States of America. Volume I. (New York, 1856:) 
One of the very few existing copies of this work is in the Bancroft 
Library. 


CHAPTER VI 


THE WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 
(1739-1742) 


The Georgia question was only one of two 
main bones of contention between Spain and 
England. Indeed, it was the smaller bone of 
the two. The other was a matter of trade 
and sea power. But both were questions of 
the Caribbean and its perimeter. Since the 
time of Hawkins, Englishmen had smuggled 
right and left in Spanish American waters. 
Then, by the Treaty of Utrecht the South 
Sea Company was granted legal right to a 
limited amount of trade in Spanish America. 
This privilege the company brazenly abused, 
and other English merchants continued to 
smuggle as of yore. Spain, weary of protest, 
established a rigorous coast guard. She freely 
exercised the “right of search,’ and captured 
scores of British vessels. Herein, too, abuses 
occurred. The blame was two-sided, of 
course. 


78 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


The wails of the British merchants re- 
sounded throughout the realm. Parliament 
held a fiery debate on Spanish depredations. 
Robert Jenkins, one of the plaintiffs, caused 
a sensation. Seven years before, off Florida, 
a Spanish coast guard had boarded his ship, 
cut off one of his ears and handed it back.1 As 
Exhibit No. 1 Jenkins now showed the bottled 
ear in Parliament. Some say that Jenkins 
lied. Be that as it may, his story caught the 
crowd and they demanded war. The excite- 
ment made Oglethorpe’s muster easy, and in 
July he departed for Georgia. At the same 
time Haddock was sent with a squadron to 
the Mediterranean. Spain realized that she 
had been duped by peace talk. She protested 


1 April 30 (May 11), 1735, Geraldino directed to the Royal 
Asiento Company a proposal for disposing of their West Indian 
trade (Ford, W. C., Vernon-Wager Manuscripts, Washington, 
1904, p. 46). For the complaints of English merchants, see 
Trevor MSS., in Hist. MSS. Commission Report, XIV, App. pt. 
IX (London, 1895), 13-14, 24; Egmont’s Diary, II, 440-442, 448, 
474; Cobbett, Parliamentary History of England (London, 1812), 
X, 562-787; Coxe, W., Memozrs of the Life and Administration of 
Sir Robert Walpole, IV (London, 1816), p. 11. For English war 
steps early in 1738, see Temperley, Harold W. V., ““‘The Causes 
of the War of Jenkins’ Ear, 1739,” in Royal Historical Society 
Transactions, Third Series, vol. III (London, 1909), 201-207, 
210, 211, 213, 214; Egmont, Diary, II, 486, 503; Laughton, J. K., 
“Jenkins’ Ear,” in English Historical Review, 1V (London, 1889), 
743. 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 79 


these new war preparations and revived her 
own. In America, Georgia and Florida again 
were likewise the scene of military activities. 

But once more the tide of war was stemmed 
by diplomacy. War might destroy more trade 
than it would conquer; and Newcastle was not 
sure of England’s claim to Georgia. In 
January, 1739, the Convention of El Pardo 
was signed.t. Spain agreed to pay certain 
indemnities. All difficulties concerning “com- 
merce and navigation in America and Europe 
and the limits of Florida and Carolina” were 
referred to a joint commission. So important 
was the Carolina boundary question that it 
was given a separate article. It provided 
that pending the settlement the status quo 
was to be maintained on the frontier. 

The Convention of El Pardo was destined 
to failure. The Georgia Trustees, fearing 


1For the negotiation of the Convention of El Pardo, see 
Temperley, “Causes of the War of Jenkins’ Ear,”’ loc. cit., 214- 
225; Cobbett, Parliamentary History of England, X, 666, 957, 
1023, 1028, note; Smollett, The History of England, III, 332-352 
(London, 1811); Trevor MSS., pp. 18-20, 24; Calvo, Tratados, 
Vol. II (Paris, 1862), 225-241; Hare MSS., in Hist. MSS. Com- 
mission, Report, XIV, App. pt. IX (London, 1895), pp. 242-244. 
For the protest of the Georgia Trustees over the Convention, see 
Cobbett, op. cit., X, 1056, 1179, 1184, 1204, 1257; Trevor MSS., 
p. 26; Ga. Col. Rec., V, 88, 97-98, 100-101, 104, 107, 113, 116- 
122, 125-137; Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 159-160. 


80 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


that their province might be sacrificed, bom- 
barded Walpole with demands for protection, 
and he promised it with a manly oath. “S: 
Robert hearing this, call’d to Col. Bladen, and 
ask’d him whether England had a right to 
Georgia? yes, reply’d the Col’ Can you prove 
it, said S: Robert, and will you undertake it? 
the Col’ answer’d he would. Then, said S 
Robert, By G-d the Spaniards shall not have 
it.’ Under further pressure the Trustees 
forced Walpole to defend England’s ‘‘posses- 
sions” as well as her “rights” in America. 
This confession that the two were not identical 
was not lost on the Spanish diplomats. 
Egmont wrote in his Diary: “‘But when they 
saw that the Convention would pass, they 
obliged Sir Robert Walpole to put the word 
‘possession’ into the address [to the Com- 
mons], which was of the greatest service for 
defeating the ensuing treaty with Spain, 
because thereby the Ministry were tied down 
from giving up an inch of ground to the 
Spaniards, which they have declared unless 
they are allowed to have restored to them, 
they will never make a treaty.” ! 


1Hgmont’s Diary, III (1923), 38; Egmont’s Journal (Ga. Col. 
Rec., V), 120-131. 


APARACHICOLAS — 


brs TASQUIQUE 


NORTHERN | LINE 


IC } 

ASK \ 
iN Ea Oconee | 
coe SAVACOLAA| 


[68 


SAVACOLA EL GRANDE 
SAVACOLA ‘685 


~VE69O 


or 


a SANTA CRUZ Sai 


er 
( Caicos. 


Sal 
ICEPCION ( uBALe) 
SAN Ae TG oy Ce COCONI}* 


ANS 
Ba LORENZO ( ND ok, “eH 


Lust yan MN 


ye BATTLE-GROUND “i 


13 


FREDERICA 
S.FORT | 


PROPOSED AND, MAINTAINEEN 
a .NEW saa a 
BY ENGUAND — 1750- 


: OXE FENOKEE 


¢  OWANP 


GROUND” 


SS oy SS ay _>ADP AYES ‘ties Ne SKE >>> SSSI 


er Yb >> 


LEGEND 

@ TOWN 
MISSION 

@ °RESIDIO 

A INDIAN TOWN 


SCALE IN _ MILES 


LA/, 


Map of the Debatable Land, 1670-1763. 


id! 


Soro. (OSsaBaw) 


APALA (SAN 19) ee 


POGACHE:.” 
CAS DE TALAJE © 


NTO DOMINGO. 


SAO (SAN SIMON 
oo on BUENAVENTURA 


1ST GEORGE 


BE SAN JUAN 
4 BY JUAN 
(CAROLINE (SAN MATEO) 


ZSANTA CRUZ 


AN AGUSTIN 
TA ANASTASIA I. 


SMATANZAS 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 81 


In spite of bluster there was still talk of 
adjustment. Report had it that the king of 
Spain would sooner part with his capital than 
with Georgia. Geraldino denied the rumor 
and even suggested that his master might 
compromise on the Altamaha as a boundary. 
Seizing on the suggestion, Egmont went a step 
further and proposed that the region south of 
the Altamaha be left “desert and unin- 
habited.”’ Geraldino then receded from his 
position. Nevertheless, Newcastle followed 
up the idea of a neutral ground. In his in- 
structions to Keene of the Commission (April, 
1739) he proposed that the San Juan be the 
legal boundary, but that the district between 
the San Juan and the Altamaha be left 
“unbuilt and uninhabited by Spaniards or 
English.” ! 

The commissioners had not the ghost of a 
show.? While they deliberated the English 


1 Ga. Col. Rec., V, 1385-137, 146, 154; Egmont’s Diary, III, 22, 
35, 45, 51. 

2 For the failure of the Convention of El Pardo and the breach 
between England and Spain, see Temperley, op. cit., 222-235; 
Hare MSS., 247-248; John Morley, Walpole (London, 1909), 
218; Coxe, William, Memoirs of the Life and Administration of Sir 
Robert Walpole, IV, 57-126, 383-389 (London, 1816); Goodrich, 
C. A., Select British Eloquence (New York, 1852), 77-79; Clowes, 
The Royal Navy, III, 51-52; South Carolina Historical Society 


82 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


public cried for war. Instead of recalling 
Haddock from the Mediterranean, the minis- 
try built more ships and impressed more 
seamen. Thereupon Spain suspended the 
Asiento and refused to pay the promised 
indemnity unless Haddock were recalled.! 
In June the break came. Sealed orders were 
hurried to Jamaica and the mainland colonies, 
authorizing privateers to “commit all sorts of 
hostilities against the Spaniards.” The four- 
year struggle which followed got its ridiculous 
name from Jenkins’ severed ear. When war 
was openly declared the English mobs went 
wild. Walpole, the pacifist, looked on in 
alarm. “Ah!” he exclaimed, “they are ring- 
ing the bells to-day; they will soon be wringing 
their hands!” 


Collections, II, 270; Hart, F. R., Admirals of the Caribbean 
(Boston, 1922), note, 131-132. For the protest of the king of 
Spain in 1739 against British war preparations and France’s 
declaration that she must stand by Spain, see Smollett, History 
of England, III, 350-352 (London, 1811); Egmont’s Diary, III, 
p. 81. The causes of the War of Jenkins’ Ear are discussed by 
Hertz, G. B., British Imperialism in the Eighteenth Century, ch. 
II (“The War Fever of 1739”), London, 1908. 

1On April 12, 1740, the King ordered Montiano to maintain 
good relations with the French “during the present war,’ and 
to call on them for supplies and munitions (A. G. I., 87-6-18); 
on May 25, 1740, he ordered the viceroy of New Spain to give all 
possible aid to Florida (A. G. I., 61-2-21). For Spanish de- 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 83 


While the war clouds gathered in Europe,! 
Oglethorpe prepared the back country. There 
the struggle of traders and diplomats had been 
unceasing. French and Spanish agents both 
did their level best to keep the Indians stirred 
up against the English. Oglethorpe needed a 
strong cordon of allies in the west. The 
Chickasaws were devoted to the Anglomen; 
the Choctaws had always been French parti- 
sans. By a triumph of diplomacy, part of 
the Choctaws now turned against the French 
and opened trade with the Georgians. The 
Creeks were a wavering factor, and they occu- 
pied strategic ground between the European 
rivals.2, Nothing but a personal visit by Ogle- 
thorpe would hold them in line, and he 
decided to make the journey. Chiefs Chisla- 


fensive measures, see Sister Mary Frances Read, ‘‘The Viceregal 
Administration of Don Pedro Cebridn y Agustin, Conde de 
Fuenclara, 1742-1746,” ch. II. (M.A. thesis, University of 
California, MS.); El Conde de Montijo, Representaciones sobre 
asuntos a la defensa colonial, Madrid, January 2, 1740 (A. G. L., 
142-1-12); Castilla de Aysa, Testimonio de las Diligencias 
practicadas con motivo de la guerra con los Ingleses, Guadalajara, 
June 3, 1740 (A. G. I., 103-5-25). 

1 For England’s sending sealed orders for reprisals to America, 
see Hare MSS., 247-248; Ga. Col. Rec., IV, 407, 412, 416, 419; 
S. C. Hist. Soc. Col., II, 270; Acts of the Privy Council, Colonial 
Series (1720-1745), III, 636 (Hereford, 1910). 

2Ga. Col. Rec., XXII, Part II, 68,95; Egmont’s Diary, III, 
80, 93. 


84 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


caliche (Chigilly) and Malachee arranged for 
a meeting at Coweta. Upper and Lower 
Creeks, Chickasaws, and the friendly Choc- 
taws promised to attend. 

In July (1739) Oglethorpe ascended the 
Savannah to Euchie Town. Thence with an 
escort of rangers, traders, and Indians he set 
forth overland. On the way Indian hunters 
provided venison, wild honey, turkey, and 
buffalo meat. Horses and riders swam the 
streams. The packs were towed over in 
leather canoes carried for the purpose. Out- 
side of Coweta, Indian boys and girls greeted 
the visitors with presents of fowls, venison, 
pumpkins, potatoes and watermelons. ‘King’ 
Chislacaliche himself came forth bearing the 
English flag, and escorted the White Chief to 
the public square, where populace and dogs 
gave noisy welcome.! Oglethorpe met the 
chiefs in solemn council; a few days later they 
reassembled at Casista, across the river. At 


1 For Oglethorpe’s journey to Coweta, see Ga. Col. Rec., IV, 
371-372; XXII, Pt. II, 166-167, 179, 208, 214-215; “A Ranger’s 
Report of Travels with General Oglethorpe, 1739-1742,” in 
Newton D. Mereness, Travels in the American Colonies, 215-222; 
Henry Bruce, Life of General Oglethorpe (New York, 1890), 207- 
208; Stephens, Journal (Ga. Col. Rec., IV, 368-369); Ga. Hist. 
Soc. Col., III (Savannah, 1873), 80, 87; Stevens, History of 
Georgia, I, 157-158; Wright, Memoir, ch. 12; Egmont’s Diary, 
III, 121. 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 85 


the end of ten days the Creeks renewed their 
alliance with England and declared that no 
Spaniard should settle north of the San Juan 
River and Apalache. On August 25 Ogle- 
thorpe set out for home. Eight days later he 
reached Augusta. There he learned that 
England and Spain were in a state of war. 
His treaty with the Creeks was well timed. 
This was an American war. It was 
directed almost exclusively at Spain’s com- 
merce and her colonies. The main target was 
the Caribbean area, with Havana at the 
center and Puerto Bello, Cartagena and San 
Agustin on the perimeter. Vice-Admiral 
Vernon—‘‘Old Grog,” his seamen called him— 
was given the center of the naval stage. 


1For Vernon’s operations early in the war, see Clowes, The 
Royal Navy, Ill, 51-52, 58, 67, 265-267. For the participation 
of the North American troops, see Hart, F. R., Admirals of the 
Caribbean, 139-140; Temperley, H. W. V., ‘“‘The Relations of 
England with Spanish America, 1720-1744,” Am. Hist. Assoc. 
Ann. Rep., 1911, I, 231-237; Storer, “Admiral Vernon Medals,” 
Mass. Hist. Soc. Proc., 1918-1919, vol. 52, pp. 195-196; An 
Account of the Expedition to Carthagena [1740] with Explanatory 
Notes and Observations. London, 1743. Printed for Mr. Cooper; 
Original Papers Relating to the Expedition to Carthagena [1740]. 
London, 1744. Printed for Mr. Cooper. See also Winsor, 
Narrative and Critical History, Vol. V (Boston, 1887), and the 
records of the various colonies. The Vernon-Wager Manuscripts 
in the Library of Congress are rich in materials for the War of 
Jenkins’ Ear. (Ford, W. C., The Vernon-Wager Manuscripts, 


pp. 60-99 passim.) 


86 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Oglethorpe played the chief réle on land. 
With a small fleet Vernon sailed to Jamaica. 
Thence he proceeded to the Isthmus and 
captured Puerto Bello. Hysterical over the 
victory, England encored. A medal was 
struck bearing the words: “Brave Vernon 
made us free; no search upon the seas shall 
be!” 

Oglethorpe was instructed at first to 
“anoy the Spaniards.” He did not need 
urging. Hastening to Frederica he raised a 
troop of mounted rangers, and sent messengers 
among the Indian allies to call for warriors. 
They promptly responded. When war was 
openly declared (October, 1739), Oglethorpe 
struck quickly. Two preliminary forays and 
two campaigns drove the Spaniards out of 
forts Pupo and Picolata, and gave him control 
of San Juan River, to the very back door of 
San Agustin (January, 1740). Montiano 
chafed in his ancient castle there, but he 
could do little, for he had only 613 men, of 


1 Oglethorpe’s summons to the Indians and his first move- 
ments against Florida are treated in Ga. Col. Rec., IV, 424, 474, 
501, 550-551, 555; Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., III, 82-94, 105-108; 
Montiano to Gtiemes, January 31, 1740 (Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., VII, 
Pt. I, 34); S. C. Hist. Soc. Col., II, 270; Stephens, Journal (Ga. 
Col. Rec., IV), 447, 458, 462-465, 474, 477, 483, 501; Stevens, 
History of Georgia, I, 161, 163; Mereness, Travels, 224-226. 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 87 


whom ninety were negroes and Indians.: Of 
Giiemes at Havana he begged a squadron to 
protect the capital. Six small galliots were 
sent. As it turned out they saved the city. 
To Oglethorpe the San Juan was only a 
means to an end. Vernon had won fame by 
capturing Puerto Bello; his was the task to 
take San Agustin. Hurrying to Charleston he 
raised 500 men under Colonel Vanderdusen; 
and with Commodore Pearce he arranged for 
cooperation with the coast fleet. In April he 
welcomed a new contingent of Indian allies. 
In all his force consisted of about 2,000 men.? 
Early in May Oglethorpe’s army crossed 
the broad San Juan. Warships effectively 
patrolled the coast, and forts San Diego and 
Moosa were taken. But these small successes 
were followed by a series of failures. An 


1Montiano’s defensive measures down to May 14 are set 
forth in his correspondence with Giiemes in ‘‘Letters of Montiano, 
Siege of St. Augustine,’”’ Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., VII, Pt. I, 7-24, 
32-53. On July 30, Montiano reported the failure of Ogle- 
thorpe’s attack to the viceroy. He stated that the English loss 
was more than 150 men, that of the Spaniards only 16 (The 
viceroy to the King, October 15, 1740. A. G. I., 61-2-21). 

2 For Oglethorpe’s appeals to South Carolina, see Oglethorpe 
to Bull, December 29, 1739, in Harris, Voyages and Travels, II, 
338-340; S. C. Hist. Soc. Col., II, 271; Stevens, History of Georgia, 
I, 170; Jones, History of Georgia, I, 327; Wright, Memoir of James 
Oglethorpe, 232-233, 238-2438. 


88 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


attempt to assault the city was frustrated by 
the six galliots in the harbor. They, if any, 
were the heroes in the engagement. The 
English garrison left at Fort Moosa was cut 
to pieces by Montiano. Oglethorpe’s plan for 
an assault now gave way to a siege.! Bat- 
teries on Santa Anastasia Island bombarded 
the town, but without effect. Starvation 
promised to be a more deadly weapon, but 
Spanish supply ships eluded the besiegers and 
relieved the famine. The task of the English 
was hopeless now, and on July 20 they raised 
the siege. Oglethorpe had repeated Moore’s 
failure of forty years before. In old San 
Agustin there was rejoicing. 

This was a war of failures. Oglethorpe’s 
retreat from San Agustin was followed by a 
series of reverses to “Old Grog”’ in the Carib- 
bean. In the summer of 1740 he was joined 
by 3,500 troops from the northern mainland 
colonies, and a little later by 9,000 more from 
England. ‘A fleet such as heretofore had 
never been assembled in the waters of the 


1 For English accounts of Oglethorpe’s attack on San Agustin, 
see Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 171-179; Wright, Memoir, 
243-260; Harris, Voyages and Travels, II, 339-340; Jones, 
History of Georgia, I, chs. 20-21. For the Spanish version, see 
Montiano’s correspondence with Giiemes, Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., vol. 
VII, Pt. I, 54-65. 


atin 
Ra es 
e. 


babe ig 


& 


Ruins on the Altamaha, opposite Darien. 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 89 


New World was now at the disposal of the 
British commander.” 

It was hoped that Vernon would next 
attack Havana.' ‘‘All our hearts are bent on 
Cuba,” Pulteney wrote him. ‘No search, 
take and hold,’ became the war cry. But 
just now Spain sent Torres to the West Indies 
with a powerful Spanish fleet. To take Havana 
was easier said than done. Vernon therefore 
turned to Cartagena. But a deadly climate 
and quarrels with Wentworth caused disaster 
there, and Vernon returned to Jamaica.’ 
Then followed another failure. Vernon was 
ordered to take Havana, but Torres still 
blocked the way. Santiago was therefore 
selected as the victim instead. Gingerly 
Vernon looked it over. Concluding that it was 
impregnable by sea, he sent Wentworth to 


1 For English desire to conquer Cuba, see Gentleman’s Maga- 
zine (London, 1748), XVIII, 303-304: Trevor MSS., p. 59; Ford, 
Vernon-Wager Manuscripts, August 5, 1739, August 8, 1739, 
October 24, 1739; undated instructions to Admiral Wager, etc., 
pp. 63, 64, 68. 

2 For Vernon’s movements in 1741, see Clowes, The Royal 
Navy, III, 67-75; Hart, F. R., Admirals of the Caribbean, 
149-153, and the bibliography, 194-195. Original Papers 
Relating to the Expedition to Panamd, 1741-42, London, 1744. 
Printed for M. Cooper. Original Papers Relating to the Expedition 
to the Island of Cuba [1741]. London, 1744. Printed for M. 
Cooper. Smollett, Tobias, History of England, III, 381-391 
(London, 1811). In his Adventures of Roderick Random, a novel, 


90 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


attack it by land. But Wentworth lost heart 
in the trackless swamps, and turned back. 
The campaign was soon abandoned, and the 
fleet returned to Jamaica. 

The Spaniards now assumed the aggres- 
sive. Privateers swarmed the Caribbean 
waters and played havoc with English com- 
merce. From Georgia to New York they 
terrorized the northern mainland coast. Caro- 
lina and Georgia plantations were sacked.! 
Within the year ending August, 1741, more 
than thirty English prizes were taken into the 
harbor of San Agustin alone. 

Oglethorpe had no intention of quitting. 
Instead he proposed a new drive on San 
Agustin and made preparations for putting it 
through. The ministry were favorable and 
the drive was planned for March (1742). 


Smollett wrote a brief account of the expedition against Carta- 
gena, in which he took part as an army surgeon. He wrote a 
longer account in his Compendium of Voyages (London, 1756). 
For Spanish reprisals, from September, 1739, to November, 1741, 
see Clowes, op. cit., III, 264-265. For plans for the Spanish 
campaign against Georgia and Carolina, see the correspondence 
and instructions in Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., VII, Pt. III, 20-47; 
Ford, W. C., Vernon-Wager Manuscripts, 87-100, passim. 


1 For the sacking of Carr’s plantation in 1741, see Egmont’s 
Journal (Ga. Col. Rec., V), 484, 529. For Spanish captures, see 
Ga. Col. Rec., IV, supplement (Atlanta, 1908), 117, 223-224; 
ibid., VI, 370; Clowes, The Royal Navy, III, 264-265. 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 91 


But money was short, red tape long, and 
dissension debilitating. Critics carped. The 
Trustees were grafters, they said, and Georgia 
was not worth a war. Sir John Cotton was so 
bold as to urge in Parliament that Port Royal 
be made the boundary, as Spain demanded. 
The Trustees finally triumphed. Georgia was 
declared useful to England, and Stephens, the 
chief critic of the Trustees, was publicly 
humiliated. Vindicated, Egmont rejoiced 
that his enemy would be “brought to his 
marrow-bones.”” On June 30, 1742, the luck- 
less young Stephens, in full view of Parliament, 
bent one knee before his accusers. This was 
not enough. ‘“‘Both knees,’’? demanded the 


1For Oglethorpe’s proposal of another campaign against 
San Agustin, May, 1741, see Ga. Col. Rec., V, 553. For Carr’s 
arrival with Maryland marines, see ibid., V, 511. For Dunbar’s 
mission to raise Indians, see Wright, A Memoir of General James 
Oglethorpe (London, 1867), 279-281. For the conference with 
Chief Wolf, see Ga. Col. Rec., IV, supplement, 160, 162, 173. 


2 For discussion in England of the value of Georgia and of 
plans for a campaign, see Ga. Col. Rec., IV, supplement, 234, 
253, 275; Ga. Col. Rec., V, 273, 293-313, 355, 416, 422, 430, 
432436, 489, 496-498, 514-555 (settlers for Georgia), 560, 561, 
565, 575-579, 589, 592, 601, 611, 612, 619, 620, 633, 635-636, 
637-644; Wright, Memoir, 280; Ga. Col. Rec., XXIII, 459. For 
proposals of Harman Verelst and Oglethorpe, concerning the 
war in Georgia and Florida, and proceedings thereon by the Lords 
Commissioners of Trade and Plantations, October 15-November 
20, 1741, see Ford, Vernon-Wager Manuscripts, 98-99. 


92 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Speaker; and both joints were flexed for half 
an hour. The Trustees gloated to witness 
their critic’s degradation. But England’s 
chance to take the offensive had passed, for 
Spain had assumed that position. 

In October the Spanish ministry had 
decided to launch an expedition to drive the 
English out of Georgia, and make good 
Spain’s claims as far as Port Royal.1 They 
would regain by war what had been lost by 
pacifism and the deceptive Convention of El 
Pardo. Now was the opportune moment. 
Vernon’s failure at Santiago released Torres 
somewhat from his arduous watch at Havana. 
England’s northern colonies were weakened by 
the drain of Vernon’s futile expeditions. 

In anticipation of victory, perhaps, Arre- 
dondo in Havana sat down and wrote an 
“Historical Proof of the right of the Catholic 
King to the territory held to-day by the 
British king under the name of New Georgia 
in the provinces and Continent of Florida, by 
which is proved the unquestionable title of 
the King of Spain as far as north latitude 32° 
30’ inclusive, where lies the harbor of the 


1 For Montiano’s proposal for a counter blow, July 28, 1740, 
see Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., VII, Pt. I, pp. 62-64. 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 93 


island of Santa Elena.’’ This was the line 
which the campaign must establish. 

Giiemes was entrusted with preparations. 
Havana was made the base of supplies and 
convoy ships. Montiano was put at the head 
of the expedition, with Rubiani in charge of 
the fleet and second in command.!_ The expe- 
dition was designed to expel the English from 
Georgia and to devastate South Carolina. It 
must “inflict a damage that will ruin and 
terrify them. It must burn all towns, posts, 
plantations and settlements.” It must re- 
pay the attacks of Drake, Moore, and Ogle- 
thorpe. Above all it must recover Georgia. 

Two Spanish diaries tell us what hap- 
pened.2. One of them was written by Arre- 
dondo. On June 1 a flotilla of ten small 
vessels left Havana. Five days later the 
main fleet set sail. At San Agustin the 
vessels reassembled and took on the Florida 
contingent. Now for a few days the old 
harbor presented a lively scene. Busiest of 


1A Spanish view of Montiano’s campaign against Georgia is 
contained in ‘The Spanish Official Account of the Attack on the 
Colony of Georgia in America, and of its Defeat on St. Simons 
Island by General James Oglethorpe,” in Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., 
Vol. VII, Part III (Savannah, 1913), pp. 20-108. 

2 These are the diaries of Montiano and Casinas (¢bid., 52- 
87). 


94 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


all was Arredondo, chief-of-staff. When all 
was ready it was an imposing force that stood 
out to sea. The fleet consisted of fifty vessels 
carrying eighteen hundred soldiers and about 
a thousand seamen. 

The main Georgia targets were St. Simons 
and Frederica. These destroyed, the fleet 
would continue by the Inland Passage to 
Savannah and Port Royal. The first day out 
from San Agustin the vessels were scattered 
by a storm. Oglethorpe rushed down the 
coast to meet the Spaniards, and their attacks 
on Fort St. Andrews and Fort William failed. 
Returning to Frederica Oglethorpe assembled 
his troops and organized a fleet in the harbor 
of Gualquini.! 

For six days Montiano was prevented by 
a storm from entering that bay. On the 
sixteenth he forced an entrance in the face of 
fire from forts and flotilla. It was a bold 
enterprise, such as Oglethorpe had tried in 
vain at San Agustin. Oglethorpe retreated 


1For Oglethorpe’s preparations, see Wright, Robert, A 
Memoir of General James Oglethorpe (London, 1867), pp. 293- 
300; Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 180-184; Jones, History of 
Georgia, I, 341-346; Ga. Col. Rec., III, 131-132; XXIII, 409, 438; 
Jones, C. C., The Dead Towns of Georgia (Savannah, 1878), 102- 
105. 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 95 


to Frederica; his fleet dispersed. The invaders 
landed and occupied the forts and village of 
St. Simons. 

Montiano planned next to advance on 
Frederica, and two detachments were sent 
out to learn the trails. The only road to 
Frederica was a narrow path cut through the 
woods along the edge of a great marsh. The 
men had to go single file, but they managed 
to get within two miles of the town. Ogle- 
thorpe leaped on a horse, led out Highlanders, 
Rangers and Indians, and rushed to the spot. 
The Spaniards, defeated, fled in confusion. 
Montiano hurried three companies of gren- 
adiers to cover the retreat. With shouts and 
drum beat they advanced to the marsh and 
halted within a hundred paces of some of 
Oglethorpe’s men in ambush. Stacking arms, 
they kindled fires and prepared to cook a meal. 
_ It was gross carelessness. Suddenly they were 
set upon and routed. Many fled without 
their muskets, others were left dead on the 
field. In the two engagements the Spanish 


1 Diaries of Arredondo and Casinas, Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., VII, 
Pt. Ill, 53-64, 65-69; Montiano’s reports, ibid., 48-49, 88-91; 
Wright, Memoir, 302-803. Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., III, 125, 140-141, 
143-145. For a manuscript copy of Arredondo’s diary, see 
Phillips, The Lowery Collection, 273-274. 


96 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


loss was two hundred. These combats are 
famed in Georgia history as the Battle of 
Bloody Marsh.! 

The tide of war had turned. Montiano 
tried to effect a landing at Frederica by the 
river but was driven back. Oglethorpe in 
turn attempted a night assault but was 
betrayed by a French deserter. Next day 
Spanish lookouts in the masts reported an 
English fleet approaching from the north. 
Fearing attack by both land and sea, the 
Spaniard hurriedly retreated to San Agustin.? 
Oglethorpe and Montiano were now even. 
The Boston rhymster wrote, in January, 1743: 


From Georgia to Augustine the General goes; 
From Augustine to Georgia come our foes; 
Hardy from Charleston to St. Simons hies, 
Again from thence to Charleston back he flies. 
Forth from St. Simons then the Spaniards creep; 
“Say Children, Is not this your Play, Bo Peep?” 


1 For the Battle of Bloody Marsh, see Casinas’s diary, loc. cit., 
72; Montiano’s report, tbid., 91-92. Stevens, History of Georgia, 
I, ch. 5; Jones, History of Georgia, I, ch. 22; Wright, Memoir, 
ch. 16; Jones, C. C., The Dead Towns of Georgia, 107-115. 

* For events after the defeat at Bloody Marsh, see Wright, 
Memoir, 308-312; Casinas, Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., VII, Pt. III, 76-87; 
Montiano, ibid., 94; Jones, Dead Towns of Georgia, 110-113. 


AVIEW TOWN r 

s ost So the LOWN and CASTLE 
bat y . 

ye eLNGLISH CAMP before 


een 


CLE of STAUGUSTINE, | 
at June 20 1740. by THOS SILVER | 


¢ 
fy Col Vander Dulon’¢ 
Y Qermee Cump, 


20.7 26 
South Cannel 


dye of S’Angutane ner Leesrer prom an Burrd f Bedor.| 
= Maye We | nore St Augultine Sime (reer> fottrd. by the 
Lamborough (fp! Prarse: AcVheensx bap Fanchan the Tavtar.| 
Capt uannshernt and the Squirrel cept Marren yy 20 Ge 

| tar the Spence Sloop Capt Lancs,and heWoll Caps? 
On the a4 Crd Sander Dulen mitt gue Carolia Soldiers app em 
the Aart af the Jaren On the 9” Gen’ Ogtethorpe came by | 


Ae dinglish rath Grench kt 3 "a toamall Morten 
Bit Marsh Jom whenee we pltyed ‘with 20 Cahora | 
C Eullana ffland 2th chiefly Sond k Bushes 
D. Adore hawling Corgan inh peach hel Wa 
|B. Mord Trench gtd & Mortar of 3 10 nt 


mnt iy the Ne 


| 1 : dl Sf fey 
a regen e Sildeors, Inder & Salers ea ee ee OF Sie c Dia 
at. Lookout taken lhe OYane Pia neh joe taldiers and oo dgdirnd [7 eax gia CH 

S = el tithe n Cee t2 If Sune se Aahey were evwd a Shore tn the Men op hare beac under | 


| shor cover sf Mesmed Shape Guns They Ln 

Endtatin nithoud Opprettion cont peak the Loak-outael © 

of fap Warren nat Shooner ant ther dpaed Mops arnt | 
Lame in thr ip tiarlOUr jee Cant Yf ‘cnr Ht a | 

Sailors revre employed in landing Ortnanee wend | 


H Alters and Setlors lading Gane our 
l..4Sand Bury yitted at our pyrode A 
K Cap* Warren Commander over the halars tiatstOtg, 
dhe Union Flag on boar la Schooner OW Fe 
L.. he Sailors wells toler the Siping. bop the Cuomga tannen ti rhick Cecaten 
1 Har mlboraugh 2 Helv. Syuerrel wey y it Sroreprdiy The same rap inee 


Ships i 
PSs Tartar 5. PRON Rosreriee voere rita htt bet (AC TT : 
qs exhale Ceneral Sammon d the Covernoer to Surrender wher 
The havigh 


Slrops\6 Ws0f > Spence r 
5 LO os vont he A hive in has C 
be “inthe Gupeditian erhaul 200 SECRER near hewkoeld be gle ln thal bar wo Niary wn agen fond i 


f 
amply | 
A, it (x ‘“%, lei Y& an seel FOP cension: . 
BDO SILEATI ANG 00 INMANS i Wed ebrmennd ever Oe Ttighlanders §¢ of whem rere tur dpc dad tke 
| Porcer of the Spanurrds 1000 brstdes LSCONG , 


Were kiling dhrvee thetr number ‘ 
Castle and aSforlyijed, Barks and a Shaler he ngAud Neatter obliged the mon of Mare patie seit ott 
ie , ae ‘2 x g ‘ J * 22 Pa 4] Lat il 


Qs; . 


fet 


i dacave muir hed been kill. Sacre ngon te OS" rene ed. 


Silver. 


The Siege of San Augustin. By Thoma 


WAR OF JENKINS’ EAR 97 


In recognition of his “good service in 
repulsing the Spaniards from Frederica” Ogle- 
thorpe was made Brigadier General.! In July, 
1743, he sailed for England, never to return. 
He was a conquering hero, and was cleared of 
all charges against him. Years later, when an 
old man, he had a tale to tell. To Oliver 
Goldsmith, Sir Joshua Reynolds, and other 
boon companions, he spun yarns of adventure 
in Georgia, and furnished Goldsmith inspira- 
tion for the lines: 


Through torrid tracts, with fainting steps they go, 
Where wild Altama murmurs to their woe. 


1For Oglethorpe’s promotions, see Ga. Col. Rec., V, 679; 
Wright, Memoir, 325, 331, 336, 337, 345; Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., II, 
146; Jones, History of Georgia, I, ch. 22. 


CHAPTER VII 


THE NEUTRAL GROUND AND THE FINAL 
STRUGGLE 


(1743-1763) 


For several years now the country south 
of the Altamaha continued to be what New-. 
castle had suggested, an “uninhabited tract.” 
England maintained Fort William on Cumber- 
land Island and another small post on Jekyl 
Island. For a short time Carr had a planta- 
tion on Blythe Island and Heron another near 
by. But through continued raids from the 
south these plantations were abandoned, and 
the slender island posts alone remained.! 

Though ‘‘deserted and unbuilt,”’ the region 
remained debatable ground. Legally speak- 
ing, nothing had been settled by the war. 
Neither side relinquished its claim. Spain 
continued to stand on the treaty of 1670. 
Indeed, she appealed to France to make it 
good. France responded. By the treaty of 
Fontainebleau (1748) she pledged herself to 


‘For posts on Cumberland and Jekyl, see Ga. Col. Rec., 
XXYV, 396-397; XXVI, 28-31. 


THE FINAL STRUGGLE 99 


‘‘oblige the English to destroy the new colony 
of Georgia and all forts built on Spanish soil.’’! 
France entered the colonial war, but she failed 
to keep her promise regarding Georgia. At- 
tention in the struggle was now turned to the 
north. The St. Lawrence supplanted the 
Caribbean; Cape Breton overshadowed Hava- 
na and San Agustin. 

As the war dragged on various peace pro- 
posals were made. One provided for a com- 
mission to try once more to settle the Carolina 
boundary. Spain again demanded that Geor- 
gia be evacuated, and rumors got abroad that 
this might come to pass. Frightened, Ogle- 
thorpe and other Trustees appealed to the 
Duke of Bedford. The fear was groundless, 
for the treaty of Aix-la-Chapelle restored 
everything to the status quo ante bellum. War 
being over, the Georgia regiment was now dis- 
banded; but some sixty men were kept at the 
island posts, “as a sign of possession.” By 
England the opposite mainland south of the 


1For the treaty of Fontainebleau, see Cantillo, Tratados, 
Convenios, y Declaraciones de Paz y de Comercio (Madrid, 1843), 
370; Lucien Schéne, La Politique Coloniale Sous Louis XV et 
Louis XVI (Paris, 1907), 119-121; Forbonnais, Histoire et 
Commerce des Colonies Anglaises, p. 327 (London, 1755), cited by 
Schéne. 


100 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Altamaha was treated as Neutral Ground. 
Pending an adjustment it must be left unoc- 
cupied. 

For a decade now England toyed with this 
idea of a Neutral Ground. Nonchalantly Spain 
let her toy. The peace of 1748 was only a 
truce, and both England and France com- 
peted for the good will of Spain. England must 
not offend her unnecessarily by an invasion 
of disputed territory. The Court of Madrid 
was also in a conciliatory mood. By a new 
treaty Spain and England made mutual con- 
cessions (1750). Spain yielded to English 
merchants extensive privileges. In return the 
Asiento of the South Sea Company was termi- 
nated. The treaty was ordered published in 
Georgia with a warning to ‘‘avoid giving the 
least ground for such complaint as may, in 
any wise, interrupt the good Harmony... 
between the two Crowns.”’ 


1 For peace movements in 1745, see Trevor MSS., 122-129. 
For the proposal of 1747, see Lord John Russell, Correspondence 
of John, Fourth Duke of Bedford (three vols. London, 1842-1846), 
I, 288-330. For French insistence on the abrogation of the Asiento, 
see Russell, Correspondence of Bedford, I, 448, 451, 476, 477, 
528-536. For the fear felt by the Trustees, see Ga. Col. Rec., I, 
508-510. For the peace of 1748, see Chalmers, Collection of 
Treaties, vol. I; Russell, Correspondence of Bedford, 1, 273-287, 
391, 586-588. 


THE FINAL STRUGGLE 101 


But old animosities could not be entirely 
forgotten in a minute. Georgia settlers felt 
uneasy and called for a garrison on the 
Altamaha (1751). Disturbing reports were 
heard of new fortifications at San Agustin and 
San Marcos; Spain’s minister Ensenada 
showed a French leaning. Hostile orders were 
sent to the Spanish governors; and Spanish 
agents showed suspicious activity among the 
Lower Creeks. Bedford complained. Yield- 
ing, the King of Spain repudiated the objec- 
tionable orders, dismissed Ensenada, and put 
Ricardo Wall in his place. Anglo-Spanish 
relations were greatly improved by the change, 
and, though France and England again went 
to war, Spain remained neutral (1755).! 

But just when Spain’s friendship was most 
important it was threatened by a violation of 
the Neutral Ground. Unruly frontiersmen 
crossed the Altamaha without permission. 


1 For English desire to conciliate Spain after 1748, see Russell, 
Correspondence of Bedford, II, 31, 34-35, 45, 46, 58, 70-72; Ga. 
Col. Rec., XXVI, 149. For the treaty of 1750, see Cantillo, 
Tratados, 409-410. For trade relations between Florida and 
Georgia after 1750, see Ga. Col. Rec., VIII, 347, 594, 687-90. 
For border fears, animosities, and Indians raids after 1750, see 
Ga. Col. Rec., 1, 560; VI, 417, 421, 440-442, 451; VII, 390-401, 
420-425. For Ensenada’s hostile policy, see Russell, Cor- 
respondence of Bedford, II, 71-72, 151, 152, 154; Yorke, The Life 
and Correspondence of Philip Yorke, Earl of Hardwicke, Lord High 
Chancellor of Great Britain (Cambridge, 1913, 3 vols.), III, 251. 


102 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Malcontents from Augusta and the Ogeechee 
settlements, “runagates” from Carolina and 
Virginia, these men were called. Headed by 
Edmund Gray they had opposed Governor 
Reynolds in politics. He had the whip hand, 
and they were expelled from the Georgia 
Assembly on the charge of sedition. Some of 
them sought liberty in the Neutral Ground. 
There, on Satilla River, thirty miles from its 
mouth, ‘‘Gray’s Gang” formed a settlement 
called New Hanover, and engaged in Indian 
trade. Ephraim Alexander opened a store and 
trading post. Fearful of consequences, Rey- 
nolds visited the border (April, 1755). He 
was not reassured by what he saw. With 
alarm he wrote that the emigrants were going 
south “by boats full.”’ His commission gave 
him authority only to the Altamaha. The 
Satilla was in the Neutral Ground. But in the 
interest of good order Reynolds asked the 
Board of Trade to extend his rule to the St. 
Marys. For good reasons his petition was 
denied. Spain’s policy was uncertain and the 
Creeks complained of Gray’s Gang. Both 
Spaniards and Indians must be kept friendly. 


1 For Reynolds and Gray’s Gang, see Ga. Col. Rec., V1, 425, 
441; VII, 95, 100, 171, 173, 252, 294, 333; Stevens, History of 
Georgia, I, 405-407, 412-413; Jones, History of Georgia, I, 486-487. 


THE FINAL STRUGGLE 103 


Spanish reaction to the colony on the 
Satilla was not long left in doubt. A force of 
thirty-four men was sent from San Agustin 
to New Hanover (October, 1756). The cap- 
tain bore a document which, being written in 
Spanish, Gray could not read. But he under- 
stood the verbal orders that the intruders must 
withdraw from Spanish soil; and he promised 
to refer the matter to his governor. For three 
days the Spaniards visited amicably, traded 
at Alexander’s store, and then departed. 

Reynolds was succeeded by Ellis. One of 
the new governor’s first acts was to visit the 
southern frontier and confer with Gray, early 
in 1757. There he was apprised of a new 
danger. The Spanish governor was now try- 
ing to attract Gray’s Gang to his own 
standard. Gray informed Ellis that Alexander 
had been urged to move his trading post to 
the north bank of the San Juan under Spanish 
protection. ‘This would be a recognition of 
Spain’s authority in the disputed area. It 
would be better, the shrewd Gray suggested, 
for Ellis himself to issue a license, as a sign of 


1¥For Gray’s visit to “St. Taffeys’” and Spanish reaction to 
Gray’s Gang, see Ga. Col. Rec., VII, 425-430, 451, 477, 480; 
Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 437-439. 


104 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


England’s authority. As a compromise Alex- 
ander was permitted to establish a post on 
the St. Marys opposite Fort William.!| Across 
the channel on Cumberland Island another 
settlement was now formed. These “profligate 
and refractory” intruders were suspected of 
having received encouragment from the gov- 
ernment of Florida to settle there, in conjunc- 
tion with a number of Spanish families “sent 
thither from their islands, purposely to 
establish a colony in those regions.” 

Ellis had made a faux pas. He had 
violated the Neutral Ground. ‘The Board of 
Trade vigorously denounced his act. The 
settlement on the Satilla was “‘an open defi- 
ance of his Majesty’s lawful authority.” 
The settlers’ influence with the Indians was 
dangerous. Moreover, it might “disturb that 


1 For Ellis and the Indians, see Ga. Col. Rec., VII, 179-180, 
206, 251-261, 294, 492, 494, 539, 540, 546, 643-667, 703-706; 
Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 412, 422-423, 427, 439, 440-443. 
For Ellis’s relations with Gray’s Gang and with the Spaniards, 
see Ga. Col. Rec., VII, 544, 547, 548; Stevens, History of Georgia, 
I, 487-488; Jones, History of Georgia, I, 531, 5389. On August 
26, 1756, the governor of Florida reported Braddock’s defeat to 
the viceroy of Mexico and added that the Indians were peaceful 
and that he was perfecting the forts at San Agustin and San 
Marcos. (A. G. L, 86-6-6.) In July, 1759, Governor Palacios 
reported Creek (Uchis) hostilities against the Spaniards (A. G. I., 
86-6-6.); in 1761 the western Creeks attacked Pensacola (A. G. I., 
89-3-15 and 89-3-18). 


eLT ‘toqaey tumbyeny jo depy s,opuoperry 


“SOATUOIV YStuRda at 4 UT [BUISLIO Ot 4 UIOLY 
. . b . . . | c 


Rk 


® 
& 


& 
sie” 


& 


iat ® » aie, ERG Ripe 


ie ar 


pEER, 
TAN 


. GG 
eg Wi 


Rok oR 
® 
< taaiges 


hee 


eng? af 


THE FINAL STRUGGLE 105 


peace and friendship which at present so 
happily subsists between his Majesty and the 
King of Spain, no limits having, as we appre- 
hend, ever been settled between the two 
crowns in that part of America.’ The St. 
Marys was not in Ellis’ jurisdiction; and the 
licensing of Alexander to establish a post 
there might be considered by Spain as a 
declaration of England’s right to the land. 
The Board of Trade referred the matter to 
Pitt, and the New Hanover settlers were 
ordered ‘“‘to remove immediately from thence” 
(June 10, 1758). Government had spoken, 
and there was pretended compliance. Early 
in 1759 commissioners served notice on the 
settlers, and by March they had departed. 
But the troublesome frontiersmen ‘‘did only 
make a show or appearance of so doing, and 
immediately returned back to their settle- 
ments.” There they still were two years later.? 


1 For official correspondence of the home government con- 
cerning Gray’s Gang, see Charles Lee, A Report of the Attorney 
General to Congress; containing a collection of Charters, Treaties, 
and other Documents Relative to and Explanatory of the Title to the 
Land Situate in the South Western Parts of the United States; and 
claimed by Certain companies Under a Law of the State of Georgia, 
Passed January 7, 1795 (Philadelphia, 1796), 105-111; Ga. Col. 
Rec., VII, 844-845, VIII, 585. 

2For the removal of Gray’s Gang, see Ga. Col. Rec., VII, 
875-876; Stevens, History of Georgia, I, 448, 449. 


106 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


The Satilla settlement was probably more 
obnoxious to the English than to the Spanish 
authorities. Governor Wright complained 
that it was used as ‘‘an Asylum by Persons 
who fly thither, to shelter themselves from 
Justice.” But having no authority to use 
force to eject them he could only appeal to 
the Board. 

Gray’s influence with the Creeks had been 
regarded as a menace. Now it was put to. 
account. In 1759 the French succeeded in 
turning the Cherokees against the English. 
To strike a counter blow Ellis fitted out a — 
Creek war party and put Gray in command 
of it. In April, Gray marched into Savannah 
at the head of a conquering band displaying 
Cherokee scalps. The braves were congrat- 
ulated, and richly rewarded for being the 
first to shed Cherokee blood. But even 
Gray’s services did not avail him to get per- 
mission to invade the Neutral Ground. He 
applied for a renewal of his license to trade in 
the south. Governor Wright gave consent, 
but only on condition that the permit be. 
restricted to Cumberland Island. 


1 For Gray’s service in the Cherokee War, see Ga. Col. Rec., 
VIII, 284, 292-294, 569. 


THE FINAL STRUGGLE 107 


Inevitably Spain was drawn at last into 
the war. Her neutrality had been greatly 
strained by her French sympathies. In vain 
she had interceded on behalf of France. She 
felt that further neutrality was merely hasten- 
ing her own destruction. Ricardo Wall, once 
England’s zealous friend, shouted in anger to 
the Earl of Bristol that all the English aimed 
at was “‘to ruin the French Power, in order the 
more easily to crush Spain;” to drive Spain’s 
subjects from their island colonies; and ‘‘to 
destroy their several Forts and Settlements on 
the Continent of North America.” In this 
mood Spain renewed the Family Compact 
(1761); then England declared war. The fate 
- of Georgia was now sealed.} 

Carlos III ‘had championed a_ cause 
already lost. Quebec had fallen before the 
Compact was signed. Humiliation for Spain 
was inevitable, and inch by inch she yielded 
her claims. Grimaldi at first denounced the 
cession of Louisiana to England; resistance 
_ being futile, he proposed a neutral zone west 
of the Alleghanies to keep England from the 


1 For the breach with Spain, see Papers Relating to the Rupture 
with Spain Laid Before Both Houses of Parliament on Friday the 
Twenty-ninth Day of January, 1762, By His Majesty’s command 
(London, 1762). 


108 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Gulf. Next he was ready to yield Georgia, 
with a “reasonable” boundary on the south— 
presumably the Altamaha. Then Havana 
fell, and the vise tightened. England offered 
to restore Havana in exchange for Florida or 
Puerto Rico. Florida could be spared better 
than the island. But to cede it would give 
England control of the Gulf and the Bahama 
Channel, the evil Spain had so long resisted. 
To save Florida for Spain, therefore, France 
offered England all of Louisiana. But Eng- 
land preferred Florida, and took it. La 
Florida was gone; with it vanished all of 
Spain’s claims to Georgia. Ostensibly to 
compensate Spain for her loss, France now 
gave Spain western Louisiana, which England 
had rejected. Reluctantly she accepted it. 
The treaty of Paris ended the long contest 
between England and Spain over the debat- 
able land of Georgia. But it served also to 
revive an old quarrel between Georgia and 
Carolina. Before the treaty was ratified the 
governor of South Carolina proceeded to 


1 For a discussion of the Louisiana cession, see Shepherd, in 
Political Science Quarterly, XIX, 439-458. For the treaty of 
Paris, February 10, 1763, see MacDonald, W., Select Charters 
and Other Documents Illustrative of American History (New York, 
1906), 261-267. 


THE FINAL STRUGGLE 109 


grant to Carolinians large tracts of land south 
of the Altamaha. Governor Wright protested. 
Suddenly he had become a good Spaniard. 
Carolina’s claim to the area on the ground 
of the grant to 29° was ridiculous, he said. 
That grant took in St. Augustine, Pensacola, 
and Mobile [and he might have added El 
Paso, Santa Fé and Albuquerque], ‘and 
therefore Mr. Boone may just as well pretend 
a right to grant those places as any spot of 
land to the southward of the river Altamaha.”’ 
Arredondo himself could scarcely have stated 
Spain’s case better.t The home Government 
took the Spanish view of the question—it was 
safe to do so now—and denied Carolina’s claim. 

Our story now soon ends. Two Gulf 
provinces, East and West Florida, were organ- 
ized from England’s new acquisitions.2 East 


1¥For the controversy between Georgia and South Carolina 
over land grants after the treaty of 1763, see Charles Lee, Report 
of the Attorney General, 112-132; Letters of Hon. James Haber- 
sham, in Ga. Hist. Soc. Col., VI, 10-15 (Savannah, 1904). 


2 For plans for the administration of the new acquisitions, 
see Lee, Report of the Attorney General, 133-136; for the Proclama- 
tion of 1763, see MacDonald, Select Charters, 267. The next Janu- 
ary, by Governor Wright’s commission, Georgia’s north and 
south boundaries were extended to the Mississippi. For Governor 
Wright’s commission, see Certain Documents and Reports Relating 
to the Locating and Marking of the Line Between the Territory and 
State of Florida and the State of Georgia. 60th Cong., 1st sess., 
Senate Doc. No. 467, (Washington, 1908). 


110 THE DEBATABLE LAND 


Florida was delimited on the north by the 
-St. Marys River, and a line thence to the 
forks of the Apalachicola. The strip between 
the St. Marys and the Altamaha was added 
to Georgia. It wasno longer Debatable Land. 


BIBLIOGRAPHY 


Arredondo’s Map of the Debatable Land. From the original in the 
Spanish Archives. Through the reduction the details are lost, but the 
heavy parallel lines convey Arredondo’s idea of the area in dispute. 


BIBLIOGRAPHY 


(List of printed works cited) 


Asap y Lasterra, Don IXtco. Relacién de el Descubrimiento, 
Conquista y Poblacién de las Provincias y Costas de la 
Florida. Afio de 1785. In Serrano y Sanz, Documentos 
Histéricos de La Florida y La Luisiana, Siglos XVI al 
XVIII. Madrid, 1912. 

ALVORD, CLARENCE WALWORTH, and Bipcoop, Ler. The first 
explorations of the Trans-Allegheny Region by the Vir- 
ginians, 1650-1674. Cleveland, 1912. 

ARREDONDO, Don Antonio DE. Journal kept by Don Antonio 
de Arredondo, Chief Engineer of the Present Expedition. 
Translation in Collections of the Georgia Historical Society, 
Vol. VII, Pt. I. Savannah, 1913. 

Barcfa, ANDRE£s GonzALuz (Don Gabriel de Cardenas Z Cano). 
Ensayo Cronolégico, para la Historia General de la Florida. 
Desde el Afio de 1512. Que Descubri6é la Florida, Juan 
Ponce de Leén, hasta el de 1722. Escrito por Don Gabriel 
de Cardenas Z Cano, Dedicado al Principe Nuestro Sefior. 
Con Privilegio: En Madrid, 1723. 

BARNWELL, JosepH W. ‘‘Dr. Henry Woodward, The First 
English Settler in South Carolina, and Some of his De- 
scendants.’’ In the South Carolina Historical and Genea- 
logical Magazine, Vol. VIII, Charleston, 1907. 

BASANIER (editor). L’Histoire Notable de la Floride située 
en Indes Occidentales contenant les Trois Voyages Faicts 
en Icelle par Certains Capitaines et Pilotes Francois 
Descrits par le Captaine Laudoniére qui y a Commandé 
L’Espace D’un an Trois Moys. Paris, 1586. Reprinted in 
Paul Gaffarel, Histoire de la Floride Frangaise. Paris, 
1875. 

Boiron, Hersert Evcrenr. The Spanish Borderlands: A 
Chronicle of Old Florida and the Southwest. New Haven, 
1921. 


114 BIBLIOGRAPHY 


Bouron, Hersert Evens, and MarsHaty, Tomas Marrianp. 
The Colonization of North America, 1492-1783. New York, 
1920. 

Brooxs, A. M. The Unwritten History of Old St. Augustine, © 
Copied from the Spanish Archives in Seville, Spain, by 
Miss A. M. Brooks, and Translated by Mrs. Annie Averette. 
St. Augustine, 1909? 


Brown, ALEXANDER. The First Republic in America; an 
Account of the Origin of this Nation. Written from the 
Records Then (1624) Concealed by the Council Rather than 
From the Histories Then Licensed by the Crown. Boston, 
1898. 


Brown, ALEXANDER. The Genesis of the United States. A 
Narrative of the Movement in England, 1605-1616, which 
Resulted in the Plantation of North America by Englishmen, 
Disclosing the Contest between England and Spain for the 
Possession of the Soil now Occupied by the United States of 
America. By Alexander Brown. 2 vols. Boston and New 
York, 1890. 


Brucs, Henry. Life of General Oglethorpe. New York, 1890. 


BucKINGHAMSHIRE, EArt or. The Manuscripts of the Earl of 
Buckinghamshire (Trevor MSS.). In the Fourteenth Re- 
port, Appendix, Part IX, of the Historical Manuscripts 
Commission of Great Britain. London, 1895. See Trevor. 


Catvo, Cartos. Coleccién Completa de los Tratados, Con- 
venciones, Capitulaciones, Armisticios y Otros Actos 
Diplomaticos de Todos Los Estados de la América Latina 
Comprendidos entre el golfo de Méjico y el cabo de Hornos, 
Desde el Afio de 1493 Hasta Nuestros Dias. 6 vols. Paris, 
1862 (vols. 1-3); Madrid, 1864 (vols. 4-6). 

Cantitto, Don ALEJANDRO DEL. Tratados, Convenios, y 
Declaraciones de Paz y de Comercio que han hecho con las 
Potencias Estranjeras los Monarcas Espajioles de la Casa de 
Borbon. Desde el Afio de 1700 Hasta el Dia. Por Don 
Alejandro del Cantillo, oficial que ha sido en la Primera 
Secretaria de Estado y del Despacho. Madrid, 1843. 


BIBLIOGRAPHY 115 


Carroui, B. R. Historical Collections of South Carolina; 
Embracing many Rare and Valuable Pamphlets, and Other 
Documents, Relating to the History of that State, From its 
First Discovery to its Independence, in the year 1776. 2 vols. 
New York, 1836. 

Castnas, Et Marquts pe. Details of What Occurred in the 
Present Expedition, Entrusted to the Care of Brigadier 
Don Manuel de Montiano, from the 15th Day of June, 
on which the Convoy Arrived from Havana at St. Augus- 
tine, the Whole Being Contained in a Journal, Kept by the 
Marquess of Casinas, ete. Translation in Collections of 
the Georgia Historical Society, Vol. VII, Pt. III. Savan- 
nah, 1913. 

CHALMERS, Grorcs. A Collection of Treaties between Great 
Britain and other Powers. 2 vols. London, 1790. 

' Ciowes, Str Winu1AM Larrp. The Royal Navy, a History 
from the Earliest Times to the Present; by Wm. Laird Clowes 
. .. Assisted by Sir Clements Markham ... Captain A. T. 
Mahan, U.S.N., H. W. Wilson, Theodore Roosevelt, E. 
Fraser, etc....7 vols. Boston, 1897-1903. 

Connor, JEANNETTE THURBER (translator). Pedro Menéndez 
de Avilés, Adelantado, Governor and Captain-General of 
Florida. Memorial by Gonzalo Solis de Merds. First 
Published in La Florida,:su Conquista y Colonizacién por 
Pedro Menéndez de Avilés, by Eugenio Ruidiaz y Caravia. 
Deland, Florida (The Florida State Historical Society), 
1923. 

Corbett, Sir JuLiAN SrarrorD (editor). Papers Relating to 
the Navy During the Spanish War, 1585-1587. London, 
1898. 

Coxr, Witu1AM. Memoirs of the Life and Administration of 
Sir Robert Walpole, Earl of Orford. 4 vols. London, 1816. 

Crane, VERNER W. ‘‘An Historical Note on the Westo In- 
dians.”? In American Anthropologist, New Series, Vol. XX. 
Lancaster, 1918. . 

Crane, VERNER W. ‘The Origin of the Name of the Creek 
Indians.”’ In the Mississippi Valley Historical Review. 
Vol. V. Cedar Rapids, 1918. 


116 BIBLIOGRAPHY 


Crane, VERNER W. ‘‘The Southern Frontier in Queen Anne’s 
War.’ In American Historical Review, Vol. XXIV. 
Washington, 1919. 

Curnock, Nenemian (editor). The Journal of the Rev. John 
Wesley, A.M. 8 vols. London, 1909-1916. See Wesley. 

Divina Papriia, Fray Avevstin. Historia de la Fvndacién 
y Discvrso de la Provincia, de Santiago de México, de la 
Orden de Predicadores Por las vidas de sus varones insignes 
y casos Notables de Nueua Espafia, Por el Maestro Fray 
Avgvstin Davila Padilla. Al Principe de Espafia, Don 
Felipe nuestro Sefior. Edicié6n Segvnda. En Brvsselas. 
En casa de Ivan de Meerbeque, MDCXXYV. 

Dunn, Winu1AM Epwarp. “Letter from Joseph Baily, Decem- 
ber 12, 1672.’’In South Carolina Historical and Genealogical 
Magazine, Vol. XVIII, Charleston, 1917. 

Dunn, Witut1am Epwarp. Spanish and French Rivalry in the 
Gulf Region of the United States, 1678-1702: the Beginnings 
of Texas and Pensacola. Austin, 1917. 

Eemont, First Eart or. Manuscripts of the Earl of Egmont, 
Diary of the First Earl of Egmont (Viscount Percival). 
Historical Manuscripts Commission. 3 vols. London, 
1920-1923. 

Eemont, First Eartor. Journal of the Earl of Egmont. First 
President of the Board of Trustees, from June 14, 1738, to 
May 25, 1744. In The Colonial Records of Georgia, Vol. V, 
Atlanta, 1908. 

ENGELHARDT, FR. ZeEpHYRIN, O. F. M. ‘‘Missionary Labors of 
the Franciscans Among the Indians of the Early Days 
(Florida). ’’In The Franciscan Herald, Vols. I-II, Chicago, 
1913-1914. 

FarrBanxs, Grorce R. History of Florida from its Discovery 
by Ponce de Leén, in 1512, to the close of the Florida War, 
in 1842. Philadelphia and Jacksonville, 1871. 

Force, Perer (editor). Tracts and Other Papers, Relating 
Principally to the Origin, Settlement and Progress of the 
Colonies in North America, from the Discovery of the 
Country to the Year 1776. Collected by Peter Force. 4 
vols. Washington, 1836, 1838, 1844, 1846. 


BIBLIOGRAPHY By. 


Forp, Wortnineron CHauncey (compiler). List of the 
Vernon-Wager Manuscripts in the Library of Congress. 
Washington, 1904. 

GaFFarEL, Pau. Histoire de la Floride Francaise. Paris, 
1875. 

Garcia, Genaro (editor). Dos Antiguas Relaciones de la 
Florida. Mexico, 1902. 

GENTLEMAN’S MAGAZINE AND Historical Curonictes. Edited 
by Sylvanus Urban, Gentleman. 253 vols. London, 1731- 
1883. 

Groreia. The Colonial Records of the State of Georgia. 
Atlanta, 1904-. (Abbreviated in the footnotes as Ga. Col. 
Rec). 

Groreaia Hisroricat Socrry. Collections of the Georgia 
Historical Society. 9vols. Savannah, 1840-1916. 

Great Brirarn: HisroricaL Manuscripts Commission. Four- 
teenth Report, Appendix, Part IX. The Manuscripts of the 
Ear! of Buckinghamshire, The Earl of Lindsey, The Earl of 
Onslow, Lord Emly, Theodore J. Hare, Esq., and James 
Round, Esq.,M.P. Presented to both Houses of Parliament 
by Command of Her Majesty. London, 1895. See Hare 
and Trevor. 

Great Brirain: PARLIAMENT. Papers Relative to the Rupture 
with Spain, Laid Before Both Houses of Parliament on 
Friday the Twenty-ninth Day of January, 1762, by His 
Majesty’s Command. London, 1762. 

Great Brirain: ParLiAMENT. Cobbett’s Parliamentary His- 
tory of England. From the Norman Conquest, in 1066, to 
the Year 1803. From which Last-Mentioned Epoch it is 
Continued Downwards in the Work Entitled ‘‘Cobbett’s 
Parliamentary Debates,”’ etc. London, 1806-1924. 

Great Brrrain: Privy Counciu. Acts of the Privy Council of 
England. Colonial Series, 1613-1783. 6 vols. Hereford, 
1908-1912. 

Great Brirain: Pusuic Recorp Orrice. Calendar of State 
Papers, Colonial Series, America and the West Indies. 
1574-1709. 20 vols. London, 1860-1922. 


118 BIBLIOGRAPHY 


Greenuow, Rozserr. The History of Florida, Louisiana, 
Texas, and California, and of the Adjoining Countries, 
including the whole Valley of the Mississippi. From the 
Discovery to their Incorporation with the United States of 
America. New York, 1856. 

HapersHaM, Hon. James. The Letters of Hon. James Haber- 
sham, 1756-1775. In Collections of the Georgia Historical 
Society, Vol. VI. Savannah, 1904. 

Hare, THeopore J. Manuscripts of Theodore J. Hare, Stine 
of Borden Wood, Hants. In the Fourteenth Report, Ap- 
pendix, Part IX of Historical Manuscripts Commission. 
London, 1895. ° 

Harine, Cuarence Henry. The Buccaneers in the West Indies 
in the XVII Century. New York, 1910. 

Harris, F. R. . Life of Edward Montagu, First Earl of Sand- 
wich, 1625-1672. 2 vols. London, 1912. ° 

Harris, Jonn. Navigantium atque Itinerantium Bibliotheca. 
Or, A Complete Collection of Voyages and Travels. Con- 
sisting of above Six hundred of the most Authentic Writers. 
2 vols. London, 1744-1748. 

Hart, Francis Russety. Admirals of the Caribbean. Boston, 
1922: 

Hertster, Lewis, sa. A Complete Collection of the Treaties 
and Conventions, and Reciprocal Regulations, at present 
subsisting between Great Britain and Foreign Powers, and 
of the Laws, Decrees, and Orders in Council, concerning 
the same; so far as They Relate to Commerce and Naviga- 
tion; to the Repression and Abolition of the Slave Trade; 
and to the Privileges and Interests of the Subjects of the 
High Contracting Parties. 4 vols. London, 1840. 

Hertz, GERALD BERKELEY. British Imperialism in the Hight- 
eenth Century. London, 1908. 

Historica, Macazine, and Notes and Queries Concerning the 
Antiquities, History and Biography of America. 23 vols. 
Boston, 1857-1875. 

Hoper, Frepertck W., and Lewis, Tueopore H. (editors). 
Spanish Explorers in the Southern United States, 1528-1543. 
New York, 1907. 


BIBLIOGRAPHY 119 


JAMESON, JOHN FRANKLIN. Privateering and Piracy in the 
Colonial Period: Illustrative Documents. Edited Under 
the Auspices of the National Society of the Colonial Dames 
of America. New York, 1923. 

Jounson, JAMES Guyton. “The Spanish Period of Georgia 
and South Carolina, 1566-1702.’’ In Bulletin of the Univer- 
sity of Georgia. Athens, 1923. 

JOHNSON, JAMES Guyton. ‘The Yamassee Revolt of 1597 and 
the Destruction of the Georgia Missions.’? In Georgia 
Historical Quarterly, Vol. VII. Savannah, 1923. 

Jones, Cares C., Jk. The Dead Towns of Georgia. Savan- 
nah, 1878. 

Jones, Cuartes C., Jr. The History of Georgia. 2 vols. 
Boston, 1883. 

Laueuron, J. K. “Jenkins’ Ear.’”’ In English Historical 
Review, Vol. IV. London, 1889. 

Les, Cuartes, Attorney General of the United States (com- 

_piler). A Report of the Attorney General to Congress; 
Containing a Collection of Charters, Treaties, and Other 
Documents, Relative to and Explanatory of the Title to 
the Land Situate in the South Western Parts of the United 
States; and Claimed by Certain Companies Under a Law 
of the State of Georgia, Passed January 7, 1795. Printed 
by order of the Senate of the United States. Philadelphia, 
1796. ; 

Lescarsot, Marc. Histoire de Novvelle-France. Paris, 1611. 


Lowery, Woopsury. The Spanish Settlements Within the 
Present Limits of the United States, 1513-1561. New 
York, 1911. 

Lowery, Woopsury. The Spanish Settlements Within the 
Present Limits of the United States. Florida, 1562-1574. 
New York, 1911. 

M’Caz, Carrarn Huew. The History of Georgia, Containing 
Brief Sketches of the Most Remarkable Events up to the 
Present Day (1784). Atlanta, 1909. 


120 BIBLIOGRAPHY 


McCrapy, Epwarp. The History of South Carolina under the 
Proprietary Government, 1670-1719. New York, 1897. 


McCrapy, Epwarp. The History of South Carolina under the 
Royal Government, 1719-1776. New York, 1899. 


McCrapy, Epwarp. The History of South Carolina in the 
Revolution, 1775-1780. New York, 1902. 

MacDonatp, Wiiu1aM (editor). Select Charters and other 
Documents illustrative of American History, 1606-1773. 
New York, 1906. 

Marery, Prerre (editor). Découvertes et Etablissements des 
Francais dans L’Ouest et Dans le Sud de L’Amérique 
Septentrionale (1614-1754). Mémoires et Documents Orig- 
inaux recueillis et Publiés Par Pierre Margry. Paris, 
M Dece Lxxxi. 

Mereness, Newton D. (editor). Travels in the American 
Colonies. Edited Under the Auspices of the National 
Society of the Colonial Dames of America. New York, 
1916. 

Montiano, Don Manvst pz. Letters addressed to Don Juan 
Francisco de Guemes y Horcasitas, Governor General of 
Cuba. Translation in Collections of the Georgia Historical 
Society, Vol. VII, Part I. Savannah, 1909. 

Mortury, Joun. Walpole. London, 1909. 

Norra Caroutina. The Colonial Records of North Carolina 
Published Under the Supervision of the Trustees of the 
Public Libraries, by Order of the General Assembly; Col- 
lected and Edited by William L. Saunders, Secretary of 
State. Raleigh, 1886-90. 

Oscoop, HerpertL. The American Colonies in the Eighteenth 
Century. 3 vols. New York, 1924. 

PaRKMAN, Francis, Pioneers of France in the New World. 
Boston, 1880. 

Puiiurrs, Puinie Ler (editor). The Lowery Collection. A 
Descriptive List of Maps of the Spanish Possessions Within 
the Present Limits of the United States, 1502-1820. By 
Woodbury Lowery. Washington, 1912. 


BIBLIOGRAPHY 121 


Rivers, Witu1am J. A Sketch of the History of South Carolina 
to the Close of the Proprietary Government by the Revolu- 
tion of 1719. With an Appendix Containing Many Valuable 
Records Hitherto Unpublished. Charleston, 1856. 


Ross, Mary. ‘French Intrusions and Indian Uprisings in 
Georgia and South Carolina, 1577-1580.’’ In Georgia 
Historical Quarterly, Vol. VII. Savannah, 1923. 


Ross, Mary. ‘The French on the Savannah, 1605.’’ In 
Georgia Historical Quarterly, Vol. VIII. Savannah, 1924. 


Rorpfaz y Caravia, Eveento. La Florida su Conquista y 
Colonizacién por Pedro Menéndez de Avilés. 2 vols. 
Madrid, 1893. See Connor. 


Russet, Lorp Joun (editor). Correspondence of John, Fourth 
Duke of Bedford: Selected from the Originals at Woburn 
Abbey, with an Introduction. 3 vols. London, 1842, 1843, 
1846. 

SaLuey, ALEXANDER SAMUEL (editor). Journal of the Commons 
House of Assembly of South Carolina for the Session Begin- 
ning September 20, 1692, and Ending October 15, 1692. 
Columbia, 1907. 

SaLLey, ALEXANDER SaMueEL (editor). Journals of the Com- 
mons House of Assembly of South Carolina for the Four 
Sessions of 1693. Columbia, 1907. 


Sanuey, ALEXANDER Samuew (editor). Journal of the Com- 
mons House of Assembly of South Carolina, for the Session 
Beginning January 30, 1696, and Ending March 17, 1696. 
Columbia, 1908. 

SautEy, ALEXANDER SaMvEL (editor). Journal of the Grand 
Council of South Carolina, August 25, 1671-June 24, 1680; 
April 11, 1690-September 26, 1692. 2vols. Columbia, 1907. 

Scuoéne, Lucien. La Politique Coloniale Sous Louis XV et 
Louis XVI. Paris, 1907. 

Serrano y Sanz, Manuet (editor). Documentos Histéricos 
de La Florida y La Luisiana. Siglos XVI al XVIII. Biblio- 
teca de los Americanistas. Madrid, 1912. 


122 BIBLIOGRAPHY 


SuarresBuRy, Lorp. The Shaftesbury Papers and Other 
Records Relating to Carolina and the First Settlement on 
Ashley River Prior to the Year 1676. Published by the 
South Carolina Historical Society. Prepared for Publica- 
tion by Langdon Cheves, Esq. In Collections of the South 
Carolina Historical Society, Vol. V. Charleston, 1897. 


Sura, Jonn Guary. History of the Catholic Church in the 
United States. 4 vols. New York, 1886-1892. 


SHEPHERD, Wiuuiam R. ‘The Cession of Louisiana to Spain.’’ 
In Political Science Quarterly, September, 1904. Vol. XIX. 
New York, 1904. 


Smms, Wimu1am Gitmore. The Yamassee: A Romance of 
Carolina. Chicago, 1890. 


SMITH, Wituam Roy. South Carolina as a Royal Province, 
1719-1776. New York, 1903. 

Smo.tierr, ToprAs GeorcEe. Adventures of Roderick Random. 
London, n. d. 


Smotierr, Tosras Grorcr, M.D. The History of England, 
from the Revolution in 1688 to the Death of George II. 
Designed as a Continuation of Hume. 6 vols. London, 
1810, 1811. 


Sotfs p—E Mmrds, Docror Gonzato. Memorial que hizo el 
Doctor Gonzalo Solis de Merds, de todas las jornadas y 
sucesos del Adelantado Pedro Menéndez de Avilés, su 
cufiado, y de la Conquista de la Florida y Justicia que hizo 
en Juan Ribao y otros franceses. In Ruidiaz, op. cit. 


Sours Carorina Hisroricat Socrery. Collections of the South 
Carolina Historical Society. 5 vols. Charleston, 1857- 
1897. 


SoutH Caromina HisroricAL AND GENEALOGICAL MAGAZINE. 
Charleston, 1900-. 


Srevens, Rev. Witu1am Bacon, M.D. A History of Georgia 
from its First Discovery by Europeans to the Adoption of 
the present Constitution in MDCCXCVIII. 2 vols. New 
York, 1847. 


BIBLIOGRAPHY 123 


Storer, Matcorm. ‘Admiral Vernon Medals, 1739-1742.” 
In Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society, 
October, 1918—June, 1919. Boston, 1919. 

~ Swanton, Joun R. Early History of the Creek Indians and 
Their Neighbors. In the Bureau of American Ethnology, 
Bulletin 73, Smithsonian Institution. Washington, 1922. 

Tempertey, Harotp W. V. ‘The. Causes of the War of 
Jenkins’ Ear, 1739." In Transactions of the Royal His- 
torical Society. Third Series, Vol. III. London, 1909. 

TEMPERLEY, Harotp W. V. “The Relations of England with 
Spanish-America, 1720-1744.’ In Annual Report of the 
American Historical Association for the year 1911. Vol. I. 
Washington, 1913. 

TorQUEMADA, JUAN DE. Primera [segunda, tercera] parte de 
los veinte i vn libros rituales i monarchfa indiana, con el 

_origen y guerras, de los Indios Ocidentales, de sus poblagones 
descubrimiento, conquista, conuersion y otras cosas maraui- 
llosas de la mesma tierra. Por F. Juan de Torquemada. 
Madrid, 1723. Ed. by Gonzdlez de’ Barcia Carbillido y 
Zuniga. 

Trevor Manuscripts. See Buckinghamshire. 

Untrep Srates. Sixtieth Congress, First Session, 1907+1908. 
Senate Document Number 467. Boundary Line Between 
Florida and Georgia. Certain Documents, and Reports 
Relating to the Locating and Marking of the Line Between 
the Territory and State of Florida and the State of Georgia. 
Presented by Mr. Bacon. Washington, 1908. 

[VeRNoN, Epwarp]. An Account of the Expedition to Cartha- 
gena, with Explanatory Notes and Observations. Printed 
for M. Cooper. London, 1743. 

[VeRNON, Epwarp]. Original Papers Relating to the Expedi- 
tion to Carthagena. Printed for M. Cooper. London, 1744. 

[VeRNON, Epwarp]. Original Papers Relating to the Expedi- 
tion to the Island of Cuba. Printed for M. Cooper. Lon- 
don, 1744. ' 

[Vernon, Epwarp]. Original Papers Relating to the Expedi- 
tion to Panama. Printed for M. Cooper. London, 1744. 


124 BIBLIOGRAPHY 


Westey, Rev. Joun. The Journal of the Rev. John Wesley, 
A.M. Enlarged from Original Manuscripts, with Notes 
from Unpublished Diaries. Edited by Nehemiah Curnock. 
8 vols. London, 1909-1916. See Curnock. 

Winsor, Justin. Narrative and Critical History of America, 
Edited by Justin Winsor. 8 vols. Boston and New York, 
1884-1889. 

Wricut, Irene A. “Spanish Policy toward Virginia.” In 
American Historical Review, Vol. XXV. Washington, 1920. 

Wricut, Ropert. A Memoir of General James Oglethorpe, 
One of the Earliest Reformers of Prison Discipline in Eng- 
land, and the Founder of Georgia, in America. London, 
1867. 

Yorke, Pamir C. The Life and Correspondence of Philip 
Yorke, Earl of Hardwicke, Lord High Chancellor of Great 
Britain. 3 vols. Cambridge, 1913. 


INDEX 


INDEX 


Achito, English expedition from, 58. 

Afuica mission, destroyed, 40. - ; 

Agramont (Abraham), buccaneer, raids Guale coast, 39, 41. 

Aix-la-Chapelle, treaty of, 99. ; 

Alabama Indians, English among,.57; rivalry for control, 62. 

Albuquerque, N. M., included in Carolina grant, 71. 

Alexander, Ephraim, trading posts, 102, 103, 104. - 

Altamaha River, Guale frontier, 4; forts on, 4, 69; boundary of 
oe grant, 72; Oglethorpe passes, 72; incorrect map of, 


Altamaha, Yamassee Chief, raids Timucua mission, 40. 

Angulo, Fabidn de, commander. at Apalachicola, 53. 

Antonio, Captain, Englishman among Apalachicolas, 58.. 

Apalache (Tallahassee) settlement, missions founded, 25-27; 
base for westward advance, 45; expeditions up Chattahoo- 
chee River, 49; English and Indian raids on, 58-62; missions 
destroyed by Carolinians, 60. ‘ 5 

Apalache Indians, ask for missions, 26; serve at Apalachicola 
garrison, 53; defeated at Flint (Pedernales) River, 59; 
moved to Savannah border, 62; reassembled at San Marcos, 


67. 

Apalachicola, district, 2, 4, 45-68, 83. 

Apalachicola garrison, 53; abandoned, 56. ' 

Apalachicola Indians (Confederacy), 2, 3; Spaniards visit, 25; 
mission founded for, 46, 48; English among, 45-68; Matheos 
visits, 49-54; towns burned, 54; location in 1685, 49; move 
to Ocmulgee, 54-56, 62; become known as Uchis or Creeks, 
54; make war on Spaniards and Apalaches, 56; return to the 
Chattahoochee, 63; expel English and ally with Spaniards, 
64; new contest for, 65-68; move south, 67, 68; defeat Uriza, 
58; dispute over country, 57. " 4 

Apalachicola village, Pentocolo chief of, 49; Spanish presidio 


at, 53. : 
Archdale, John, Governor of South Carolina, boundary dispute, 
57. 
Argiielles, Capt. Alonso, at Port Royal, 29. 


Arredondo, Antonio, ‘‘Historical Proof,’’ 92; diary, 93; confer- 
ence with Oglethorpe, 73; in Georgia campaign, 94 


128 INDEX 


Asao (St. Simons) I., Fr. Velascola at, 15; massacre, 16; town 
destroyed, 17; mission abandoned, 40. 

Asile (Aucilla), royal farm at, 26. 

Aufion, Fr. Miguel, takes friars to Guale, 15. 

Ayllé6n, Lucas V4squez, takes colony to Carolina, 6 

Ayubale, Apalache mission, destroyed, 60. 

Azilia, colony projected, 69. 

Badajoz, Fr. Antonio, at mission Santa Catalina, 15; killed, 16. 

Bailey, Joseph, captured by Spaniards, 33. 

Baptisms, in Guale, 20. 

Barbados, influence on South Carolina, 28. 

Barnwell, Joseph, at Fort King George, 69. 

Bedford, Duke of, Georgia Trustees appeal to, 99; complains, 
101. 

Benavides Bazdn, Gov. Antonio, plans to capture Charleston, 
70; protests Fort King George, 69 

Bienville, Sieur de, resists English in Alabama country, 63. 

Blake, Joseph, Gov. of 8. C., boundary dispute, 57. 

Bloody Marsh, battle of, 95-96. 

Blythe, L., Carr’s plantation on, 98. 

Boone, Thomas, Gov. of S. C., makes grants south of Altamaha 
River, 109; opposed by Gov. Wright, 109. 

Boundaries, discussed, 57, 68-70, 72-74, 79-81, 99-100, 109. 

Boundary commission, 70-71, Se 74, 79-82. 

Boyano, Hernando, explorations, 10, 16, 24. 

Brimins, Old, Emperor of Caveta, favors English, 64-65. 

Buccaneers, on Gulf of Mexico, 26; raid Guale, 34; destroy Guale 
as 38-39; at Charleston, 48-44; threaten San Agustin, 
5 


Cabrera, Gov. Juan Marqués, defends Guale, 37; moves Guale 
missions, 41; destroys Port Royal, 41-42; attacks Charles- 
ton, 42; "sends expeditions to the Chattahoochee, 47, 53. 

Canary Islanders, ordered sent to Guale, 37. 

Canzo, Gov. Gonzalo Méndez, puts down Guale rebellion, 17; 
plans interior colony, 18. 

Capillos, Fr. Juan de, missionary at San Pedro, 19; first pro- 
vincial of Santa Elena, 20. 

ives ae colony at Port Royal, 37; buys Indian cap- 
tives 

Caribbean Sea, English advance from, 28; commerce of, 77; 
Vernon’s operations in, 85-90. 

Carlos III, enters Family Compact, 107. 

Carolina colony, need of buffer, 69; boundary commission, 79; 
reached by Spaniards, 90; dispute with Georgia, 108-109; 
plots against Guale, 36, 38-40. 


INDEX 129 


Carolina grant, includes Spanish settlements, 28, 69-70; ridi- 
@uled by Wright, 109. . ick 

Carolinians, destroy Tallahassee missions, 4; destroy Guale 
missions, 38-39; push west, 45, 57-58; slain in Yamassee war, 
63. See English. 

Carr, William, captured by Spaniards, 32. 

Cartagena, Vernon’s attack on, 85, 89. 

Casista, burned by Matheos, 51; Oglethorpe visits, 84. 

Caveta (Coweta), town, opposes missionaries, 47, 48; English 
blockhouse at, 51; burned by Matheos, 51; council at, 53, 58; 
fort at, 58; Engiish and Spanish factions at, 65; Oglethorpe 
visits, 84. 

Charleston (Kiawah, San Jorge), founded, 4, 32; fear of Span- 
iards, 32, 34; attacked by Spaniards, 33, 42; plan attack on 
Guale, 34; on San Agustin, 43; plan to capture, 70; boundary 
commission at, 70; Oglethorpe at, 87. 

Chattahoochee River, mission on, 2, 47; fortified, 4; Spanish 
advance toward, 27; Guale Indians flee to, 37; navigated, 
47, 51; Apalachicolas desert, 54-55; return to, 63. 

Chatuache mission, S. C., 21. 

Chesapeake Bay (Santa Marfa), Jesuits at, 11. 

Chickasaws, English among, 57, 62, 83. 

Chipacasi, Creek chief, favors Spaniards, 65-67; goes over to 
English, 67. 

Chislacaliche (Chigilly, Cherokee Leechey), welcomes Ogle- 
thorpe, 84. 

Choctaws, 26, 62; won over by English, 83. 

Chozas, Fr. Pedro Ferndndez, missionary at San Pedro, explores 
interior, 15. 

Colleton, J., Gov. of 8. C., forbids attack on San Agustin, 43. 

Collins, John, captured at Santa Catalina, 33. 

Commerce, with Apalache, 26; difficulties over English, 77-79. 

Commission, on Carolina boundary, 70, 81-82; to remove 
Gray’s Gang, 105. 

Corpa, Fr. Pedro, missionary at Tolomato, 15; killed, 16. 

Cotton, Sir John, proposes to yield Georgia, 91. 

Coweta. See Caveta. 

Crane, V. W., works cited, Preface, 39, 46, 55, 59, 60, 63. 

Creeks, Lower (Apalachicolas), 2; migrate to Ocmulgee, 4, 54- 
56; Spanish expeditions to, 25; ask for missionaries, 46; turn 
against English, 65; Oglethorpe’s treaty with, 83; contest for 
control, 101-102; attack Cherokees, 106. 

Cuba, Bishop of, visits Guale, 19. Es 

Cufitachiqui, pearls of, 24; Woodward visits, 46. 

Cumberland Island, settlements on, 2, 21, 104, 106. 


130 INDEX? 2 A eee 


Datha, giant king, in S. C., 6. 

Davila, Fr. Francisco, missionary on Jekyl I., 15; captured, 16; 
rescued, Ls 

De Leén, Tomés, destroys Port Royal, 41. 

Delgado, Fr. Pedro, at Talaje and Espogache, 19. 

De Luna y Arrellano, Tristan de, Sse oe to ‘Alabama 
country, 6. 

Dempsey, Charles, diplomatic mission, 73. 

De Soto, Hernando, in Georgia country, 6. 

Diamond Mountain, tales of, 16, 24. 

Diplomatic controversies over Georgia country, 4, 69-76, 101. 
See Boundaries. 

Domingo, Agustin, Br., Jesuit missionary, writes Guale gram- 
mar, 10 : 

Drake, Francis, destroys San Agustin and rescues Roanoke © 

colony, 3, 15. 

Hast Florida, formed by England, 109. 

Edisto I., De Leén attacks, 42. 

Egmont, Earl of, Georgia Trustee, 80, 91. ‘ 

Ellis, Henry, Gov. of Georgia, relations with Gray’s Gang, 103- 
106; reprimanded by Board of Trade, 104-5. ‘ 

England, conciliatory toward Spain, 100. 

English, encroach on Guale, 3, 28; at Jamestown, 19; stimulate 
Spanish activity, 20; in Carolina back country, 23-24; 
pirates, 26; Indian traders, 26, 48; among Apalachicolas 
48, 54, 62; Killed by Guale Indians, 52: among Alabamas anil 
Chickasaws, 57, 63; plan. to destroy Florida, .58; defeat 
Uriza, 58; killed at Apalache, 61; attack Pensacola, 63; 
expelled by Apalachicolas, 64; by Falapoosas, 66; dominate 
Upper Creeks, 68; defeated by Montiano, 88. : 

Ensenada, Spanish minister, hostile to English, 101. 

Epidemics, in Guale, 20. 

Espogache, massacre of Spaniards, 12; Fr. Pedro Delgado at, 19. 

Hstrozi, Nicolas, French corsair, captured, 12-13. 

Explorations, Spanish, in Georgia back country, 4, 24-25. 

Family Compact, renewed, 107. 

Fernandez, Juan, mission to Creeks, 66. 

Fitch, Tobias, mission to Creeks, 67-68; organizes war-on 
Yamassees, 67; wins Chipacasi over, 67. 

Florida, defenses strengthened, 34-35; invaded by English, .86- 
88; taken by England, 108. 

Fontainebleau, treaty of, promises to restore Georgia to ra 

Fort Caroline, built, 7. 


INDEX 131 


Fort King George, on the Altamaha, 67-71; a buffer against 
Florida, 4 

Fort St. George, abandoned, 74. 

Fort William, 98. 

France, agrees to restore Georgia to Spain, 98. 

Franciscans, in Guale, 13-14, 18, 20; at Sdbacola, 46-48; erect 
Province of Santa Elena, 20. : 

Frederica, founded, 72; Montiano’s plan to capture, 94. 

French, corsairs, 3, 12, 13, 18, 26; colonies on Atlantic coast, 7; 
at Biloxi and Mobile, 62; contest with English in Alabama 
country, 62-63. ; 

Fuentes, Capt. Francisco, defends Santa Catalina, 36. 

Georgia (English colony), founded, 71; raided by Spaniards, 90; 
protested by Spain, 91-92; Cotton proposes to yield, 91; 
Montiano’s campaign against, 93-97; France promises to 
recover for Spain, 99; regiment disbanded, 99; settlers fear 
Spaniards, 101; territory enlarged, 109; diplomatic dispute 
over, 69-76. : 

Georgia, region, Anglo-Spanish contest for, 1-5; Spanish settle- 
ments in, 1, 6-27; missions on southern border, 25. See Guale. 

Geraldino, Tomds, diplomatic protests against Oglethorpe’s 
colony, 72, 81. ' 

Gil, French corsair, kiiled, 12-13. 

Goldsmith, Oliver, pictures Georgia in ‘‘Deserted Village,’’ 97. 

Gray, Edmund, settles New Hanover, 102-106; settles on Cum- 
berland Island, 106. 

“Gray’s Gang.”’ See Gray. 

Grimaldi, Marqués de, resist English conquest, 107-108. 

Guale (the Georgia coast country), 1; Spanish settlements in, 
1-27; Anglo-Spanish contest for, 3-4, 28-44; Menéndez de 
Avilés in, 9; Indian revolts in, 11, 12, 16; Jesuits in, 10-11; 
towns destroyed, 17; Spanish authority restored, 17-18; 
visited by Bishop of Cuba, 19; list of missions, 21; Indians 
work at San Agustin, 35; Indian and English raids on, 38-39; 
missions removed south, 39-41; last missions destroyed, 60. 

Guale (St. Catherines) Island, mission on, 14. See Santa 
Catalina. ; 

Gualquini, English raid at, 39; Spanish fleet enters, 94. 

Giiemes y Horcasitas, Juan Fernando de, captain-general of 
Havana, sends Arredondo to Georgia, 73; aids Montiano, 
87; organizes campaign against Georgia and South Caro- 
lina, 93. 

Guerra, Governor Francisco, sends expedition against Charles- 
ton, 33-34. in 

Gutiérrez, Father Francisco, missionary at Sdbacola, 47-48. 

Haddock, Admiral Nicholas, sent to Mediterranean, 78, 82. 


132 INDEX 


Havana, trade with, 26; prepares to attack Georgia, 76, 93; 
English desire to capture, 85, 89; restored to England, 107. 

Henry N. See Woodward. 

Heron, Col. Alexander, plantation south of Altamaha, 98. 

Hilton, William, relations with Argiielles at Port Royal, 29. 

Hinckley (‘‘Jingle’’), English pirate, 39. 

Ibarra, Governor Pedro, visits Guale, 18. 

Indians, uprising in Guale and Orista, 11-12; uprising in Guale, 
16, 23; aid in attack on Charleston, 33; work at San Agustin, 
35; slaves, 36, 45, 57, 62; a pawn between Europeans, 45; 
Indian trade, 26, 45. See Apalache, Apalachicola, Creeks, 
Missions, Yamassees. 

Inland Passage, used by Spaniards, 2, 3, 12, 17, 18, 94. 

Jamaica, Vernon at, 86, 90. 

Jamestown, alarms Spaniards, 19, 23; advance westward from, 
23-25. 

Jekyl Island (Ospo), English fort on, 98. 

Jenkins’ Har, War of, causes (Georgia question, Commerce), 5, 
69-82; Jenkins’ story, 78; events of, 83-97; aimed at Carib- 
bean and Florida, 85; Georgia’s part in, 83-88, 90-92, 94-97; 
Montiano’s campaign, 94-97; peace proposals, 99-100. 

Jesuits, in Guale, 10-11; replaced by Franciscans, 13. 

Juan, Chief, heads revolt at Tolomato, 16. 

Keene, Benjamin, commissioner in Spain, 81. 

Kiawah (Charleston), founded, 32. 

Lara, Juan de, interior exploration, 18. 

Laudonniére, René, colony in Florida, 7. 

Lépez, Fr. Baltasar, missionary at San Pedro, 14. 

Lords Proprietors of Carolina, grant to, 28; criticise Caro- 
linians, 44. 

Louisiana, rejected by England, ceded to Spain, 108. 

Lucas, Don, Guale Indian, hanged, 17-18. 

Luna, Fr. Pedro de, discussion with Quiroga, 55. 

Malachee, Lower Creek chief, weleomes Oglethorpe, 84. 

Marqués, Francisco Menéndez, on boundary commission, 70. 

Marqués, Juan Menéndez, leads attack on Charleston, 33-34. 

Marqués, Pedro Menéndez, governor of Florida, 12-13; puts 
down rebellion, 12; punishes corsairs, 12; services of, 12-13. 

Massacre, of officials in Guale, 12. 

Matheos, Lt. Antonio, commander at Apalache, expeditions to 
capture Woodward, and to punish Apalachicolas, 49-52; 
destroys English stockade, 50; confiscates furs, 51; holds 
council at Caveta, 51; burns Caveta, Casista, Tasquique, 
and Colone, 51. 


INDEX 133 


Menéndez, Pedro, ‘“‘The Crosseyed,” killed in Guale, 12. 

Menéndez de Avilés, Adelantado Pedro, founds Florida, 8, 
exterminates French colony, 8; in Guale and Santa Elena, 8; 
brings Jesuits, 10; leaves America, 11. 

Mexia, Lt. Juan Rufz, defeated by Moore, 61. 

Mexico City, Creek chiefs visit, 64. 

Middleton, Arthur, President of Council of 8. C., conference on 
boundary, 71. 

Mines, rumors of, 24, 45. 

Miranda, Father Angel, burned at stake at Apalache, 61. 

Missionaries, in Guale, 1; inland journeys, 2; labors of, 21-22. 
See the names of individual missionaries. 

Missions, on Georgia coast, 14; hold the frontier, 20; lack of 
funds, 21; records, 22; Indian complaints, 23; at Apalache, 
destroyed, 61. See names of individual missions. 

Mobile, French at, 58, 60; English aim to destroy, 62. 

Montgomery, Sir Robert, Azilia scheme, 69. 

Montiano, Gov. Manuel, resist Oglethorpe’s attack, 87-88; 
defeats English at Moosa, 88; campaign against Georgia, 93- 
96; captures St. Simons, 95; defeat at Bloody Marsh, 95-96. 

Moore, James, Goy. of South Carolina, deals in Indian slaves, 
57; expedition against San Agustin, 59; destroys Guale 
missions, 60; destroys Apalache missions, 60-62; harsh treat- 
ment of prisoners, 61; carries away Indian captives, 61-62. 

Moosa, Fort, captured by Oglethorpe, 87. 

Morton, Joseph, Goy. of S. C., plantation sacked, 42. 

Musgrove, John, Carolina trader, at Caveta, 66; trading post at 
Savannah, 72. 

Neutral Ground, 5; proposed, 81, 98, 107; invaded by Gray’s 
Gang, 101; added to Georgia, 109, 110. 

Newcastle, Duke of, discusses Carolina boundary, 69, 73, 81; 
favors Neutral Ground, 81. 

New Hanover, settlement on Satilla River, 102; expelled, 105; 
opposed by Gov. Wright, 106. 

New Mexico, included in Carolina grant, 71, 109. 

New York, threatened by Spanish privateers, 90. 

Nicholson, Francis, Gov. of 8S. C., and the boundary dispute, 
69. 


Niquesalla, killed at Port Royal, 42. 

Ocheese Creek (Ocmulgee River), 54. 

Ocmulgee River, Lower Creeks move to, 4, 62. 
Océn, Fr. Juan, founds Sdébacola mission, 46, 47. 
Ocute, Chozas and Velascola visit, 16. 


134 INDEX 


Oglethorpe, James, 4; founds Georgia colony, 72; claims the 
San Juan as boundary, 73; conference with Arredondo, 73; 
treaty with Sanchez, 74; withdraws from Fort St. George 
(San Juan), 74; return to England, 74; granted more soldiers, 
74-76; return to Georgia, 76, 78; expedition to Coweta, 83- 
85; treaty with Lower Creeks, 85; invades Florida, 86; fail- 
ure at San Agustin, 87-88; plans new drive on Florida, 90-91; . 
defends Frederica, 94-96; promotion, 97; relations with Gold- 
smith and Reynolds, 97; appeals to Bedford, 99. 

“Old Grog,’’ (Admiral Vernon), 85, 88. 

Ore, Fr. Luis, leads mission to Florida, 20. 

Orista (Orizta), Indian province in South Carolina, 10; upris- 
ing at, 11. : 

Ospo (Jekyl) I., Father Ddvila at, 15; uprising at, 16; town 
destroyed, 17. 

Pardo, El, Convention of, 79, 92; failure, 80. 

Pardo, Juan, explores interior, 10. 

Pareja, Father Francisco, linguist, at San Pedro mission, 15. 

Parkman, Francis, condemns Avilés, 8. 

Parris Island, Spaniards on, 21, 30. 

Pearce, Commodore, codperates with Oglethorpe, 87. 

Pedernales (Flint) River, mission on, 48; battle on, 58-59. 

Pefia, Diego de, mission to Coweta, 65; contest with English 
faction, 66. — 

Pensacola, 2, 27; English efforts to destroy, 62-63; Creek- 
Spanish treaty at, 64. 

Pentocolo, chief of Apalachicola town, aids Matheos, 49-50. 

Philip II, decides to end Florida expeditions, 6-7; sends Menén- 
dez to Florida, 8. 

Philip III, fails to destroy Jamestown, 19-20. 

Picolata, Fort, captured by Oglethorpe, 86. 

Pocotaligo, Yamassee uprising at, 63. 

Port Royal, Spaniards at, 1; French colony, 7-8; Hilton finds 
Spaniards there, 29; contest over, 30; Spain claims, 92; 
attack on, 33, 41-48. 

Pozobueno, Jacinto, Spanish diplomat, discusses Carolina 
boundary, 69. 

Presidios, Spanish, on Georgia coast, 1. 

Primo de Rivera, Joseph, builds Apalachicola fort, 53; on 
boundary commission, 70. 

Privateers, English, authorized, 82; Spanish, raid Atlantic 
coast, 90. 

Prizes, taken to San Agustin, 90. 

Puerto Bello, captured by Vernon, 85-86. 

Puerto Rico, desired by England, 108. 


INDEX 135 


Pupo, Fort, captured, 86. 

Queen Anne’s War, 4, 59-63. 

Quiroga y Losada, Diego, governor of Florida, 35; relations 
with Apalachicola, 53; discussion with Father Luna, 55. 

Raleigh, Walter, his Roanoke colony, 24. 

Reynolds, John, Gov., relations with “Gray’s Gang,’ 102; 
refused authority over Neutral Ground, 102. 

Reynolds, Sir Joshua, relations with Oglethorpe, 97. 

Reynoso, Father Alonso, work in Guale, 14. 

Ribaut, Jean, colony in Carolina and Florida, 3, 6-7. 

Rivers, John, captured at Santa Catalina, 32. 

Rodriguez, Father Blas, at Tupique, 15; martyred, 16. 

Rogel, Juan, Jesuit Father, at Orista, 10. 

Rojas, Hernando Manrique, at Guale and Santa Elena, 9. 

Rosario, The, wrecked near Charleston, 42. 

Rubriani, Francisco, heads fleet against Georgia, 93. 

Ruiz, Jesuit Father, in Guale, 10. 

Ruiz, Fray Pedro, at Santa Catalina, 19. 

Sdbacola mission, 2, 4, 47-48; moved down stream, 48. 

St. Johns River. See San Juan River. 

St. Marys River, 9; becomes Georgia boundary, 110. 

St. Simons Island, mission on, 21; to be attacked, 94. See 
Gualquini. 

Salazar, Gov. Pablo, sends aid to Santa Catalina, 36; withdraws 
to Zapala, 37. 

Salinas, Gov. Juan, sends expeditions to interior, 24. 

San Agustin, base for Guale, 2; garrison reduced, 11; missions 
at, 14; Carolina prisoners at, 32-33; sends expedition against 
Charleston, 33; stone castle built, 34-35; alarm at, 59; 
captured by Moore, 60; welcomes Yamassees, 64; Apalachi- 
colas give allegiance at, 65; objective in War of Jenkins’ 
Ear, 85; attacked by Oglethorpe, 88; prizes taken to, 90; 
fleet at, 93; military preparations, 101; founded, 8; burned 
by Drake, 3, 15; included in Carolina grant, 70, 109. 

San Buenaventura mission, 21. 

Sanchez, Gov. Francisco, treaty with Oglethorpe, 73; hanged, 
74 


San Diego, Fort, captured by Oglethorpe, 87. 

Sandford, Robert, at Santa Elena, 29-30. 

San Felipe, mission, 21. 

San Felipe (presidio in South Carolina), 2, 11; Indian revolt at, 
12 


San Jorge. See Charleston. 
San José, mission, on Sapelo Island, 21. 


136 INDEX 


San Juan River (May, St. Johns), French on, 7; Guale extended 
to, 9; battle on, 13; becomes Spain’s frontier, 60; Oglethorpe 
claims as boundary, 73; controlled by Oglethorpe, 86; Spain 
withdraws to, 4. 

San Juan Island, Spanish settlement on, 41; English settle- 
ment (St. George) abandoned, 74. 

San Luis de Apalache (Tallahassee), 25; garrison at, 26; base 
for westward advance, 27. 

San Marcos Bay, port opened, 26; missions and presidio at, 62, 
67; military activities, 101. 

San Mateo, Huguenot settlement at, 7-8. 

San Simén, Island, abandoned, 39. 

Santa Anastasia Island, Oglethorpe’s batteries on, 88. 

Santa Catalina Island (St. Catherines), Avilés visits, 8; Canary 
Islanders for, 37; settlement on, 9 

Santa Catalina mission (Santa Catharina, St. Catherines), 
outpost of Guale, 2, 15; abandoned, 4; Fathers Aufion and 
Badajoz at, 15; massacre at, 16; Fr. Pedro Ruiz at, 19; 
English captured at, 32-33; post at, 9; presidio founded at, 
34; attacked by English and Indians, 35-36; abandoned, 37. 

Santa Catalina de Afuica, mission, destroyed by Yamassees, 
40 


Santa Cruz Island, mission on, 48. 

Santa Cruz de Sdbacola, mission, 48. 

Santa Elena, (Port Royal), outpost for Guale, 2; discovered, 6; 
Avilés at, 9; rebellion at, 12; fort described 12; uprising at, 
12; abandoned, 2, 3, 15; missions restored, 21; threatened by 
English, 28; Hilton, Argtielles, Sandford, and Woodward at, 
30; Woodward’s purchase of, 30. 

Santa Elena, Franciscan Province, 20. 

Santa Fé mission, destroyed, 58. 

Santa Maria Bay (Chesapeake), Jesuits at, 11. 

Santa Maria Island, Spanish settlement on, 41; abandoned, 60. 

Santiago de Cuba, Wentworth’s failure at, 89-90. 

Santo Domingo, mission at Talaje, 21. 

Sapelo Island (Sapala, ZApala), mission on, 21. See Zapala. 

Sassafras, French trade in, 12-13. 

Satilla River, New Hanover settlement on, 102. 

Savannah River, 2; Apalache removed to, 62. 

Savannah, town, founded, 72. 

Sayle, William, governor of South Carolina, sends rescue expe- 
dition to Guale, 32-33. 

Scotch colony at Port Royal, 30; desttoyed by Spaniards, 42. 

Searles, Robert, attack on San Agustin, 31; Woodward’s 
escape with, 31. 

Seepey Coffee (Chipacasi), favors Spanish and French, 65-67. 


INDEX 137 


Segura, Juan Bautista, Jesuit Father, missionary at Axacan, 
Virginia, martyred, 11. 

Seminoles, friendly to Spain, 68. 

Seven Years’ War, Spain enters, 15, 107-108. 

Slaves, Indian, 34, 36. 

Smith, John, 24. 

Smuggling, English, 77. 

Solfs, Alonso, puts down rebellion in Guale, 12. 

South Carolina, English Colony, 28-30; incites Guale Indians, 
36, 39; Spain plans to invade, 93. 

South Carolina region, Spanish pioneers in, 6-27; missions, 21. 

South Sea Company, privileges of, 77; suspended, 82; term- 
inated, 100 

Spain, enters Seven Years’ War, 5; loses Florida, 5; regains 
influence over Apalaches, 63; protests Oglethorpe’s regiment, 
75; plans to re-annex Georgia, 75; military preparations, 75- 
76; suppresses English smuggling, 77; protests English war 
preparations, 78-9; prepares for war, 90, 92; campaign against 
Georgia, 94-96; demands Georgia, 99; conciliatory, 100; 
neutral in French War, 101; opposes New Hanover, 103, 
joins French War, 107; loses Florida, 107. 

Spaniards, defeated on Flint River, 59; captives given up by 
Creeks, 64; alarmed at English advance, 69; settle on Cum- 
berland Island, 104. 

Spanish settlements, included in Carolina grant, 70. 

Stephens, Thomas, criticises Trustees, 91; punished, 91. 

Swanton, Dr. J. R., works cited, 29, 41, 48, 55, 59, 61, 67. 

Talaje, town destroyed, 17; Fr. Pedro Delgado at mission, 19, 
21 


Talapoosa, (Talapus), English expelled from, 66. 

Tallahassee district (See A palache), mission destroyed, 4. 

Tama, friars visit, 15-16, 21; colony projected for, 18. 

Tasquique, town, burned by Matheos, 51. 

Teguale, Fernandez meets Old Brimins at, 66. 

Timucua missions, 25, 35. 

Tolomato, mission, Fr. Corpa at, 15; uprising at, 16; Indian 
town destroyed, 17. 

Torres, Admiral, protects Havana, 89, 92. 

Torres, Governor Laureano de, sends campaign against Apala- 
chicolas, 56; boundary dispute, 57. 

Torres, Pedro de, expedition to interior, 25. 

Traders, Carolina, in back country, 3. 

Treaty of 1670, provisions discussed, 32, 70; Cabrera ordered 
to observe, 37; cited by both England and Spain, 98. 

Treaty of 1748, 100. 

Treaty of 1750, 100. 

Treaty of 1763, 108. 


138 INDEX 


Treaty, Oglethorpe’s with Creeks, 85. Kee 

Trustees of Georgia, fear Convention of E] Pardo, 79; criticised, 
91; fear loss of Georgia, 99. See Georgza. 

Tupique mission, 14; Father Rodriguez at, 15; alarm, 16; town 
destroyed, 18; neophytes abandon, 40. 

Turkeys, wild, from Apalache supply Spanish fleets, 20. 

Uchis (Ocheese) River, English on, 56. See Ocmulgee. 

Uchis, tribe, on the Ocmulgee, 54. 

Upper Creeks, chiefs go to Mexico, 64. ) : 

Vedsee Francisco Romo de, defeated by English and Apalachi- 
colas, 58. 

Vanderdussen, Col. Alexander, commands Carolina troops, 87. 

Vasquez de Ayllén, Lucas. See Ayllén. 

Velascola, Father Francisco, at Asao (St. Simons), 15; explores 
interior, 15; martyred, 16. 

Vernon, Admiral Edward, in War of Jenkins’ Ear, 85-86; medals, 
86; forces, 88; failures of, 88. 

Villafafie, Angel de, expedition, 61. 

Virginia, Raleigh colony, 19, 23. 

Wall, Ricardo, Spanish minister, friendly to England, 101; 
chides Earl of Bristol, 107. oF 

Walpole, Robert, quiets Spain’s fears, 76; declares he will keep 
Georgia, 80; opposes war, 82. 

War of Jenkins’ Har. See Jenkins’ Har. 

Wentworth, Gen. Thomas, failure at Santiago, 89-90. 

Western Georgia country, Anglo-Spanish contest for, 45-69. 

West Florida, formed, 109. 

Westoes, Woodward visits, 46; destroyed by English, 48. 

Woodward, Dr. Henry, with Sandford, 29; at Parris Island, 30; 
given land by the Niquesalla, 30;. goes to San Agustin, 31; 
in Charleston, 32; visits Cufitachiqui, 46; crosses the Savan- 
nah, 46; at Caveta, 48; defies Matheos, 50; ill at Casista, 52; 
carried to Charleston by Indians, 52; English grants to, 30. 

Wright, James, Gov. of Georgia, relations with New Hanover, 
106; disputes Carolina’s claims, 109. 

Yamassees, grammar, 10; won over by Carolinians, 38; flee to 
Carolina, 40; abetted by Carolinians, 44; campaign against, 
ae recess War, 4, 63-64, 69; return to Spanish allegiance, 

Yeamans, Governor John, Carolina Proprietor, 29. 

Yoa, mission, 14. 

Zapala settlement, destroyed, 14; becomes outpost, 4, 37; 
garrison at, 37; ‘‘Old Sugar House,”’ 37; abandoned, 39. See 
Sapelo. 

Zuftiga, Joseph de, Governor, sends Uriza against Apalachi- 
colas, 58; defends San Agustin, 59. 


7 


Kaaliche aa/ . 
Great Oukiuskress ‘ 


% 


ao AMOTSFORY } 
French? it 
ci hhauokly Wharche 


nf Sab ew 


P Ra charines Sound 


| $narnin ff \0colas in the Nation | cree f ; 
iF ‘ f alloke pity aN i nak WtharinesT. 
: ‘ t f é Alavhfoukoly ’ irom.» CHE ae 
§ r } t | \) Sapetia 
| ? De 2S) Sinaous Sound [ 
Ey | - ls 
|: ONL Nate TAN T Tc 
, id = > 5 , ee\) Ape 7 
| Sar oy — ee Pr = f 
‘ "A ; : » Indians : in Pe is 
| ay ‘ f ede, 
tf D ( PA k ! t wbuty rich the Cnghith2 3 Cunt 
‘ , ¢ 4 2 
Whi aa dadinche destroy in ae et ae Ea gj Fort William 
NZ] « 4705 ty the Grek Indiana + * He cs ‘ aH metia Sound 
= 2? Web 5 =) nN , 
+ - ra » 6 t i! fom ¢ ¥ t Amelia | 
ce ‘ t 5 ! 
Sa fe He fi e t >' 
a | ? 
eh, = 
5 \ BR’ fi. , hie 
apr , hom ay Ke ' é A z BE A 
: ZS lea RaKa Chions t t ay 
oi 
Jf . Yralache j z 
. Z a 
ye S! Blaife t eo S"Femeifea 
BZ Mond from SMa rhe 
Tide EB ‘ip ae hi 
. drnidow PN < E . = t 
C , 
Fill. 7) own 
Y hari Oe 
‘a WAMU. 


Bowen’s map of the Georgia country, 1748. 


From Harris, Voyages and Travels, 


ViOlle WAL. 


} 


CORUAIS 3 aE oh 
se 


«> 
mer ks 


ae 


€ 


ar 
ee 


a | 4 
“ oe 


AAT AH 
eR: | 


| A fe Te fi oe eet 
VET} (ORAWN